(October 2019)
This is a repository of articles and analyses relating to earlier editions of this coverage form.
Related Article: CA 00 25–Auto Dealers Coverage Form Analysis
Archive Index |
|
Analysis |
|
Analysis |
|
Analysis |
|
Endorsements |
ISO Garage Coverage Form Available Endorsements And Their Uses |
Comparison |
|
Comparison |
Compare: CA 00 01–Business Auto Coverage Form To CA 00 05–Garage Coverage Form |
Comparison |
Compare: CA 00 01–Business Auto Coverage Form To CA 00 05–Garage Coverage Form Knowledge Tester Quiz |
Comparison |
Compare: CA 00 05–Garage Coverage Form 03 10 Edition To The 03 06 Edition |
Comparison |
Compare: CA 00 05–Garage Coverage Form 03 10 Edition To The 03 06 Edition Knowledge Tester Quiz |
Comparison |
|
Comparison |
|
Comparison |
|
Comparison |
Comparison Of The 02/99 Multistate Garage Policy To The 07/97 Edition |
Comparison |
Comparison Of The 02/99 Multistate Garage Policy To The 07/97 Edition Knowledge Tester Quiz |
Declarations |
|
Special Analysis |
Vehicle dealerships are unique because the lines between their general liability and automobile liability exposures blur and overlap in many areas. To address this, the Insurance Services Office (ISO) developed CA 00 05–Garage Coverage Form. It covers both exposures under a single coverage form while eliminating coverage gaps and overlaps. It covers premises liability, products liability, automobile liability, and physical damage to covered autos, as well as garagekeepers coverage for customer's autos. A number of endorsements are available to broaden or restrict coverage.
This analysis is based
the 03/10 edition of this coverage form. Changes from the previous edition
are in bold print.
CA 00 05 opens by defining the terms you or your as the named insured and we, us and our as the insurance company providing the coverage. Named insured is not defined. As a result, it means only the entities on the declarations.
Numerical symbols are used to determine the autos insured and the coverages provided. These symbols are defined in the Description Of Covered Auto Designation Symbols.
The sample Garage Declarations has spaces to insert the symbol or symbols next to each business auto coverage. The only coverages provided are those having a symbol or symbols indicated and only those autos designated by the symbol or symbols are covered autos for that coverage.
A. Description Of
Covered Auto Designation Symbols
21–Any Auto
This is the broadest symbol designation and has no limitations or restrictions. Vehicles defined as autos in this coverage form are covered, subject to certain exclusions and conditions. Because of the broad scope of the coverage provided, many insurance companies are reluctant to use this symbol. Even if a company uses it for liability, it may not do so for physical damage. No other symbol should appear in the same box when Symbol 21 is used.
Note: Section VI–Definitions defines auto as a land motor vehicle, trailer or semitrailer.
22–Owned Autos Only
This symbol means that any auto the named insured owns is covered, including those it acquires after the inception date. In addition, any owned or non-owned trailer pulled by an owned vehicle is covered if this symbol is used with liability coverage.
Note: The definition of trailer includes semitrailers. See Section VI–Definitions.
23–Owned Private Passenger Autos Only
All private passenger type autos that the named insured owns are covered when this symbol is used. This includes any private passenger type vehicle it acquires after the inception date.
24–Owned Autos Other Than Private Passenger Autos Only
This symbol means that all autos other than private passenger types that the named insured owns are covered, as well as those it acquires after the inception date. Similar to Symbol 22 above, the liability coverage provided is extended to any owned or non-owned trailer pulled by this type of owned vehicle.
Example: Paula's Pre-Owned Autos is insured under CA 00 05–Garage Coverage Form. Paula's sells and services autos. A new mechanic takes a one-ton stake truck, visits several junkyards, and purchases some used parts and equipment. By the time he gets to the last one, the truck is already loaded but this is where he needs to pick up an engine block needed that day. The junkyard owner loads the engine block on one of his trailers and attaches it to Paula's truck. Because the trailer is attached to the truck, Paula's Garage Coverage Form's liability coverage applies to it. |
25–Owned Autos Subject To No-Fault
This symbol applies to vehicles licensed or garaged in a state where no fault coverage is available but only to autos required to have such coverage. Coverage also extends to such autos acquired after the inception date.
26–Owned Autos Subject To A Compulsory Uninsured Motorists Law
This symbol applies to any auto the named insured owns garaged or licensed in a state that requires the named insured to carry uninsured motorists coverage. It also applies to any auto it acquires after the inception date.
Note: This symbol does not apply to vehicles licensed or operated in states that allow the named insured to formally reject uninsured motorists coverage.
27–Specifically Described Autos
Only autos specifically scheduled that have a premium charge are covered. Similar to Symbol 22 above, the liability coverage provided extends to any owned or non-owned trailer pulled by this type of owned vehicle.
28–Hired Autos Only
This symbol covers autos the named insured leases, hires, rents or borrows but it has a significant limitation. It does not include leased, hired, rented, or borrowed vehicles owned by an employee, partner, LLC member, or by members of any of the preceding groups’ households.
29–Non-Owned Autos Used In Your Garage Business
This symbol applies only to autos the named insured uses in its business that it does not own, lease, hire, rent or borrow. Autos owned by employees, partners in the case of a partnership, members in the case of limited liability companies, or members of the preceding group’s households are included. Covered status exists only while those non-owned autos are used in the named insured’s garage business.
Example: Paul recently started his job at The Friendly Garage, was learning the ropes, and cheerfully agreed to his boss' request to make a run to the deli for lunch. The boss and eight other employees wrote down their orders, Paul called the order in, and then headed out to pick them up. While driving back, a drink lid popped off and he bent over to readjust it. At that exact moment, the car in front of him stopped and Paul rammed it, setting off a chain reaction that eventually damaged six vehicles. The drivers brought claims against Paul and The Friendly Garage upon learning that Paul was traveling on company business. Friendly's owner and his insurance company are still discussing whether the lunch run qualifies as part of the garage business. |
30–Autos Left With You
For Service, Repair, Storage Or Safekeeping
This symbol applies to customer autos, including autos of employees and
their household members, left with the named insured for service, repair,
storage or safekeeping for which a fee for the services provided is charged.
31–Dealers Autos (Physical Damage Coverages)
This symbol applies to any auto and the interests of any loss payees in those autos in Item Seven of the declarations.
Manuscript Symbol
An additional manuscript symbol not mentioned in the Garage Coverage Form is available by adding endorsement CA 99 54–Covered Auto Designation Symbol. Symbol 32 is available for the Garage Coverage Form and the autos considered covered must be listed and described on the endorsement.
Example: Jane’s dealership displays the first automobile it ever sold. It is still in working condition but is driven only in parades and commercials for the dealership. Since it is insured on an antique auto policy, it is not to be covered for physical damage coverage on Jane’s Garage Coverage Form. The insurance company agrees to provide symbol 21 for liability and symbol 32 for physical damage. CA 99 54–Covered Auto Designation Symbol is attached with the wording, “Except for the 1906 Ford, any auto and the interests in those autos described in Item Seven of the declarations." |
B. Owned Autos You
Acquire After The Policy Begins
1. If Symbols 21–Any Auto, 22–Owned Autos Only, 23–Owned Private Passenger Autos Only, 24–Owned Autos Other Than Private Passenger Autos Only, 25–Owned Autos Subject To No-Fault, or 26–Owned Autos Subject To A Compulsory Uninsured Motorists Law are entered on the declarations, autos of the type described by such symbols that the named insured acquires during the policy period are also covered. This means that a newly acquired auto that does not match the symbol is not covered until the insurance company is notified.
Example: |
2. When symbol 27–Specifically Described Autos is used, new autos acquired during the policy period are covered if the insurance company either covers all vehicles the named insured already owns or if the new vehicle replaces a vehicle already scheduled. However, the named insured must inform the insurance company of the acquisition within 30 days of the date it was acquired.
Example: |
C. Certain Trailers
And Temporary Substitute Autos
When liability coverage is provided, two additional categories of vehicles are added as covered vehicles.
1. Utility trailers having a load capacity of 2,000 pounds or less and designed for travel on public roads are covered while being pulled by a covered auto.
Note: A semi-trailer is not covered. There is no requirement that the utility trailer be owned. This means that liability coverage applies to a utility trailer the named insured rents to transport a piece of machinery as long as the load capacity is 2,000 pounds or less.
2. If the named insured's covered, owned auto is temporarily out of service for repair or service or due to breakdown, repair, servicing, loss or destruction, a non-owned, temporary substitute for it is covered but only if the named insured uses it with the owner's permission.
Example: Scenario One: All of Greatful Garage's autos are insured under CA 00 05–Garage Coverage Form using Symbol 22–Owned Autos. Karl, one of the partners, is given the opportunity to drive a newly introduced electric car that the manufacturer would like Greatful Garage to consider selling. Karl strikes a pedestrian but has no coverage under Greatful Garage’s coverage form because the electric car is not a substitute vehicle |
Note: Cars temporarily substituting for owned vehicles being repaired, maintained or serviced are covered.
Example: Scenario Two: All of Greatful Garage's autos are insured under CA 00 05–Garage Coverage Form, using Symbol 22–Owned Autos. Karl, one of the partners, returns his electric car to the manufacturer for repairs. The manufacturer provides him with a substitute vehicle until the repairs can be completed. When Karl strikes a pedestrian, coverage applies because the vehicle is a substitute for a covered vehicle. |
A. Coverage
This coverage form
provides two types of liability coverage. The first is similar to commercial
general liability coverage and the second is similar to business auto coverage.
1. Garage Operations–Other Than Covered Autos
The insurance company pays amounts an insured is legally obligated to pay
as damages because of bodily injury or property damage covered by this
insurance. The injury or damage must be caused by an accident and be due to
garage operations. Accidents due to ownership, maintenance or use of covered
autos are not covered.
The insurance company has the right and duty to defend any insured
against suits seeking damages covered by this insurance. It alone
decides how to handle that obligation. It has the right to decide what to
investigate, whether the claim is valid, and whether settling the claim or
contesting it is appropriate. The insurance company’s obligation to defend ends
once an action is resolved by paying a settlement or a court award that
exhausts the limit of insurance that applies. Coverage applies if the accident
takes place in the coverage territory and the bodily injury or property damage
occurs during the policy period. In addition, coverage does not apply to a loss
prior to the policy period even if it is a continuation or a recurrence that
takes place within the current policy period. Coverage for any injury or damage that occurs in the current policy
period applies to its continuation, change or resumption beyond the end of the
policy period.
Bodily injury or property damage is considered to have been known at the time any insured or authorized and responsible employee:
Note: This is consistent with the fact that insurance coverage is intended to insure against fortuitous events. Allowing an insured to purchase coverage for a loss already known to have occurred is unfair to the insurance company and could be fraudulent.
Example: Jamie Phillips works for ABC Garaging. He handles customer personal property that is lost or found on the premises. Jamie has known for a few weeks that a large metal waste container has a broken wheel that causes it to tip over without warning. He simply picks it up whenever it falls over and has not mentioned it to any of the parking attendants or the shift supervisors. As an attendant turns a corner while parking an insured’s BMW, the waste container suddenly tips over and smashes the side of the car. The impact startles the attendant, causes her to lose control, and the vehicle crashes into Jamie’s office. Chargemore Insurance Company tries to deny coverage when it discovers that Jamie knew about the hazardous container. However, it changes its decision when ABC's owner informs it that, while it would have been nice if Jamie had mentioned the problem to somebody in authority, his duties did not include responsibility for such matters. |
Note: This coverage is similar to the coverage provided under CG 00 01–Commercial General Liability Coverage Form in that it provides premises and products liability coverage for garage operations.
2. Garage Operations–Covered Autos
The insurance company pays amounts an insured is legally obligated to pay
as damages because of bodily injury, property damage, and certain pollution
costs and expenses this insurance covers caused by an accident and resulting
from garage operations involving ownership, maintenance or use of covered
autos. It only pays covered pollution costs and expenses if there is covered
bodily injury or property damage caused by the same accident.
Example: Greystoke Auto Dealers owns a shuttle that transports customers who have left their cars for service. The shuttle strikes an SUV as it exits the parking lot. The SUV is upended, falls over, and its gas tank ruptures and spews fuel all over the street, sidewalk and the storefront of a neighboring restaurant. The city sues Greystoke for the expense of cleaning up gas residue, and the restaurant sues for the cost of removing gas smells from its awning, tablecloths and furniture. These losses are covered. |
Now, let’s change this scenario slightly.
Example: Greystoke Auto Dealers owns a shuttle that transports customers who have left their cars for service. It strikes an SUV as it exits the parking lot. The shuttle driver gets his customers out of the vehicle and then rushes to remove a spare can of fuel from the shuttle as its damaged engine catches fire and places it on the sidewalk. Later, forgetting it was there, he trips over it and falls. The can's loose lid allows five gallons of gas to spill onto the sidewalk and into a sewer drain. The city sues Greystoke for the expense of cleaning up gas residue. This loss is not covered. |
The insurance company has the right and duty to defend any insured against suits seeking damages this insurance covers. It alone decides how to handle that obligation. It has the right to decide what to investigate, whether the claim is valid, and whether settling the claim or contesting it is appropriate. Its obligation ends once an action is resolved by a settlement, a court award, or exhaustion of the limit of insurance that applies.
Note: The insurance company's obligation to defend is identical to that in Garage Operations–Other Than Covered Autos. This liability coverage is similar to that provided in CA 00 01–Business Auto Coverage Form with respect to ownership, maintenance or use of covered autos.
3. Who Is An Insured
a. Insureds for covered
autos are:
(1) The named insured
(2) Anyone else who uses a covered auto the named insured owns, hires or borrows with the named insured’s permission except:
Example: If the named insured rents a car from a rental agency, the rental agency is not considered an insured. However, when the named insured rents a utility trailer to move furniture, the trailer owner is considered an insured. |
Example: If the named insured borrows an employee's car to pick a client up at the airport, the employee is not considered an insured. |
(3) Anyone liable for the conduct of an insured indicated above, limited to the extent of that liability
(4) An employee of the named insured while using
a covered auto that the named insured does not own, hire or borrow in its
business or personal affairs
Example: Jim is
the body shop manager for |
Note: CA 99
33—Employees As Insureds was the only way to provide this coverage in the past.
b. Insureds for garage operations other than covered autos are:
(1) The named insured
(2) The named insured's partners, if the named insured is a partnership, members, if the named insured is a limited liability company, employees, directors or shareholders while acting within the scope of their duties
Note: This is a very restrictive definition when compared to Who Is An Insured in the Commercial General Liability Coverage Form. Neither the named insured's spouse nor partners are insureds.
4. Coverage Extensions
a. Supplementary Payments
The insurance company pays the following on behalf of the insured:
(1) All expenses it incurs. This clarifies that the insurance company's expenses do not reduce the limit of insurance.
(2) If a bail bond related to a covered accident is required, up to $2,000 is available to pay its cost. The bond could be for a traffic law violation if related to the covered accident. The insurance company does not have to furnish the bond.
(3) The cost of bonds needed to release attachments in a suit filed against the insured that it defends, but only the amount of such bonds within the limit of insurance.
(4) Reasonable expenses if it asks the insured to participate in any investigation or defense. This includes actual loss of earnings up to $250 a day because of time taken off from work.
(5) All costs taxed against the insured in a suit filed against it that the insurance company defends. The exception is that attorney’s fee and attorney’s expenses taxed against the insured are not included (03 10 change).
(6) Interest that accrues following a judgment is covered. If the insurance company offers to pay, deposits payment with the court, or pays the judgment, any additional interest that accrues is not covered.
Note: None of these payments reduce the limit of insurance. This means that it is available to pay for the actual injuries or damages.
b. Out-Of-State Coverage Extensions
This section provides two important coverage extensions when an insured is away from the state where the auto is licensed or garaged. They essentially make the insurance provided comply with any state financial responsibility law, no-fault or other compulsory coverage. The two extensions are:
(1) The limit of insurance provided is automatically increased as needed to meet the limits required by a compulsory or financial responsibility law in the jurisdiction where the covered auto is being operated. An important note to this extension is that it does not apply to any law governing motor carriers, passengers or property.
Example: Percy’s garage policy liability limit is $50,000. It complies with the financial responsibility laws of the state where the vehicle is licensed and garaged. However, that limit is inadequate when Percy drives across the state line into the next state that has a minimum limit requirement of $75,000. This extension automatically increases the limit to $75,000 while Percy drives in that state. |
(2) The Garage Coverage Form provides the minimum amounts and types of other coverages required of out-of-state autos by the state where the covered auto is operated. One such coverage is no-fault.
Example: Percy’s state does not require no-fault coverage, but a neighboring state where Percy often travels does. This extension provides the coverage that state requires when Percy drives there. |
Note: A statement here clarifies that the insurance company does not pay anyone more than once for the same elements of loss because of these extensions. In other words, it does not duplicate any coverage or allow damages to be collected more than once.
B. Exclusions
It is important to read these exclusions to determine what is excluded and to also carefully consider any exceptions to them.
1. Expected Or Intended Injury
Any bodily injury or property damage the insured expects or intends to cause is excluded. However, for garage operations other than covered autos, this exclusion does not apply to bodily injuries that come from reasonable force used to protect persons or property.
Note: It is important to note that this exclusion applies to the entire policy, but the exception does not apply to covered auto coverage.
Example: George, an employee of First Auto Dealership, witnesses a purse snatching. He pursues the thief, catches him, and holds him until the police arrive. If the thief sues George, the First Auto Dealership Garage Coverage Form responds to the loss. However, there is no coverage if George drove a covered vehicle at the time and used it to pin the thief against a building. |
Note: This exclusion is intended to protect insurance companies from responding to damages or injuries the insured causes intentionally. It is in the public interest to prevent the insurance coverage from being used for gain, to injure competitors, as an instrument of revenge, or to cause any other deliberate harm. There is no ISO endorsement available to buy coverage for intentional acts or to delete this exclusion at the present time.
2. Contractual
Damages for bodily injury or property damage that result from liability the insured assumed in a contract or agreement are excluded. However, there are two exceptions. Coverage applies if either the contract or agreement is considered an insured contract or if the insured would have been liable without a contract or agreement. There is no ISO endorsement available to buy back or delete this exclusion at the present time.
3. Workers Compensation
Coverage does not apply to any requirement or obligation the insured or its insurance company must assume due to any workers compensation, disability benefits, unemployment compensation, or similar law.
Note: This exclusion and the one that follows are intended to prevent double indemnification for injury that should be covered under workers compensation or employers liability policies.
Insurers and brokers having to provide coverage on a variety of difficult, unusual or specialty workers compensation situations should refer to the Workers Compensation section in The Insurance Marketplace, a publication of The Rough Notes Company, Inc.
4. Employee
Indemnification And Employers Liability
Bodily injury to an employee that results from the actual employment or performance of duties that relate to the insured’s business is excluded.
In addition, bodily injury to a person who is not hired, or who is fired or is subject to negative employment-related practices, is also excluded.
Example: Maury worked as a mechanic for Lavid Motors. He specialized in brakes and sues Lavid when he develops asbestosis because asbestos was in the brake linings he worked on. Lavid’s insurance company denies coverage. |
Bodily injury to the spouse, child, parent, brother or sister of the employee or the person described in the first section of this exclusion that is consequential to that person’s or employee’s bodily injury is also excluded.
Example: Maury’s wife helps to care for him. She injures her back when he falls, and she attempts to lift him up. She sues Lavid Motors because her injury is a consequence of Maury’s injury. Lavid’s insurance company denies coverage. |
This entire exclusion applies regardless of when the employment- practices described above took place, whether before, during, or following employment (03 10 addition). It also applies whether the insured is liable as an employer or in any other capacity, or whether the insured is obligated to share damages with or repay someone else who must pay damages because of the injury.
Note: This clarification is important because of the widespread use of contractors, subcontractors, independent contractors or leased employees, and much of the uncertainty with respect to who is responsible.
Note: This exclusion has two exceptions. Coverage does apply to bodily injury to domestic employees who are not entitled to workers compensation benefits and also to liability the insured assumes in an insured contract. Domestic employees are persons who perform household or domestic work primarily for a residence premises.
5. Fellow Employee
It is important to
remember that employees are considered insureds. As a result, exclusions 3 and
4 could be circumvented if the injured employee could sue the fellow employee
who actually caused the accident. This exclusion prevents that workaround.
Bodily injury to a fellow employee of the insured that occurs as a result of or
in the course of that employee’s employment is excluded. In addition, bodily injury to the spouse, child, parent, brother or
sister of the fellow employee consequential to the fellow employee’s bodily
injury is also excluded (03 10 addition).
There are two ways to modify this exclusion. CA 20 55–Fellow Employee Coverage can be used to eliminate this exclusion entirely. CA 20 56—Fellow Employee Exclusions For Designated Employees/Positions can be used to eliminate this exclusion for injuries caused by certain employees or positions.
6. Care, Custody Or Control
Property damage to or covered pollution cost or expense to property the insured owns, rents, or occupies, property loaned to the insured, property it holds for sale or transports, or that is in its care, custody or control is excluded unless such liability was assumed in a sidetrack agreement.
The Garage Coverage Form protects the insured for its negligence and tort liability to others, not to damages or injury to the insured or its property. As such, it reinforces the need for the insured to maintain its premises and properties in good condition and to use reasonable care to prevent damage or injury, including damage to property in its care, custody or control.
Note: A sidetrack agreement involves the owners of a premises and a railroad with respect to a railroad sidetrack (a transfer or access track) on the insured's premises. The railroad allows the owner of the premises to use the sidetrack as long as it guarantees the railroad access to the sidetrack and agrees to certain conditions of property maintenance. It may also contain specified conditions of hold-harmless between the owner and the railroad.
Note: Section III–Garagekeepers Coverage insures customers’ vehicles in the insured’s care, custody and control. Coverage for property damage to other types of property is not available under this coverage form but property of others can be scheduled on a commercial property or an inland marine coverage form.
7. Leased Autos
Covered autos leased or rented to others are excluded except for covered autos rented to customers while their autos are left for service or repair.
8. Pollution Exclusion Applicable To Garage Operations–Other Than
Covered Autos
a. There is no coverage for
bodily injury or property damage arising out of any actual, alleged or
threatened discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration, release or escape of
pollutants:
(1) At or from any premise or site ever owned or occupied by, or rented or loaned to, any insured
(2) At or from any premises, site or location that is or ever was used by or for any insured or others to handle, store, dispose of, process or treat waste
(3) At or from any location that the insured or contractors or subcontractors working directly or indirectly on the insured's behalf perform operations:
(a) To test for, monitor, clean up, remove, contain, treat, detoxify, neutralize or respond in any way to the effects of pollutants
(b) If the contractor or subcontractor brought the pollutants on or to the premises, site or location in connection with such operations
(4) That are or ever were transported, handled, stored, treated, disposed of or processed as waste by or for any insured or any organization the named insured may be legally responsible for
Paragraphs a. (1) and a. (3) (b) do not apply to bodily injury or property damage that arises out of heat, smoke or fumes from a hostile fire.
Paragraph a. (1) does not
apply to bodily injury sustained in a building and caused by smoke, fumes,
vapor or soot produced by or originating from equipment that heats, cools or dehumidifies the building, or from equipment used to provide hot water
for the building's occupants.
Paragraph a. (3) (b) does not apply to bodily injury or property damage sustained inside a building caused by release of gases, fumes or vapors from material brought inside in conjunction with work done by the named insured or by contractors or subcontractors working on its behalf.
b. There is no coverage for any loss, cost or expense arising out of:
(1) Any request, demand, order or legal requirement to test for, monitor, clean up, remove, contain, treat, detoxify, neutralize, or responding to or assessing the effects of pollutants in any way
(2) Any claim or suit by or on behalf of governmental authorities for damages because of testing for, monitoring, cleaning up, removing, containing, treating, detoxifying, neutralizing or responding to or assessing the effects of pollutants in any way
9. Pollution Exclusion Applicable To Garage Operations–Covered Autos
There is no coverage for bodily injury or property damage arising out of
any actual, alleged or threatened discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration,
release or escape of pollutants:
a. Contained in any property:
(1) Being transported or handled in any way in, on or off a covered auto
(2) In transit otherwise by the insured or on its behalf
(3) Being stored, disposed of, treated or processed in or on a covered auto
b. Before the pollutant or its container is moved from the place where the insured accepts it for movement to the covered auto
c. After the pollutant or its container is moved from the covered auto to its final delivery destination for disposal or to be abandoned.
Paragraph a. does not apply to fuels, liquids, lubricants, exhaust gases and similar pollutants needed for normal operations of the covered auto that escape in any way from the compartment intended to contain them.
Paragraphs b. and c. do not apply to accidents that take place away from an insured's premises involving pollutants not in or on a covered auto if the pollutant or its container is upset, overturned or damaged resulting from maintenance or use of a covered auto and the release is directly caused by the upset, overturn or damage.
Example: Paul, a salesman with Miracle Motors, is with Mary as she test-drives a car from his dealership. She loses control and crashes into the outside oil tank at Jimmy’s Convenience store. The tank ruptures and releases all of its contents. Because the tank is not on the dealership’s premises and the release is caused by damage to the tank, the pollution release is covered under Miracle's Garage Coverage Form. |
Note: CA 99 55–Pollution Liability–Broadened Coverage for Covered Autos–Garage Coverage Form provides a buyback for pollution coverage. It changes the pollution exclusion by excluding only liability the insured assumes under a contract or agreement.
10. Racing
There is no coverage for any auto while being used in, practicing or being prepared for any professional or organized racing, demolition contest or stunts.
Note: Simply stated, vehicles are troublesome, even under normal operating conditions. They're heavy, difficult to control, and can cause an incredible amount of damage. For these reasons, insurance companies are not interested in providing coverage in cases where vehicle owners deliberately operate their property recklessly or dangerously.
11. Watercraft Or
Aircraft
Watercraft or aircraft are excluded except watercraft on shore at the named insured's garage locations where it conducts operations.
12. Defective Products
Coverage does not apply to property damage to any of the named insured's products if a defect in a product or one of its parts was transferred to another.
Note: CA 25 01–Broad Form Products Coverage eliminates this exclusion and covers loss involving an insured's defective products.
13. Work You Performed
Property damage to the named insured’s work or any part of it is excluded if it results from any part of the work itself or from parts, materials or equipment used in connection with the work.
Example: Paul’s Fine Cars repairs the engine in a customer’s vehicle. The work is defective and causes a vehicle fire. There is no coverage for the engine damage, but coverage may apply for the rest of the vehicle. |
14. Loss Of Use
There is no coverage for loss of use of other property not physically damaged caused by any defect, inadequacy or dangerous condition in the named insured’s product or work, or caused by any delay or failure of the named insured or anyone acting on its behalf to perform the terms of a contract or agreement.
Note: This exclusion has an exception. The Garage Coverage Form responds to loss of use if the loss of use of other property is the result of sudden or accidental damage to either the named insured’s product or work after being used as intended.
15. Products Recall
There is no coverage for damages claimed for any loss, cost or expense the named insured or others incurs for loss of use, withdrawal, recall, inspection, repair, replacement, adjustment, removal or disposal of the named insured’s product. There is also no coverage if the claims for damages are due to work the named insured performed, or other property of which the named insured's work or product is a part when withdrawn, recalled or removed because of a known or suspected defect, deficiency, inadequacy or dangerous condition.
Note: Coverage does not apply, regardless of the party that initiates the withdrawal, recall or removal. The expense and cost of the recall, repair or removal is excluded if there is reason or cause to suspect that a product, work or property is defective or could cause injury or damage.
Example: Jamie's Car Doctors had a very successful two-week brake inspection and repair promotion, performing nearly 200 brake replacements. A month after the promotion, Jamie began getting complaints about brake malfunctions during sudden stops and had to contact every customer and replace the brake pads. Jamie filed a claim for products recall that was denied. |
16. War
This exclusion unequivocally bars coverage for either bodily injury or property damage related to war and similar military events. It is not affected by circumstances such as a formal declaration of war, that the war is a civil uprising, or whether it involves government or civilian participants.
Note: The bottom line is that there is no coverage for loss related either directly or indirectly to war or warlike activity.
17. Distribution Of Material In Violation Of Statutes Exclusion
Applicable To Garage Operations–Other Than Covered "Autos"
Insurance coverage does not apply to bodily
injury or property damage that arises directly or indirectly out of any act or
omission that violates or allegedly violates the Telephone Consumer Protection
Act (TCPA), including its amendments or additions, the CAN-SPAM Act of 2003,
including its amendments or additions, or any other statute, ordinance or
regulation prohibiting or limiting the sending, transmitting, communicating or
distributing of material or information.
Example: Midtown Car Sales is insured under the Garage Coverage Form. It sends notice to its insurance company and requests that it handle a recently filed claim notice of a class-action lawsuit on behalf of thousands of citizens in the area over receiving e-mail advertisements of Midtown's monthly auto deals. Midtown sent the e-mails based on an e-mail list purchased from a third party. The insurance company rejects the claim request because Midtown's action involved spamming. |
C. Limit Of Insurance
1. Aggregate Limit Of
Insurance–Garage Operations–Other Than Covered Autos
For these operations, without regard to the number of insureds, claims made, or suits brought, the most paid for the total of all damages resulting from all bodily injury and property damage in any one accident is the aggregate limit on the declarations. These damages do not include ownership, maintenance or use of covered autos because that coverage has its own limit. It does include the following coverages, if provided:
Note: All bodily injury and property damage that is the result of continuous or repeated exposure to essentially the same conditions is considered the result of one accident.
The Aggregate Limit applies separately to each annual 12-month period beginning on the inception date. For any remaining period of less than 12 months, the limit also applies separately to that period unless coverage was extended for that period. In that case, the extended period is part of the preceding policy period for purposes of applying the limit.
Example: |
2. Limit Of
Insurance–Garage Operations–Covered Autos
For these operations, without regard to the number of covered autos, insureds, premium paid, claims made, or vehicles involved in the accident, the most paid for the total of all damages resulting from all bodily injury and property damage in any one accident is the each accident limit on the declarations. Damages and covered pollution costs or expenses are that are payable under this coverage are not payable under Garage Operations–Other Than Covered Autos.
Note: All bodily injury, property damage, and covered pollution cost or expense that is the result of continuous or repeated exposure to essentially the same conditions is considered the result of one accident.
Note: No party can receive duplicate payments for essentially the same loss under this coverage form and any medical payments, uninsured motorists or underinsured motorists coverage that is part of this coverage form.
Example: The two named insureds on the Garage Coverage Form are Smith, Inc. and John Smith, Smith Inc.'s owner. Smith, Inc. owns several private passenger vehicles that John uses for both business and pleasure. John causes a serious accident while using one of them on a personal errand. Because of the severity of her injuries, the injured party sues John individually for $500,000 and Smith, Inc. as the vehicle owner for $500,000. The Garage Coverage Form's limit is $500,000 Each Accident For Garage Operations–Covered Autos. The claimant is awarded $1,000,000, or $500,000 from each party named in the lawsuit but the Garage Coverage Form pays only its $500,000 limit. |
D. Deductible
$100 is deducted from the damages in an accident resulting from property damage to an auto resulting from the named insured's work done on that auto.
A. Coverage
1. The insurance company pays amounts the insured is legally obligated to pay as damages for loss or damage to either a customer's auto or its equipment left in the insured's care while attending, servicing, repairing, parking or storing it in the named insured's garage operations. One or more of the following coverages applies if a limit for it is on the declarations:
a. Comprehensive Coverage
Coverage applies to any cause of damage to a customer's auto except collision with another object and overturn.
b. Specified Causes Of Loss Coverage
This coverage applies only to loss or damage caused by or resulting from fire, lightning, explosion, theft, mischief or vandalism.
c. Collision Coverage
This coverage is very specific. The only covered loss or damage is that caused by the customer's auto's collision with another object or its overturn.
Note: Another object could be another vehicle as well as an animal, bird, person, tree, building or sign, to name a few.
2. The company has both the right and the duty to defend any insured against suits seeking these damages if coverage applies. It can investigate and settle claims and suits in the appropriate manner but its duty to defend ends when the limit of insurance for the coverage that applies is exhausted by payment of judgments or settlements.
3. Who Is An Insured
The insured for loss or damage to customer's autos and their equipment is the named insured, its partners if the business is a partnership, its members if the business is a limited liability company, and employees, directors or shareholders while acting within the scope of their duties.
4. Coverage Extensions
The insurance company pays the following supplementary payments for the insured. They apply to any claim or suit it defends and do not reduce the limit of insurance.
a. All expenses it incurs.
b. The cost of bonds needed to release attachments in a suit filed against the insured that it defends, but only the amount of such bonds within the limit of insurance
c. Reasonable expenses if it asks the insured to participate in any investigation or defense. This includes actual loss of earnings up to $250 a day because of time taken off from work.
d. All costs taxed
against the insured in a suit filed against it that it defends, except for attorney’s fees and expenses
taxed against the insured (03 10 addition).
e. Interest on the
full amount of any judgment that accrues after it is entered in a suit against
the insured that it defends. The duty to pay interest ends after the company
offers the part of a judgment that falls within its limit of insurance.
B. Exclusions
1. The insurance provided by this coverage form
does not apply to the following:
a. Contractual
Obligations
Liability that results
from any contract or agreement where the insured accepts responsibility for a
loss is excluded, unless the insured
would be liable for the loss without a contract or agreement.
b. Theft
Coverage does not apply to loss due to theft or conversion caused in any way by the named insured, its employees, or shareholders.
Note: This coverage is available under crime or employee dishonesty coverage forms.
c. Defective Parts
Loss caused by or resulting from use of defective parts or materials is excluded.
d. Faulty Work
There is no coverage for loss caused by or resulting from the named insured's faulty work performed.
2. The following types of property are excluded:
a. Sound equipment not permanently installed in the vehicle. This includes tape decks, compact disc players and new types of sound reproducing equipment.
b. Media used to produce sound in sound reproducing devices. This includes compact discs, cassettes and new types of media.
c. Equipment not permanently installed and designed to receive sound. This includes citizens’ band radios, two-way mobile radios, telephones or scanning monitor receivers, including their antennas, and any accessories unless permanently installed.
Note: CA 99 59–Garagekeepers Coverage–Customers' Sound Receiving Equipment covers this type of equipment and essentially deletes exclusion c.
d. Equipment designed or used to detect, locate or jam radar or any other speed detection devices.
Note: There is no reference to increasingly common and sophisticated computing, visual and/or navigational devices.
3. Coverage does not apply to loss or damage
caused by or resulting from the following, regardless of any other cause or
event that contributes concurrently or in any sequence to the loss.
a. War. This includes civil war and undeclared war.
b. Warlike actions by military forces. This includes actions by any government, sovereign or other authority that uses military personnel or other agents to hinder or defend against actual or expected attacks
c. Action taken by governmental authority to hinder or defend against insurrection, rebellion, revolution or usurped power
C. Limits Of Insurance
And Deductibles
1. For these operations, without regard to the number of customer's autos, insureds, premium paid, claims made, or suits brought, the most paid for each loss at each location is the limit on the declarations.
Note: An important
point for the named insured to consider in selecting the limit is the total
number of vehicles in its care at any one time and their associated values.
Example: A fire damages four vehicles at Handy’s Used Car Lot, for total damages of $65,000. Since Handy’s Garagekeepers limit is $50,000, only $50,000 is paid. |
The deductibles that apply to a loss must be subtracted from the amount
claimed prior to applying the limit cap (03 10 clarification change).
Example: Hail damaged 25
customers’ vehicles at Small Town Dealership. |
2. The deductible
for Garagekeepers Coverage Comprehensive or Specified Causes Of Loss Coverages
on the declarations is the most deducted for all loss in any one occurrence.
3. If the insurance company pays all or part of the deductible in order to settle a claim or suit, the named insured must reimburse the company for any such amounts it paid.
A. Coverage
The insurance company
pays for loss to a covered auto and its equipment based on the coverages on the
declarations and the symbols selected. When selected, the following coverage is
provided:
1. The insurance company pays for loss or damage to covered autos or their equipment if a symbol is indicated.
a. Comprehensive
Coverage
This is loss or damage from any cause except the covered auto colliding with another object or overturning.
b. Specified Causes Of
Loss
This is loss or damage caused by only fire, lightning, explosion, theft, windstorm, hail, earthquake, flood, mischief, vandalism, or sinking, burning, collision or derailment of any conveyance transporting the covered auto.
Note: Although these are the most common losses, they are very specific, and many losses are not covered.
c. Collision Coverage
This is loss or damage caused by the covered auto colliding with another object or overturning.
Note: "Another object" could be an animal, bird, person, tree, building, sign, etc., in addition to another vehicle.
2. Glass Breakage–Hitting A Bird Or Animal–Falling Objects Or Missiles
The insurance company pays for loss or damage caused by glass breakage, striking an animal or bird, and by falling objects or missiles if comprehensive coverage applies to the damaged auto. However, the named insured can choose to cover a glass breakage loss as part of collision when the breakage is due to a collision and avoid paying two deductibles.
Note: This clarifies coverage. The three types of losses indicated could be called collisions because an object struck the vehicle. This is important because the named insured might have a smaller deductible on its comprehensive coverage or may only carry comprehensive coverage.
3. Coverage Extension
Loss Of Use Expenses
The expenses an insured must pay under a written rental contract or agreement for loss of use of a rental car are covered but only if it purchases Hired Auto Physical Damage. Coverage is limited to $20 per day and $600 maximum. Payment is made if the loss of use expenses is caused by:
Note: CA 99 90–Optional Limits–Loss Of Use Expenses can be used to purchase higher limits.
B. Exclusions
Editor’s note: Some exclusions are given titles for analysis purposes. These titles are not a part of the Garage Coverage Form.
1. Coverage does not apply to loss or damage caused by or resulting from the following, regardless of any other cause or event that contributes concurrently or in any sequence to the loss.
a. Nuclear Hazard
This is explosion of any weapon using atomic fission or fusion, or nuclear reaction, radiation or radioactive contamination, regardless of how caused.
b. War Or Military Action
This includes declared or undeclared war, civil war, warlike action by a military force, including acts to defend or hinder an expected or actual attack by any government or authority employing military personnel or agents, as well as insurrection, rebellion, revolution, usurped power or any action to hinder or defend against these.
Note: Damage or loss involving nuclear or war-like activities is excluded even if other loss factors contribute to an incident. In other words, these losses are excluded regardless of how caused or whether or not they combine with any other cause of loss.
2. The insurance company does not pay for loss or damage to the following:
a. Leased Or Rented
Autos
Coverage does not apply to any covered auto leased or rented to others.
Note: This exclusion has an exception for autos rented to customers who leave their autos with the named insured for service or repair.
b. Racing
There is no coverage for any covered auto while it is being used in or practicing or being prepared for any professional or organized racing, demolition contest or stunting activity.
c. Tapes, Records,
Discs
Tapes, records, discs and similar property or devices designed for use with audio, visual, or electronic equipment are excluded. This exclusion is extremely broad because of changes in media. Tapes and CD’s are excluded as well as DVD’s and equipment that can be attached to any media system within the auto.
Note: In this exclusion, ISO uses the term “data electronic” that is neither defined nor in common usage. The term is used to describe devices that are excluded and also to describe equipment to which any of these excluded items could be designed for. Although it appears to be an all-inclusive term, its lack of clear meaning could make this exclusion ambiguous.
d. Speed Detection
Devices
There is no coverage for radar and laser jamming, detecting, eluding or disrupting equipment designed or used to detect speed.
e. Electronic
Equipment (03 10 change)
Coverage does not apply to any type of electronic equipment used to receive, reproduce, or transmit audiovisual or data.
Note: The exception for equipment used solely to reproduce sound is eliminated (03/10 change).
f. Other Equipment
Any accessory used with electronic equipment described in paragraph e. is also not covered.
3. This item provides exceptions to exclusion 2.e and 2.f above (03 10
change).
Exclusions 2.e and 2.f. do not apply to property designed to operate
only from the auto’s electrical system and that at the time of loss meet any of
the following criteria:
a. Permanently installed in or on the covered
auto
b. Not permanently installed but removable only from a housing unit
that is permanently installed in or on the covered auto
c. Any item that is considered integral to items described in a. or b.
above
d. Other electrical
equipment normal to the operation of the covered auto or that monitors the
operating system
4. False Pretense
There is no coverage for loss to a covered auto caused by or resulting from another party causing the named insured to voluntarily part with it under false pretenses, or because of a trick or scheme, or because the named insured acquired an auto from a seller who did not have legal title to it.
Example: Suburban Motors turns in a loss on a pre-owned vehicle it purchased from an individual two weeks earlier. When investigating the loss, the adjuster discovers that the seller did not have legal title to it because it was actually stolen, and the seller used falsified papers to transact the sale. The insurance company denies the claim. |
Note: CA 25 03–False Pretense Coverage covers dealers and garage operations that receive used vehicles for trade-ins. It covers the insured up to the specified limit for vehicles it acquires from customers who engage in false pretense.
5. Specific Exclusions
a. Coverage does not apply to the named insured's expected profit, loss of market or resale value.
b. The insurance company does not pay for loss to any covered auto stored or displayed at any location not on the declarations 45 or more days after the named insured begins using that location.
c. Collision coverage does not apply to any covered auto driven or transported more than 50 miles between the purchase or distribution point and the destination.
Note: CA 25 02—Dealers Driveaway Collision Coverage is used with dealers and garage operations with driveaway exposures that may need additional collision coverage by eliminating the 50 mile limitation. The insured must provide additional information with the periodically required reports if this endorsement is used.
d. Specified Causes Of Loss coverage does not apply to loss or damage to any covered auto caused by or resulting from collision or upset of the vehicle transporting it.
6. Diminution Of Value
Loss of a covered auto's value because it was involved in an accident is not covered. Diminution Of Value is defined in Section VI–Definitions.
Example: |
7. Other Exclusions
Coverage does not apply
to loss or damage caused by and confined
to wear and tear, freezing, mechanical or electrical breakdown, or from
blowouts, punctures or other road damage to tires. This exclusion does not
apply if the loss is the result of the
total theft of the vehicle.
Note: The exception previously was for any cause of loss that was
otherwise covered. It is now reworded to provide similar coverage because the
loss or damage must be “confined” to only the excluded items.
Note: There are no current ISO endorsements available to buy back or delete this exclusion. The insured interested in insuring some of these exposures should check into the special warranty, labor and replacement programs available through many dealerships.
C. Limits Of Insurance
1. The most paid for loss or damage to any one covered auto is the lesser of:
a. The actual cash value of the stolen or damaged property
Note: This value is based on what the property was worth at the time of the loss, not at the time of adjustment or when it was purchased.
b. The cost to repair or replace the stolen or damaged property with property of like kind and quality
2. A $1,000 sub-limit
applies to certain types of covered electronic equipment. It must be
permanently installed or removable but in a permanently installed housing in a
part of the vehicle the auto manufacturer does not use for such equipment. Any
equipment that is part of such equipment is also subject to the sub-limit (03
10 addition).
3. In case of a total loss, adjustments are made for the auto's depreciation and physical condition to establish the actual cash value.
4. If repairing or replacing the auto increases its value, the insurance company does not pay for that increase.
Note: CA 99 28–Stated Amount Insurance appears to be a way around this limitation. However, for vehicles on the endorsement schedule, the limit for physical damage coverage is changed to the least of the actual cash value, the cost to repair or replace, or the limit specified. This means this limitation would still apply. In fact, this endorsement should be used cautiously because it could actually decrease the settlement amount.
5. Additional
Provisions
a. The most paid for all loss or damage at any
one location is the limit for that location on the declarations, regardless of
the number of covered autos damaged or involved in the loss. Similarly, the
most paid for all loss in transit is the limit on the declarations for loss in
transit, regardless of the number of covered autos damaged or involved in the
loss.
b. Quarterly Or
Monthly Reporting Premium Basis
If the actual value of the covered autos at the loss location exceeds the value given on the latest report, the insurance company pays only a percentage of the loss. It arrives at this percentage by dividing the total reported value for the involved location by the actual value on the date of the last report. If the first report was not submitted on time, the most paid is not more than 75% of the limit of insurance on the declarations for the involved location.
c. Non-Reporting
Premium Basis
If the actual value of the covered autos at the loss location exceeds the value on the declarations, the insurance company pays only a percentage of the loss. It arrives at this percentage by dividing the limit by the total values at risk at the time of loss.
D. Deductible
The amount the insurance company pays to repair, return, or replace damaged or stolen property is reduced by the deductible amount on the declarations. Comprehensive or Specified Causes Of Loss Coverages can have a deductible for only theft and vandalism or for all perils. The per-loss deductible is capped at the maximum deductible indicated for that location on the declarations.
Note: The collision deductible is a per loss deductible and there is no maximum.
The conditions in this section are in addition to the conditions in IL 00 17–Common Policy Conditions.
A. Loss Conditions
1. Appraisal For Physical Damage Loss
If the insurance company and the named insured fail to agree to the amount of a loss, either may demand an appraisal. When this occurs, each party selects a competent appraiser, both of whom then select a competent and impartial umpire. Each appraiser separately states the actual cash value and amount of loss. If the two appraisers do not agree, they submit their differences to the umpire. When any two of the three agree, that decision is binding on all parties. The insurance company and the named insured each pay the cost of the appraisers and share the expense of the umpire and costs of the appraisal equally.
Note: Even if the insurance company participates in the appraisal process, it still retains the right to deny the claim.
2. Duties In The Event Of Accident, Claim, Suit Or Loss
The insurance company has no duty to provide any coverage under this coverage form unless the named insured fully complies fully with the following duties:
a. In case of an accident, claim, suit or loss, the named insured must provide either the insurance company or its authorized representative with prompt notice of how, when and where the accident or loss occurred, the insured’s name and address, and the names and addresses of any injured persons or of any witnesses, if known.
b. The named insured and the involved insured must not commit the insurance company to any payment, obligation or expense. However, the insured can make any commitments it wants at its own expense. The named insured and the insured involved must cooperate with the insurance company during investigating or settling the claim or defending the suit. They must also provide copies of all documents the company requests as well as provide it with all necessary authorizations so it can obtain medical records or other pertinent information and submit to examination by a physician the company chooses as long as it is reasonable and at the company's expense.
c. The named insured has additional duties in case of a physical damage loss to a covered auto or its equipment. It must notify the police promptly if the loss is due to theft. In other loss situations and within reason, the named insured must protect the covered auto from further damage and record the expenses incurred to do so because they can be considered when the claim is settled. The insurance company must be able to inspect the damaged auto and obtain information about the loss before the auto is repaired or disposed of. If the company requests, the named insured must agree to be examined under oath and sign any statement of answers.
Failure to cooperate can have serious consequences. Although it does not involve commercial auto, this case illustrates what can happen to a party who does not comply with such provisions.
3. Legal Action Against Us
No one may bring legal action against the insurance company until all coverage form terms have been complied with. In addition, under liability coverage, the insurance company must agree that the insured has an obligation to pay a third party or a court must have determined that there is such an obligation The insurance company cannot be brought into any action to determine the insured’s liability.
4. Loss Payment–Physical Damage Coverages
The insurance company determines the method to use to settle a physical damage loss. It can:
a. Pay to repair or replace the damaged or stolen property
b. Return the stolen property but bear the expense of returning it. It also pays any damages the auto incurred due to the theft.
c. Pay the appraised or agreed value of the damaged or stolen property and then take any or all of it
Note: Any payment made includes any required sales tax.
5. Transfer Of Rights Of Recovery Against Others To Us
If the insurance company made payments to a party under this coverage form, any rights that party may have to recover from another transfer to the insurer. The party that was paid must do everything necessary to secure the company's rights to recover and do nothing to impair those rights.
B. General Conditions
1. Bankruptcy
Bankruptcy of the insured or its estate does not relieve the insurance company of its obligations under this coverage form.
2. Concealment, Misrepresentation Or Fraud
Coverage is void in any case of fraud by the named insured at any time relating to this coverage form. It is also void if the named insured or any insured at any time intentionally conceals or misrepresents material facts relating to this coverage form, the covered auto, the named insured’s interest in the covered auto, or any claim made under this coverage form.
Example: Nigh-Eve Mutual issues a garage coverage form to Acme Autos. Acme turns in a claim involving losses to more than a dozen new cars it alleges were vandalized on its lot. The loss investigation reveals that Acme actually deals in used, older vehicles and targets persons with poor credit instead of being the dealer in high-value new cars as stated on the application. The loss is denied. |
3. Liberalization
Any broadened or additional coverage the insurance company provides without an additional premium charge automatically applies to this coverage form. It is effective on the date that the coverage is effective in the named insured’s state.
4. No Benefit To Bailee–Physical Damage Coverages
If a party, such as a bailee, holds or transports property for a fee and requires an assignment of coverage, the insurance company does not recognize that assignment, regardless of any other provision in this coverage form.
5. Other Insurance
a. This insurance is primary if the named insured owns the covered auto. Otherwise, it is excess over any other insurance that can be collected. Trailer coverage is similar but is based on the vehicle it is attached to. If the trailer is attached to the named insured's covered auto, coverage for the trailer is primary. However, coverage is excess when the trailer is attached to a motor vehicle the named insured does not own.
b. Under hired auto physical damage coverage, a covered auto the named insured leases, hires, rents or borrows is considered an owned covered auto. The one exception is when such autos come with a driver.
Note: CA 20 54–Employee Hired Autos covers situations when an employee hires an auto in his or her own name as an individual intending to perform business-related duties and activities for the named insured.
c. This coverage is always primary when liability is assumed in an insured contract.
Note: This supersedes the provisions of paragraph 5.a above.
d. The insurance company pays only its share when any other insurance covers the loss on the same basis, regardless of whether that coverage is on a primary or excess basis. Its share is the proportion that this limit of insurance bears to the total of the limits of all coverage forms and policies that apply on the same basis.
Note: Ratios are determined based on each company’s limits as a percentage of all limits available. Losses are proportioned among the insurers accordingly.
6. Premium Audit
a. The initial premium paid is an estimate based on the exposures the named insured stated at inception. The insurance company calculates the final premium based on the insured's actual exposures. Once that is done, the estimated premium is subtracted, and the first named insured is either billed for the additional amount owed or receives a refund if it overpaid. The billing statement indicates the date additional premium is due.
b. When coverage is issued for longer than a one-year term, the premium is calculated annually based on the insurance company's rates in effect at the beginning of each annual period.
7. Policy Period,
Only bodily injury,
property damage and losses that occur during the policy period are covered.
Only covered pollution cost or expense that arises from accidents that occur
during the policy period is covered. The occurrence or accident must take place
within the coverage territory. The coverage territory is the
Worldwide coverage is provided if the covered private passenger auto is leased, rented or hired for a period of less than 30 days and the responsibility to pay is determined in the territories listed in the first paragraph of this condition.
The coverage territory is extended to anywhere in the world if the bodily injury or property damage is caused by one of the insured’s products sold for use in one of the coverage territories indicated above. The original suit for damages resulting from the bodily injury or property damage must first be brought in a described coverage territory.
Note: CA 01
21–Limited
8. Two or More Coverage Forms Or Policies Issued By Us
Except for coverage forms or policies issued specifically as excess, if this coverage form and any other coverage form or policy issued to the insured by the insurance company or any of its affiliates apply to the same accident, the most paid for the total limit of insurance under all the coverage forms or policies is not more than the highest applicable limit of insurance under any one coverage form or policy.
A. Accident includes continuous or repeated exposure to the same conditions that result in bodily injury or property damage.
B. Auto is a land motor vehicle, trailer or semitrailer.
C. Bodily injury is not only bodily injury sustained by a person but also sickness or disease sustained by a person, including resulting death from any of these.
D. Covered pollution cost or expense is any cost or expense arising out of requests, demands, orders, statutory or regulatory requirements, claims or suits by or on behalf of a governmental authority demanding that the insured or others test for, monitor, clean up, remove, contain, treat, detoxify, neutralize, or in any way respond to or assess the effects of pollutants. This includes suits or claims brought by the governmental authority or others for any of these.
It does not include cost or expense that arises out of the actual, alleged or threatened discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration, release or escape of pollutants:
a. Being transported, towed by, handled or handled for movement into, onto or from a covered auto, are otherwise in the course of transit by or on behalf of the insured, or are being stored, disposed of, treated or processed in or on a covered auto. This includes any pollutants contained in any property during any of the previously indicated conditions.
This paragraph has an exception. Coverage may apply if fuels, lubricants, fluids, exhaust gases or other similar pollutants needed for or as a result of the normal electrical, hydraulic or chemical function of the covered auto or its parts cause the pollution. The pollutants must escape, seep, migrate or be discharged, dispersed or released directly from an auto part designed by the manufacturer to hold, store, receive or dispose of the pollutants.
b. Prior to moving the pollutant generating property to the place where the insured receives it in order to move it either into or on a covered auto
c. After moving the pollutant generating property from the covered auto to the point of the insured’s final delivery
Paragraphs b and c do not apply if an accident occurs away from a premises any insured owns or rents and the pollutants are not in or on a covered auto, but only if the pollutant generating property is upset, overturned or damaged resulting from maintenance or use of a covered auto and upset, overturn or damage causes the polluting event.
E. Customer's Auto (03
10 change)
This is a motorized
vehicle, trailer or semitrailer designed for land use in the named insured’s possession for storage, safekeeping, repair or
service. The possession must be lawful but does not require the vehicle owner's
consent or knowledge. The vehicle can belong to an employee or members of his
or her household as long as they pay for the service the named insured
provides.
Note: This 03 10 change is both a broadening and a restriction. The
vehicle is covered even if the customer does not know it is in the named
insured’s possession. This could be considered a broadening of coverage.
However, since the purpose of the possession must be lawful, this could be
considered a restriction of coverage.
F. Diminution in value is the loss of market value solely due an accident. This loss of value can be actual or perceived.
G. Employee includes leased workers but not temporary workers.
H. Garage operations is the ownership, maintenance or use of locations for garage business and portions of roads or other accesses adjoining them. It also includes the ownership, maintenance or use of autos indicated in Section I as covered autos as well as all operations necessary or incidental to a garage business.
I. Insured is any party who qualifies as an insured under Who Is An Insured. Coverage applies separately to each insured seeking coverage or against whom a claim or suit is brought. The one exception is that the limit of insurance does not apply per insured.
J. Insured contract includes the following:
1. Leases of premises
2. Sidetrack agreements
3. Easement or license agreements. However, any contract in conjunction with construction or demolition operations on or within 50 feet of a railroad is not an insured contract.
4. Obligations required by ordinance when the purpose is to indemnify a municipality. However, this does not apply to any work being done for the requesting municipality.
5. The portion of a contract or agreement that relates to the named insured’s business, including any municipal indemnification in connection with work being done for the municipality, where the named insured assumes the tort liability of another party. The tort liability must be to pay for bodily injury or property damage to a third party or organization. Tort liability is liability the named insured would have had without a contract or agreement.
6. Elevator maintenance agreements
7. The portion of an auto rental or lease contract or agreement the named insured or an employee enters into that relates to the named insured’s garage business. Any obligation the named insured or its employee has to pay for property damage to the auto is not considered an insured contract.
These contracts or agreements are not considered insured contracts:
K. Leased worker is a person the named insured leases from a labor-leasing firm to work in its business. It requires an agreement between the leasing firm and the named insured. Temporary workers are not considered leased workers.
L. Loss is direct and accidental loss or damage. Garagekeepers Coverage is broadened to include any resulting loss of use.
M. Pollutants are any solid, liquid, gaseous, or thermal irritant or contaminant, including smoke, vapor, soot, fumes, acids, alkalis, chemicals and waste. Waste includes materials to be recycled, reconditioned or reclaimed.
Note: This definition is consistent in all ISO coverage forms.
N. Products are goods or products the named insured made or sold in a garage business. This includes warnings or instructions given or that should have been given.
O. Property damage is not limited to just damage to tangible property. It also includes any loss of its use.
P. Suit is not limited to only civil proceedings alleging damages. It also includes any arbitration or alternative resolution proceedings as long as the insurance company consents to them. All allegations must be due to covered bodily injury, property damage or covered pollution costs or expenses.
Q. Temporary worker is neither a leased worker nor an employee. The named insured uses these workers as substitutes for permanent employees or to help out in short-term situations. The named insured must understand that temporary workers are not considered an insured. For this reason, temporary workers should not drive any company vehicles or use their vehicles for company business.
R. Trailer includes semitrailers as well as small utility trailers.
S. Work you performed is the work the named insured performed, including work another party performed on the named insured's behalf. This includes warnings or instructions that were given or that should have been given.
This list identifies endorsements available to modify the Insurance
Services Office (ISO) Garage Coverage Form. It is arranged by form number and
title and includes a brief explanation of the use of each form. This section
does not include any state specific endorsements, changes or amendments. New
endorsements introduced or changes in the 03 10 edition are in bold print.
The ten-digit numbering sequence of ISO forms and endorsements has a
very specific meaning.
CA 00 |
Coverage Forms |
CA 01 |
Amendatory Endorsements |
CA 02 |
Cancellation And Suspension Endorsements |
CA 03 |
Deductible Endorsements |
CA 04 |
Coverage Endorsements |
CA 20 |
Special Type Endorsements |
CA 21 |
Uninsured Motorists Endorsements |
CA 22 |
No-Fault Endorsements |
CA 23 |
Commercial Auto Endorsements |
CA 24 |
Public Transportation Endorsements |
CA 25 |
Garage Endorsements |
CA 26 |
Single Interest Endorsements |
CA 31 |
Uninsured Motorists Endorsements |
CA 99 |
Common Coverages And Rating Procedures Endorsements |
IL 00–12 |
Interline Endorsements |
CA 01 21–Limited
This endorsement opens
with a stern warning about driving in
CA 02 38–Reinstatement Of Insurance (03 10 change)
This endorsement is used to reinstate previously suspended coverages and/or vehicles. A schedule was added so that only certain items can be reinstated. Completing the schedule is very important because autos remain suspended if it is not completed properly.
CA 02 40–Suspension Of Insurance (03 10 change)
This endorsement is used
to suspend the coverages and/or vehicles
on the endorsement schedule. Return premiums are provided only if the
suspension extends beyond 30 days. Note that only the suspension effective date
is indicated. The suspension is lifted on the date on CA 02 38–Reinstatement Of
Insurance.
CA 03 01–Deductible Liability Coverage (03 10 change)
This endorsement provides liability deductibles that apply per accident. They can apply to all liability or be limited to only property damage. Credits apply for the deductibles selected based on the ISO rating plan.
CA 03 02–Deductible Liability Coverage (03 10 change)
This endorsement provides liability deductibles that apply per accident. They can apply to all liability or be limited to only property damage. Credits apply for the deductibles selected based on the ISO rating plan. This endorsement is identical to CA 03 01–Deductible Liability Coverage except for one word that requires the insurance company to pay the deductible and then be reimbursed by the named insured. Under CA 03 01, the insurance company may pay the deductible and then be reimbursed. Under this endorsement, the insurance company will pay the deductible and then be reimbursed.
CA 03 03–100 Dollar
Deductible For Completed Operations Does Not Apply
The $100 deductible for property damage does not apply when this endorsement is added to the Garage Coverage Form.
CA 04 42–Exclusion Of Federal Employees Using Autos In Government
Business (03 10 addition)
This endorsement tries to eliminate any attempt to provide coverage for
the federal government under private insurance coverage. Under this coverage,
the named insured or its employee acting as a federal government employee when
an accident occurs is not an insured.
CA 04 44–Waiver Of Transfer Of Rights Of Recovery Against Others To Us
(Waiver Of Subrogation) (03 10 addition)
No organization or person on the endorsement schedule can be subrogated
against as long as a contract was signed agreeing to the waiver before any loss
they were involved in occurred.
CA 20 01–Lessor–Additional Insured And Loss Payee
The leased vehicles on the endorsement schedule are treated as owned autos for coverage purposes. Any lessor on the endorsement schedule is an insured for the designated vehicles and receives notice of cancellation if either the named insured or the insurance company cancels coverage.
CA 20 16–Mobile Homes Contents Coverage
This endorsement insures covered property inside, attached to and outside (within 25 feet) of a mobile home. The coverage provided is limited to certain causes of loss and specifically excludes theft. It excludes business property, sales samples, exhibition property, and certain other property. CA 20 17–Mobile Homes Contents Not Covered should be attached if this endorsement is not used.
CA 20 17–Mobile Homes Contents Not Covered
This endorsement deletes coverage for all contents in a mobile home not usually found in a truck or private passenger vehicle.
CA 20 21–Snowmobiles (03 10 change)
This endorsement is used for commercially operated snowmobiles used off public roads but away from the named insured’s premises. Symbol 19 may be used instead of this endorsement in states where snowmobiles must be registered.
Note: This edition removes all references to physical damage coverage.
CA 99 28–Stated Amount Insurance should be used to provide the coverage (03 10
change)
CA 20 27–Registration Plates Not Issued For A Specific Auto
This endorsement provides the liability coverages selected for which a premium is charged for autos while using the plates on the endorsement schedule. The premium charge is per plate.
CA 20 33–Autos Leased, Hired, Rented Or Borrowed With Drivers–Physical
Damage Coverage (03 10 change)
This endorsement insures the physical damage coverages selected for the non-owned vehicles on the endorsement schedule. A physical damage limit, deductible and the estimated cost of hire and a premium charge based on estimated annual cost must appear for each coverage selected.
Note: The 03 10 edition removed rates from the endorsement schedule.
CA 20 47–Additional
Insured–Lessor Of Leased Equipment
This endorsement makes additional insureds of persons or organizations on the declarations or endorsement schedule that lease equipment to the named insured for liability arising out of its maintenance, use or operation of that equipment. The coverage provided is subject to three additional exclusions.
CA 20 48–Designated Insured
This endorsement adds the person or organization on the endorsement schedule as an insured for liability coverage to the extent that they qualify as such under Who Is an Insured.
CA 20 49–Additional
Insured–Garages–Grantor Of Franchise
This endorsement is used to add the grantor of a franchise as additional insured for liability insurance under Garage Operations–Other Than Covered Autos.
CA 20 54–Employee Hired Autos
This endorsement includes as an insured an employee who rents or hires a vehicle without an operator in his or her own name for the named insured's benefit.
CA 20 55–Fellow Employee Coverage
This endorsement deletes the fellow employee exclusion. As a result, coverage applies if one employee injures another employee in the course of performing their duties. However, the Workers Compensation and Employee Indemnification and Employers Liability exclusions are unaffected.
CA 20 56–Fellow Employee Coverage For Designated Employees/Positions
This endorsement is similar to CA 20 55–Fellow Employee Coverage but allows specific persons, job title or positions to appear on the endorsement schedule. As a result, only actions of scheduled persons, job titles or positions that cause injury to a fellow employee are covered. Actions of all other employees involving injury to a fellow employee remain excluded.
CA 20 70–Coverage For Certain Operations In Connection With Railroads
This endorsement deletes the two exceptions in the definition of insured contract that relate to construction or demolition operations within 50 feet of a railroad with respect to use of a covered auto in operations for or affecting the railroad and for the job site on the endorsement schedule. It is designed to match a similar extension in the ISO Commercial General Liability Coverage Forms.
CA 20 71–Auto Loan/Lease Gap Coverage
This endorsement changes the Physical Damage Coverage section. The
insurance company pays any unpaid amount due on the lease or loan in case of a
total loss to a covered auto on the endorsement schedule to which Auto
Loan/Lease Gap coverage applies and for which a premium is charged. This amount
is reduced by the amount paid under Physical Damage Coverage and certain other
specified charges or amounts.
Note: Most Uninsured and Underinsured Motorists Endorsements are mandated by each state and are not listed in this section.
CA 21 02–Split Bodily Injury Uninsured Motorist Coverage Limits
This endorsement revises CA 21 07–Split Uninsured Motorist Coverage Limits to apply to bodily injury only and eliminates all reference to property damage coverage.
CA 21 07–Split Uninsured Motorists Coverage Limits
This endorsement revises the limit of insurance section to provide separate uninsured motorists coverage limits for bodily injury per person, bodily injury per accident and property damage per accident instead of on a combined single limit basis.
CA 21 46–Split Underinsured Motorists Coverage Limits
This endorsement revises the limit of insurance section to provide separate underinsured motorists coverage limits for bodily injury per person, bodily injury per accident and property damage per accident instead of on a combined single limit basis.
CA 23 25–Coverage For Injury To Leased Workers
This endorsement amends the Employee Indemnification and Employer’s Liability exclusions so that the definition of employee does not include leased or temporary workers.
CA 23 84–Exclusion Of Terrorism
CA 23 85–Exclusion Of Terrorism Involving Nuclear, Biological Or
Chemical Terrorism
CA 23 86–Exclusion Of Terrorism Above Minimum Statutory Limits
CA 23 87–Exclusion Of Terrorism Involving Nuclear, Biological Or
Chemical Terrorism Above Minimum Statutory Limits
CA 23 94–Silica Or Silica-Related Dust Exclusion For Covered Autos
Exposure
This endorsement excludes bodily injury, property damage and expenses to respond to or assess silica or silica-related dust issues.
CA 23 97–Amphibious Vehicles (03 10 addition)
This endorsement excludes coverage for any vehicle that can be used on
both land and water. However, it applies only when the vehicle is on the water,
being launched, or while ashore.
CA 25 01–Broad Form
Products Coverage
This endorsement deletes the defective products exclusion in the Garage Coverage Form. Coverage on property damage to the named insured's products in any one accident is subject to a $250 deductible.
CA 25 02–Dealers
Driveaway Collision Coverage (03 10 change)
This endorsement deletes the exclusion for collision losses to covered autos driven more than 50 road miles from the purchase or distribution point to the destination for auto dealerships, subject to certain additional reporting requirements. The reporting requirements on the 03 10 edition were slightly changed.
CA 25 03–False
Pretense Coverage (03 10 change)
This endorsement deletes the False Pretense Exclusion in the Garage
Coverage Form and provides coverage for tricks and schemes that cause the named
insured to part with an owned auto. The $25,000 limit can be increased. The 03
10 edition removed the rate from the endorsement schedule.
CA 25 04–Fire, Fire
And Theft And Limited Specified Causes Of Loss Coverage For Dealers (03 10
change)
This endorsement is used to provide specified cause of loss coverage for
dealers and other specified interests, such as automobile manufacturers or financial
institutions. Causes of loss, parties and interests covered, limits,
deductibles and the types of vehicles covered must be indicated in the spaces
provided. The 03 10 edition revised the endorsement schedule to match the
revised garage declarations.
CA 25 05–Garage
Locations And Operations Medical Payments Coverage
This endorsement provides Medical Payments coverage for garage locations
and operations. It does not extend to the use of an auto.
CA 25 07–Locations And
Operations Not Covered
This endorsement excludes locations or operations indicated on the endorsement schedule from all coverage provided by the Garage Coverage Form.
CA 25 08–Personal
Injury Liability Coverage–Garages (03 10 change)
This endorsement adds personal injury coverage to the Garage Coverage
Form. It is similar to the Personal Injury Liability Coverage in the ISO
Commercial General Liability Coverage Form except for not including Advertising
Injury Liability Coverage. Changes
made in the 12 07 edition of the Commercial General Liability (CGL) Coverage
Form were added to this endorsement.
CA 25 09–Owners Of
Garage Premises
This endorsement adds the building owner of a leased garage premises indicated on the endorsement schedule as an additional insured.
CA 25 10–Damage To
Rented Premises Liability Coverage–Garages (03 10 change)
This is similar to damage
to Damage To Premises Rented To You coverage under the CGL Coverage Form. The
location, limit of insurance, and premium charge is entered in the spaces
provided on the endorsement schedule. The limit is $100,000 unless modified. The
03 10 edition changed the schedule and limit of insurance section.
CA 25 11–Named Driver
Collision Coverage
This endorsement adds Collision Coverage for the driver indicated on the endorsement schedule, subject to a deductible and premium charge.
CA 25 14–Broadened
Coverage–Garages
CA 25 16–Garage
Coverage Form–Other Than Covered Autos Exposure–Total Pollution Exclusion
This endorsement completely excludes pollution under the Garage Coverage Form. It applies only to garage operations and not to covered autos.
Note: This endorsement does not indicate that personal and advertising injury is excluded.
CA 25 18–Exclusion–Year
2000 Computer-Related And Other Electronic Problems
This endorsement excludes bodily injury, property damage and, where applicable, personal injury and advertising injury that arises in any way from actual or alleged failure of computer and electronic equipment to recognize the year 2000, later dates and similar problems.
CA 25
19–Exclusion–Year 2000 Computer-Related And Other Electronic
Problems–Products/Work You Performed
This endorsement excludes bodily injury and property damage caused by the named insured's products or work it performed that arises in any way from actual or alleged failure of computer and electronic equipment to recognize the year 2000, later dates, and similar problems.
CA 25 20–Year 2000
Limited Coverage Options–Computer-Related And Other Electronic Problems
This endorsement form gives the named insured a way to select coverage for bodily injury, property damage, and/or personal and advertising injury for specified locations, products, services or work it performed to be covered that are otherwise excluded under year 2000, later dates and similar problems.
CA 25
24–Exclusion–Year 2000 Computer-Related And Other Electronic Problems–With
Exception For Bodily Injury On Your Premises
This endorsement excludes all coverage except bodily injury on the named insured's premises that arises in any way from actual or alleged failure of computer and electronic equipment to recognize the year 2000, later dates, and similar problems.
CA 25 25–Year 2000
Computer-Related And Other Electronic Problems–Exclusion Of Specified Coverages
For Designated Locations, Products, Services Or Work You Performed
This endorsement form gives the named insured a way to select coverage for bodily injury, property damage, and/or personal and advertising injury for specified locations, products, services or work it performed to be excluded.
CA 25 36–Garage
Coverage Form–Other Than Covered Autos Exposure–Total Pollution Exclusion With
A Building Heating, Cooling And Dehumidifying Equipment Exception And A Hostile
Fire Exception
This is the same exclusion as CA 25 16 except that it has exceptions for
building heating, cooling and dehumidifying equipment and for hostile fires.
CA 25 37–Fungi Or
Bacteria Exclusion–Garage Operations–Other Than Covered Autos
This endorsement excludes bodily injury, property damage and, where
applicable, personal injury and advertising injury arising from any fungus or
bacteria not intended for human consumption. It also applies to expenses to
respond to the presence of fungi or bacteria. It applies only to Garage
Operations–Other Than Covered Autos.
CA 25 38–Limited Fungi
Or Bacteria Coverage For Garage Operations–Other Than Covered Autos
This endorsement amends the coverage provided to apply to bodily injury
or property damage arising out of an incident involving fungi or bacteria up to
the aggregate limit indicated on the endorsement schedule. Coverage does not
apply to personal injury or advertising injury. This exclusion does not apply
to incidents of food or beverage poisoning and applies only to Garage
Operations–Other Than Covered Autos.
CA 25 39–Silica Or
Silica-Related Dust Exclusion For Other Than Covered Autos Exposure–Garage
Coverage Form
This endorsement excludes bodily injury, property damage and, where applicable,
personal injury and advertising injury arising in any way from silica or
silica-related dust. It also applies to expenses to respond to the presence of
silica or silica-related dust.
CA 26 01–Single Interest Automobile Physical Damage Insurance Policy (Individual Policy Form)
This policy provides physical damage coverage to the seller of a vehicle for losses caused by the retail purchaser of the specific auto and applies only when the seller retains an interest in the vehicle because of a payment arrangement with the seller. It is a self-contained policy and applies specifically to one purchase.
CA 26 02–Single Interest Automobile Physical Damage Insurance Policy
(Finance Master Policy Form)
This policy provides physical damage coverage to the seller of vehicles for losses caused by the retail purchaser of those autos and applies only when the seller retains an interest in the vehicle because of a payment arrangement with the seller. It is a self-contained policy and applies on a blanket basis for dealers.
CA 26 05–Single Interest Deductible
This endorsement is used
with CA 26 01–Single Interest
Automobile Physical Damage Insurance Policy (Individual Policy Form) and CA 26
02–Single Interest Automobile Physical Damage Insurance Policy (Finance Master
Policy Form) to add either a $100 or $250 deductible to the physical
damage coverages provided by those single interest policies.
CA 99 03–Auto Medical Payments Coverage
CA 99 10–Drive Other Car Coverage–Broadened Coverage For Named
Individuals (03 10 change)
CA 99 14–Fire, Fire And Theft, Fire, Theft And Windstorm And Limited
Specified Causes Of Loss Coverages
This endorsement provides extremely limited physical damage coverage.
CA 99 16–Hired Autos Specified As Covered Autos You Own (03 10 change)
This endorsement treats any non-owned auto on the endorsement schedule as a covered auto for either liability or physical damage coverages. The symbols on the declarations determine whether these autos should also be indicated on the declarations.
Note: The 03 10 edition clarifies the intent of this endorsement but
does not change it.
CA 99 18–Individual
Named Insured–Dealers Only
This endorsement must be attached when the named insured is an individual. It extends the definition of named insured to include a spouse living in the same household.
CA 99 23–Rental Reimbursement Coverage (03 10 change)
This endorsement provides rental reimbursement coverage to covered autos on the endorsement schedule that sustain loss or damage from a covered cause of loss. The amount paid is subject to the maximum limit for any single day, the number of days and the total amount indicated for any one period. It is subject to several limitations or exclusions, such as coverage not applying if other spare or reserve autos are available for use.
Note: The 03 10 edition revises the schedule so that only one type of
auto can be designated.
CA 99 28–Stated Amount Insurance (03 10 change)
This endorsement has a stated amount of insurance for each vehicle on the endorsement schedule. As a result, physical damage losses are settled for the actual cash value, the cost to repair or replace, or the stated amount of insurance, whichever is least. While a cost savings accompanies this endorsement, the named insured must understand that the loss settlement may be for an amount less than the stated amount in some cases.
Note: The 03 10 edition separates the deductible and limit of insurance
sections for clarification purposes only.
CA 99 30–Tapes, Records And Discs Coverage (03 10 change)
This endorsement deletes the physical damage exclusion applying to tapes, records and discs and extends comprehensive coverage to apply to tapes, records and discs the named insured or a family member owns while in a covered auto at the time of loss for up to $200, without being subject to a deductible.
Note: The 03 10 edition adds a schedule to designate the vehicles this
endorsement applies to.
CA 99 33–Employees As
Insureds
This endorsement adds the named insured's employees as insureds when using an auto, the named insured does not own, hire or borrow in its business or personal affairs.
CA 99 38–Split
Liability Limits–Garages
This endorsement changes the limit of insurance for liability coverages from a single limit to split limits for bodily injury liability-each person, bodily injury liability-each accident and property damage liability-each accident.
CA 99 40–Exclusion Or Excess Coverage Hazards Otherwise Insured
This endorsement excludes coverage for a covered auto insured for liability coverage under another coverage form or policy or to make this coverage excess over the other coverage.
CA 99 44–Loss Payable Clause
This endorsement adds provisions that apply to loss payments when a loss payee is indicated on the policy.
CA 99 47–Employee As Lessor (03 10 change)
This endorsement adds the auto on the endorsement schedule as a covered owned auto and includes the employee who leases it to the named insured as an insured.
Note: The 03 10 edition removes the words “under the coverage for which
it is a covered auto.”
CA 99 54–Covered Auto Designation Symbol
This endorsement is used to add a covered auto symbol to any of the Business Auto Coverage Forms and to manuscript a definition for it to describe what is considered a covered auto.
CA 99 55–Pollution
Liability–Broadened Coverage For Covered Autos–Garage Coverage Form
This endorsement changes the liability pollution exclusion in the coverage form to provide pollution coverage assumed under a contract or agreement but only while the pollutants are in transit.
CA 99 59–Garagekeepers Coverage–Customers' Sound-Receiving Equipment
(03 10 change)
This coverage is similar to that provided under CA 99 37–Garagekeepers Coverage except that it applies only to customers’ sound-receiving equipment.
CA 99 60–Audio, Visual And Data Electronic Equipment Coverage Added
Limits (03 10 change)
This endorsement is changed from one that provides coverage
to one that allows scheduling of limits in excess of the $1,000 sub-limit for
audio, visual and data electronic equipment coverage provided in the coverage
form. The limit on the endorsement schedule is in addition to the sub-limit and
is not a replacement.
Note: Since this
endorsement does not amend the limit of insurance section of the coverage form,
it appears to still be a sub-limit and subject to the other limit of insurance
provisions. The lack of clarity may result in loss settlement confusion that
may benefit the named insured due to its ambiguity.
CA 99 61–Loss Payable Clause–Audio, Visual And Data Electronic
Equipment Added Limits (03 10 change)
This endorsement is changed from one that provides coverage to one that
allows scheduling of limits in excess of the $1,000 sub-limit for audio, visual
and data electronic equipment coverage provided in the coverage form. The limit
on the endorsement schedule is an addition to the sub-limit and is not a
replacement. Loss payment is for the benefit of the named insured and the
scheduled loss payee.
CA 99 90–Optional Limits–Loss Of Use Expenses (03 10 change)
This endorsement modifies the Physical Damage Loss Of Use Expense Coverage Extension limits of $20 per day with a $600 maximum. It allows a greater number of days and a higher maximum.
Note: The lead in language is the only change.
IL 00 03–Calculation Of Premium
This endorsement states that the insurance company uses the rules and rates in effect as of the policy renewal or anniversary date.
IL 00 17–Common Policy Conditions
This mandatory endorsement provides certain common policy conditions.
IL 00 21–Nuclear Energy Liability Exclusion Endorsement (Broad Form)
This endorsement excludes hazards relating to nuclear energy liability and is attached to all policies.
IL 09 11–Supplement To Retrospective Premium Endorsement-Final Premium
Computation
This endorsement eliminates the requirement to make calculations of the retrospective premium final when attached to a policy subject to the Retrospective Premium Endorsement. It also clarifies the premium calculation intervals.
IL 09 18–Retrospective Premium Endorsement–One Year Plan–Multiple Lines
This endorsement provides for retrospective rating of a policy and contains a schedule used to develop the premium for a one-year plan.
IL 09 19–Retrospective Premium Endorsement–Three Year Plan–Multiple
Lines
This endorsement provides for retrospective rating of a policy and contains a schedule used to develop the premium for a three-year plan.
IL 09 20–Retrospective Premium Endorsement–Long-Term Construction
Project–Multiple Lines
This endorsement provides for retrospective rating of long-term construction projects and contains a schedule used to develop the premium.
IL 09 21–Retrospective Premium Endorsement–Short Form
This endorsement permits addition of a policy to an existing retrospective premium endorsement rating procedure.
IL 09 22–Exclusion Of Aviation Exposures
This endorsement exempts the scheduled aviation exposures from the retrospective rating plan.
IL 09 23–Retrospective Premium Endorsement–Exclusion Of Retrospective
Development Factors
This endorsement deletes reference to any Retrospective Development Factors in the states scheduled.
IL 12 01–Common Policy Changes
This generic change endorsement permits various changes that affect all coverages provided in the policy.
This comparison of the Insurance Services Office CG 00 01–Commercial General Liability Coverage Form with ISO CA 00 05–Garage Coverage Form and CA 25 14–Broadened Coverage–Garages follows the Commercial General Liability Coverage Form arrangement.
Coverage Form Feature |
CG 00 01 12 07 |
CA 00 05 03 10 & CA 25 14 03 10 |
|
Section I–Coverages |
|
|
|
Coverage A–Bodily
Injury And Property Damage Liability |
All sums the insured is legally obligated to pay due to bodily injury or property damage. The insurance coverage form must apply. |
Same except the BI or PD must be related to the garage operations and not covered autos. |
|
Coverage A–Bodily Injury And Property Damage Liability (cont.) |
Legal defense provided for covered occurrences. The company decides when it investigates or settles claims but efforts end when insurance is exhausted by payment of judgments. |
Same |
|
Coverage A–Bodily Injury And Property Damage Liability (cont.) |
The bodily injury or property damage must be due to an occurrence that takes place in the coverage territory and during the policy period. |
The bodily injury or property damage is covered if an accident takes place in the coverage territory during the policy period. |
|
Coverage A–Bodily Injury And Property Damage Liability (cont.) |
Prior knowledge limitations and damages due to loss of services, loss or care, and death are included as damages from bodily injury. |
Same with respect to prior knowledge limitations, but no references to consequential loss of service. |
|
Exclusions |
|
|
|
Expected Or Intended Injury |
No coverage if damages are due to bodily injury or property damage expected or intended by the named insured except for reasonable force to protect persons or property. |
Same |
|
Contractual Liability |
No coverage for assumed
liability from a contract except if liability existed regardless of contract
or an insured contract prior to the loss. |
Same with respect to assumed liability. No similar reference to assumption of defense costs. |
|
Liquor Liability |
Applies only if the named insured is engaged in any aspect of the liquor business |
No corresponding exclusion |
|
Coverage Form Feature |
CG 00 01 12 07 |
CA 00 05 03 10 & CA 25 14 03 10 |
|
Workers Compensation And Similar Laws |
No coverage for workers compensation, disability benefits, or similar obligations |
Same |
|
Employers’ Liability |
Injuries while working/performing duties or for injured employee’s family are excluded. Coverage applies if assumed under an insured contract. |
Same |
|
Employers’ Liability (cont.) |
No corresponding language |
The entire exclusion does not apply to domestic employees not subject to workers compensation. |
|
Employers’ Liability (cont.) |
No corresponding
language–similar to |
No coverage for any employment related practices such as termination, refusal to employ, harassment, etc. |
|
Pollution |
No coverage except for hostile fire, equipment to heat, cool or dehumidify the building, material brought to a premises in connection with operations performed by named insured or on named insured’s behalf. No coverage for expenses due to any regulatory requirements to test, etc. |
Essentially the same |
|
Aircraft, Auto Or Watercraft |
No coverage for any aspect of aircraft,
auto or watercraft ownership or operation, including allegations of improper
supervision
|
Similar provision, but applies to aircraft and watercraft only–no reference to auto or allegations of improper supervision |
|
Aircraft, Auto, Or Watercraft (cont.) |
Coverage applies to watercraft on shore, non-owned watercraft less than 26 feet long, parking non-owned autos on premises, liability assumed under contract and mobile equipment. |
Coverage applies to watercraft on shore and non-owned watercraft less than 26 feet long. No reference to auto or mobile equipment in exclusion so no need for an exception |
|
Mobile Equipment |
Excludes transporting equipment with owned or rented auto or for use of mobile equipment in racing and similar events |
No corresponding exclusion |
|
War |
Excluded |
Same |
|
Damage To Property |
No coverage for property damage to property the named insured owns, rents or occupies, including costs to improve safety |
Same, except no corresponding language for costs to improve safety |
|
Damage To Property (cont.) |
No coverage for property damage to any property sold, abandoned or given away unless the named insured built it and never occupied it |
No corresponding language |
|
Damage To Property (cont.) |
No coverage for any loaned property |
Same |
|
Damage To Property (cont.) |
No coverage for care, custody or control or personal property or real property being worked on if damaged by the named insured’s work except assumed sidetrack liability |
Similar, as it applies to all, and not to just personal property. No reference to real property |
|
Damage To Property (cont.) |
No coverage for any property damaged because of the named insured’s faulty work, unless covered under the products/completed operations hazard or assumed sidetrack liability |
Same but no exceptions |
|
Coverage Form Feature |
CG 00 01 12 07 |
CA 00 05 03 10 & CA 25 14 03 10 |
|
Damage To Property (cont.) |
Coverage applies to items 1, 3, and 4 rented to a named insured if the rental is for seven or fewer consecutive days. The maximum limit is the applicable Damage To Premises Rented To You Limit. |
Refer to Fire Legal Liability Coverage |
|
Damage To Property (cont.) |
Coverage applies to item 2 if it was built to sell and was never occupied. |
No corresponding language |
|
Damage To Your Product |
No coverage for property damage to the named insured's own product due to it or any part of it |
Similar |
|
Damage To Your Work |
No coverage for property damage to the named insured’s work that arises from the work or any part of it |
Similar |
|
Damage To Impaired Property Or Property Not Physically Injured |
No coverage for loss of use of property if there is no property damage |
Same |
|
Recall Of Products, Work Or Impaired Property |
No coverage for any type of product recall |
Same |
|
Personal And Advertising Injury |
No coverage for any bodily injury arising out of personal and advertising injury |
No specific exclusion but CA 25 14 provides this coverage |
|
Electronic Data |
No coverage for damage caused by the loss or loss of use of electronic data |
No corresponding exclusion |
|
Fellow Employee |
No corresponding exclusion |
No coverage for injuries to fellow employees |
|
Distribution of Material In Violation Of Statutes |
No coverage for injury or damage due to violations of TCPA or CAN-SPAM Acts |
Same |
|
Coverage B–Personal And Advertising Injury Liability |
Pays damages an insured
must pay that involve personal injuries or certain advertising-related
activities that qualify for coverage, including cost of legal defense. |
Part of CA 25 14–Broadened Coverage–Garages |
|
Exclusions |
|
|
|
Knowing Violation Of Rights Of Another |
No coverage for an insured who knowingly injured a person by violating that person’s rights |
Part of CA 25 14–Broadened Coverage–Garages |
|
Material Published With Knowledge Of Falsity |
No coverage for communicating information in any way that an insured knows is false |
Part of CA 25 14–Broadened Coverage–Garages |
|
Material Published Prior To Policy Period |
No coverage for damage or injury related to publication date that is earlier than the policy period |
Part of CA 25 14–Broadened Coverage–Garages |
|
Criminal Acts |
No coverage for any criminal act by any insured or at any insured’s direction |
Part of CA 25 14–Broadened Coverage–Garages |
|
Coverage Form Feature |
CG 00 01 12 07 |
CA 00 05 03 10 & CA 25 14 03 10 |
|
Breach Of Contract |
No coverage for breach of contract unless it was due to an implied contract with respect to the use of advertising ideas |
Part of CA 25 14–Broadened Coverage–Garages |
|
Quality Or Performance Of Goods–Failure To Conform To Statements |
No coverage if the products advertised do not do what they are supposed to do |
Part of CA 25 14–Broadened Coverage–Garages |
|
Wrong Description Of Prices |
No coverage due to mistakes in prices of items in advertisements |
Part of CA 25 14–Broadened Coverage–Garages |
|
Infringement of Patent, Copyright, Trademark Or Trade Secret |
No coverage for infringement except in the named insured’s advertisements |
Part of CA 25 14–Broadened Coverage–Garages |
|
Insureds In Media And Internet Type Businesses |
No coverage for anyone in the advertising or media, web designer, or internet search provider business. Certain web design aspects are included. These businesses are covered for only “personal injury” type offenses. |
Part of CA 25 14–Broadened Coverage–Garages |
|
Electronic Chatrooms Or Bulletin Boards |
No coverage for anything that takes place on bulletin boards, chatrooms or any similar area the insured hosts or controls |
Part of CA 25 14–Broadened Coverage–Garages |
|
Unauthorized Use Of Another’s Name Or Product |
No coverage if another’s name is used in any internet communications in order to mislead the marketplace |
Part of CA 25 14–Broadened Coverage–Garages |
|
Pollution |
No coverage for pollution |
Part of CA 25
14–Broadened Coverage–Garages |
|
Pollution-Related |
No coverage for pollution cleanup costs or expense |
Part of CA 25
14–Broadened Coverage–Garages |
|
Employment Related |
Not mentioned but often excluded using CG 21 47 |
No coverage for employment related offenses. |
|
War |
Excluded |
Same |
|
Distribution of Material In Violation Of Statutes |
No coverage for injury or damage due to violations of TCPA or CAN-SPAM Acts |
Same |
|
Coverage C–Medical Payments |
All medical expenses
incurred due to accidents either on or next to owned or rented premises or
due to operations. |
No Medical Payments coverage in either form. CA 25 05–Garage Locations And Operations Medical Payments Coverage provides this coverage. |
|
Exclusions |
|
|
|
Any Insured |
Only volunteer workers are covered |
No Medical Payments coverage in either form |
|
Hired Person |
No coverage for any person hired to work for any insured or any tenant |
No Medical Payments coverage in either form |
|
Coverage Form Feature |
CG 00 01 12 07 |
CA 00 05 03 10 & CA 25 14 03 10 |
|
Injury On Normally Occupied Premises |
No coverage for persons injured in space they normally occupy |
No Medical Payments coverage in either form |
|
Workers Compensation And Similar Laws |
No coverage if the injured party is eligible for workers compensation or other benefits |
No Medical Payments coverage in either form |
|
Athletic Activities |
No coverage if the party was injured while participating in exercise or athletic activities |
No Medical Payments coverage in either form |
|
Products-Completed Operations Hazard |
No coverage if the accident was part of the products-completed operations hazard |
No Medical Payments coverage in either form |
|
Coverage A Exclusions |
No coverage if the injury is a type excluded under bodily injury and property damage coverage |
No Medical Payments
coverage in either form |
|
Supplementary Payments–Coverages A And B |
|
|
|
Insurance Company Expenses |
All are paid |
Same |
|
Bail Bonds |
Up to $250. Does not furnish bonds |
Up to $2,000. Does not furnish bonds |
|
Bonds To Release Attachments |
Costs of bonds up to the limit of insurance |
Same |
|
Insured's expenses incurred at the company's request |
All reasonable expenses plus loss of earnings up to $250 per day |
Same |
|
Insured's court costs in a suit |
All are paid except for attorney’s fees and expenses taxed by the court |
Same |
|
Prejudgment interest |
All are paid unless the company offers the policy limits |
No corresponding language |
|
Post judgment Interest |
All are paid based on the limit of insurance |
Same |
|
Third party supplementary payments |
Paid subject to meeting numerous stipulations. However, all payments are within policy limits |
No corresponding language |
|
Section II–Who is An Insured |
|
|
|
Individual |
Named insured and spouse |
Same |
|
Partnership |
Named insured, partners and partners' spouses |
Similar, but partners and spouses are not covered for personal and advertising injury |
|
Joint venture |
Named insured and members |
No corresponding language |
|
Limited liability company |
Named insured, members and managers |
Same and including spouses but does not mention managers |
|
Other organization |
Named insured, executive officers, directors and stockholders |
Same |
|
Trust |
Named insured and trustees |
No corresponding language |
|
Volunteer workers and employees |
Covered but with significant limitations |
Employees are covered but volunteer workers are not mentioned. No limitations |
|
Newly acquired or formed organizations |
Coverage applies for up to 90 days following the acquisition or formation but not for any prior occurrences or offenses |
Similar |
|
Coverage Form Feature |
CG 00 01 12 07 |
CA 00 05 03 10 CA & 25 14 03 10 |
|
Section III–Limits Of Insurance |
|
|
|
Limits on the declarations |
The limits on the declarations are the most paid regardless of number of insureds, suits or claims. |
Same |
|
General Aggregate Limit |
The General Aggregate Limit is the most paid during the policy period for all coverages except products/completed operations that has its own separate limit. |
Same except medical payments is a separate endorsement and not part of the aggregate. All coverages provided in CA 25 14–Broadened Coverages–Garages are part of the aggregate. |
|
Products-Completed Operations Aggregate Limit |
Products-Completed Operations Aggregate Limit is the most paid during the policy period for all such damages. |
No separate aggregate. Products-Completed Operations are subject to the general aggregate. |
|
Personal And Advertising Injury Limit |
Personal And Advertising Injury Limit is the most paid for all such damage and is subject to the deductible and the General Aggregate Limit. |
Same |
|
Each Occurrence Limit |
This is the most paid for all damages for all bodily injury, property damage, medical payments and fire legal in a single incident. It is subject to either of the two aggregates. |
Garage uses an Each Accident Limit that is the most paid for all damages under all coverages. Medical Payments remain separate. |
|
Damage To Premises Rented to You Limit |
The per-premises limit is $50,000 and is subject to the occurrence limit. It can be increased. |
The per-premises limit is $100,000 and is subject to the aggregate limit. It can be increased. |
|
Medical Expense Limit |
This is the most paid for all medical expenses due to bodily injury to one person. |
No corresponding language |
|
Application of Aggregate Limit |
Aggregates apply for the duration of the policy term, whether it is 12 months, less than 12 months, more than 12 months, or an extended policy period. |
Same |
|
Deductible |
No corresponding language |
A $100 property damage deductible applies to damage caused by work the named insured performed on a vehicle. |
|
Section IV–Commercial General Liability Conditions |
|
|
|
Bankruptcy |
Bankruptcy or insolvency of the insured does not relieve the insurance company of its obligations. |
Same |
|
Duties In The Event Of Occurrence, Offense, Claim Or Suit |
A number of duties of the named insured are required to ensure that the company’s rights are protected and that it is notified promptly. |
Similar |
|
Legal Action Against Us |
The named insured cannot sue the insurance company until all terms and conditions in the coverage form are met. |
Same |
|
Coverage Form Feature |
CG 00 01 12 07 |
CA 00 05 03 10 & CA 25 14 03 10 |
|
Other Insurance |
This coverage is
primary unless the other coverage is for fire, extended coverage, builders’
risk, installation risk, insured’s work or for loss due to maintenance or use
of aircraft, autos or watercraft. |
Primary, but the company pays only the fair proportion of the loss whether other coverage is primary or excess |
|
Premium Audit |
Premiums are estimates and may be audited. |
Similar. However, if the policy term is for more than one year, premium must be recalculated at the beginning of each policy year. |
|
Representations |
The named insured agrees that the statements on the declarations are accurate and complete, are based on its representations, and that coverage is issued relying on those representations. |
Insurance is void if there is any fraud on the part of the named insured or if there is intentional concealment or misrepresentation regarding the coverage or any claims. |
|
Separation Of Insureds |
Each insured is treated as though it is the only insured, except with respect to the maximum limit payable. The first named insured has certain assigned rights, but it does not affect the handling of claims. |
The definition of insured includes a separation of insured statement. |
|
Transfer Of Rights Of Recovery Against Others To Us |
All rights of recovery transfer to the company and the insured is not to interfere with them. |
Same except it does not apply for medical payments coverage |
|
When We Do Not Renew |
Insurance company gives at least 30 days notice to the first named insured before non-renewing. |
No corresponding language |
|
Liberalization |
No corresponding language |
Any revision to the coverage without an additional premium charge automatically extends to coverage effective as of its approval date. |
|
Two Or More Coverage Forms Or Policies Issued By Us |
No corresponding language |
The highest applicable limit acts as the single, maximum limit, regardless of the number of coverage forms or policies. |
|
Coverage Form Feature |
CG 00 01 12 07 |
CA 00 05 03 10 & CA 25 14 03 10 |
|
Section
V–Definitions |
|
|
|
Advertisement |
Information publicly broadcast in any medium to attract customer sales. If on the Internet, only the part of the website that attracts customers is considered an advertisement. |
Same but no reference to website or electronic publications |
|
Auto |
A land motor vehicle intended for use on public roads, including trailers, semi-trailers and attached machinery but not mobile equipment |
Similar but no limitation for use on public roads and no reference to machinery and equipment or mobile equipment |
|
Bodily Injury |
Any sickness, disease or other injury to the body of a person, including that person's death resulting from an injury, sickness, or disease |
Same but also includes incidental medical malpractice provided the insured is not in the health care business |
|
Coverage Territory |
The United States of
America and its territories and possessions, Canada and Puerto Rico. Suits
must be brought in these places. |
Not a defined term It is part of the policy conditions. Similar but no reference to the Internet |
|
Employee |
Leased workers are considered employees. Temporary workers are not. |
Same |
|
Executive Officer |
Any person who occupies an officer’s position as provided for in the company charters, by-laws or a similar document |
No corresponding definition |
|
Hostile Fire |
Any fire that escapes its confines |
No corresponding definition |
|
Impaired Property |
Property made useless or less useful because it has one of the named insured's products that is defective or dangerous or because the named insured did not fulfill a service contract and the property can regain its usefulness if the named insured repairs the product or fulfills the contract |
No corresponding definition |
|
Insured Contract |
Insured contract
includes leases of premises, sidetrack agreements, easement or license
agreements, obligations required by ordinance, elevator maintenance
agreements and tort liability assumed by contract. |
Same except for adding contracts that loan, lease or rent a car with a driver are not insured contracts and that any contract that holds someone harmless who has a public authority to transport goods and the insured is hired to transport for that firm is also not an insured contract. |
|
Leased Worker |
A person contracted to work for the named insured through a leasing agency but not a temporary worker |
Same |
|
Coverage Form Feature |
CG 00 01 12 07 |
CA 00 05 03 10 & CA 25 14 03 10 |
|
Loading or unloading |
Handling items starting at the point where they are accepted and ending at the point of delivery. Does not include the use of mechanical devices not attached to aircraft, watercraft or auto |
No corresponding definition |
|
Mobile equipment |
A variety of land vehicles intended for use off public roads |
No corresponding definition |
|
Occurrence |
An accident including continuous exposure to the same conditions |
No corresponding definition but the definition of accident is similar |
|
Personal and advertising injury |
False arrest, wrongful prosecution, improper invasion of tenants’ rights, slander, libel, violation of rights, use of ideas of others in advertising, infringement of copyright, etc., of others in advertising |
Same |
|
Pollutants |
Any solid, liquid, thermal or gaseous irritant or contaminant, including waste |
Same |
|
Products-completed operations hazard |
Any bodily injury or property damage due to products or work except products still in the named insured's possession and work it has not yet completed |
No corresponding definition |
|
Property damage |
Physical damage to and loss of use of property and loss of use of property not physically damaged. Electronic data is not considered tangible property. |
Property damage to tangible property or its loss of use |
|
Suit |
Any civil proceeding including arbitration and other alternative dispute resolutions where injury or damage is alleged |
Same |
|
Temporary worker |
A person who substitutes for a regular employee or is hired for a short term or seasonal situation |
Same |
|
Volunteer worker |
One who works as an employee but is not compensated |
No corresponding definition |
|
Your product |
Goods sold, made, handled, distributed or disposed of by the named insured or on its behalf, including their containers. All warranties and instructions are part of the products. |
Similar but defined as
“product”. |
|
Your work |
Any work done by the named insured, on its behalf, and all materials included in the process. It includes warranties and instructions |
Similar but defined as “work you performed”. No reference to warranties or materials and parts. |
|
Accident |
No corresponding definition |
Similar to “occurrence” |
|
Customers auto |
No corresponding definition |
Any "auto" left by a customer including employees and their families who leave vehicles and will pay for services |
|
Diminution in value |
No corresponding definition |
Loss of value of a vehicle due to an accident. Loss may be actual or perceived. |
|
Coverage Form Feature |
CG 00 01 12 07 |
CA 00 05 03 10 & CA 25 14 03 10 |
|
Garage operations |
No corresponding
definition |
All premises associated
with a garage business and adjoining roadways and all operations needed to
conduct garage operations |
|
Insured |
No corresponding definition |
Any person or organization in the "Who Is An Insured" provision |
|
Loss |
No corresponding definition |
Any accidental but direct loss or damage. Under Garagekeepers coverage, loss of use is considered part of the loss. |
|
Products |
No corresponding definition |
Goods or products the named insured made or sold in its garage business, including providing or failing to provide warnings or instructions |
|
Trailer |
No corresponding definition |
Trailer includes semitrailers |
|
Work you performed |
No corresponding definition |
Includes work done by others on the named insured's behalf, including providing or failing to provide warnings or instructions |
|
Garage Coverages not referenced in the CGL |
|
|
|
Host Liquor Liability Coverage |
No specific reference but coverage is similar due to the wording of the liquor liability exclusion |
Any serving of alcohol incidental to the garage operations is covered for bodily injury and property damage if the named insured is not in the liquor business |
|
Incidental Medical Malpractice Liability Coverage |
No specific reference but not excluded. A professional exclusion is needed to exclude professional health care services. |
Coverage is provided
for injury due to providing or failing to provide health care services,
giving food/drink for health care services or giving drugs or other medical
devices. |
|
This summary comparison is brief and not as thorough as the detailed analyses for each of these coverage forms.
CA 00 01–Business Auto Coverage Form has five sections. CA 00 05–Garage Coverage Form has six. The additional section in CA 00 05 is Garagekeepers Coverage. This comparison follows the Business Auto Coverage Form and addresses Garagekeepers Coverage last.
Description Of Covered
Auto Designation Symbols
Both coverage forms open with a description of covered auto designation symbols. The definitions in both forms are similar but several definitions in the Garage Coverage Form are unique.
Symbol
Comparison |
||
Symbol Meaning |
CA 00 01–Business
Auto |
CA 00 05–Garage |
Any Auto |
1 |
21 |
Owned Autos Only |
2 |
22 |
Owned Private Passenger Autos Only |
3 |
23 |
Owned Autos Other Than Private Passenger Autos Only |
4 |
24 |
Owned Autos Subject To No-Fault |
5 |
25 |
Owned Autos Subject To Compulsory Uninsured Motorists Law |
6 |
26 |
Specifically Described Autos |
7 |
27 |
Hired Autos Only |
8 |
28 |
Non-Owned Autos Only |
9 |
N/A |
Non-Owned Autos Used In Your Garage Business |
N/A |
29 |
Mobile Equipment Subject To Compulsory Or Financial Responsibility Or Other Motor Vehicle Insurance Law Only |
19 |
N/A |
Autos Left With You For Service, Repair, Storage Or Safekeeping |
N/A |
30 |
Dealers Autos (Physical Damage Coverages) |
N/A |
31 |
Note: The definition of Non-Owned is slightly different and more limited in the Garage Coverage Form. Symbol 9 in the Business Auto Coverage Form includes only non-owned autos used in the named insured’s business or its personal affairs. Symbol 29 in the Garage Coverage Form includes only non-owned autos used in the named insured's garage business.
Owned Autos You
Acquire After The Policy Begins
These symbols determine if coverage applies to newly acquired autos.
· Business Auto Coverage Form symbols 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 19 extend coverage to similar autos the named insured acquires during the policy term. Symbol 7 extends coverage to similar autos acquired during the policy term if all owned vehicles are scheduled and insured, or if the acquisition replaces one of them and the named insured notifies the insurance company of the acquisition within 30 days of the acquisition date.
· Garage Coverage Form symbols 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 and 26 extend coverage to similar autos the named insured acquires during the policy term. Symbol 27 extends coverage to similar autos acquired during the policy term if all owned vehicles are scheduled and insured, or if the acquisition replaces one of them and the named insured notifies the insurance company of the acquisition within 30 days of the acquisition date.
Certain Trailers,
Mobile Equipment And Temporary Substitute Autos
This is liability coverage only. While the coverage provided for trailers and substitute autos is the same in both coverage forms, the Garage Coverage Form does not mention mobile equipment while being towed or carried by a covered auto because this coverage form does not exclude mobile equipment.
The liability insurance provided under the Garage Coverage Form is split between the Garage Operations–Other Than Covered Autos and Garage Operations–Covered Autos sections. Since this is an auto comparison, all references are to only the Auto portion.
All coverages are identical except that the Garage Coverage Form requires that an accident result from garage operations and involve ownership, maintenance or use of covered autos. The Business Auto Coverage Form only requires that an accident involve ownership, maintenance or use of a covered auto.
Who Is An Insured
Both coverage forms list the same groups of insureds, but the Garage Coverage Form changes a few items to correspond to those business operations.
Coverage Extensions
This section is identical in both forms.
Exclusions
These exclusions apply to both forms:
Note: The Garage Coverage Form also excludes property owned, rented or occupied by the insured, property loaned to the insured, and property held for sale or being transported by the insured.
Note: The Garage Coverage Form separates this into two exclusions.
These exclusions apply to only the Garage Coverage Form:
Limit Of Insurance
This section is identical for the Covered Autos section.
Coverage
This section is identical in both forms. The three Physical Damage coverage options are:
Note: Towing coverage applies if indicated on the declarations. However, it is not available for dealerships.
Exclusions
These exclusions apply to both forms:
These exclusions apply only to the Garage Coverage Form:
Limit of Insurance
Both coverage forms address the impact of depreciation, actual cash value, and repair and replacement. A dealership has a special limit of insurance that provides for a maximum loss at a particular location and a maximum loss on property in transit. Reporting provisions apply to dealerships and accuracy and timeliness of reports determines the limits available.
Deductible
Both coverage forms address how deductibles are applied in case of loss. Dealerships have a maximum per loss deductible that must appear on the declarations.
These conditions are similar in both coverage forms:
Loss Conditions
Loss Conditions
Note: The Garage Coverage Form adds worldwide products coverage.
These definitions are similar in both coverage forms:
Note: The Garage Coverage Form includes Commercial General Liability-related contracts.
The definition of Mobile equipment is in only the Business Auto Coverage Form.
These definitions are in only the Garage Coverage Form:
This section is unique to the Garage Coverage Form. It insures the garage's customers’ vehicles on either a direct damage or a legal liability basis.
1. How do these coverage forms handle coverage for trailers, substitute autos, and mobile equipment?
2. Briefly describe Section II–Liability Coverage in these two coverage forms.
3. Is there any difference between the two coverage forms with respect to "Who Is An Insured"?
4. Name the Physical Damage Coverage exclusions that are only in the Garage Coverage Form.
5. Compare the symbols used to describe covered autos in these two coverage forms.
1. Both coverage forms provide identical coverage for trailers and substitute autos. The Garage Coverage Form does not mention mobile equipment because it does not exclude mobile equipment.
2. The liability insurance provided under the Garage Coverage Form is split between the Garage Operations–Other Than Covered Autos and Garage Operations–Covered Autos sections. All coverages are identical except that the Garage Coverage Form requires that an accident result from garage operations and involve ownership, maintenance or use of covered autos. The Business Auto Coverage Form only requires that an accident involve ownership, maintenance or use of a covered auto.
3. Both coverage forms list the same groups of insureds, but the Garage Coverage Form changes a few items to correspond to those business operations.
4. The Physical Damage Coverage exclusions that are only in the Garage Coverage Form are:
5. Both coverage forms open with a description of covered auto designation symbols. The definitions in both forms are similar but several definitions in the Garage Coverage Form are unique.
Symbol
Comparison |
||
Symbol Meaning |
CA 00 01–Business
Auto |
CA 00 05–Garage |
Any Auto |
1 |
21 |
Owned Autos Only |
2 |
22 |
Owned Private Passenger Autos Only |
3 |
23 |
Owned Autos Other Than Private Passenger Autos Only |
4 |
24 |
Owned Autos Subject To No-Fault |
5 |
25 |
Owned Autos Subject To Compulsory Uninsured Motorists Law |
6 |
26 |
Specifically Described Autos |
7 |
27 |
Hired Autos Only |
8 |
28 |
Non-Owned Autos Only |
9 |
N/A |
Non-Owned Autos Used In Your Garage Business |
N/A |
29 |
Mobile Equipment Subject To Compulsory Or Financial Responsibility Or Other Motor Vehicle Insurance Law Only |
19 |
N/A |
Autos Left With You For Service, Repair, Storage Or Safekeeping |
N/A |
30 |
Dealers Autos (Physical Damage Coverages) |
N/A |
31 |
This is a summary of the changes made in the 03 10 edition of CA 00 05–Garage Coverage Form. Most of the changes reduce coverage.
A.4.a. Supplementary Payment
This is a reduction in coverage because attorney’s fees or expenses taxed against the insured by the courts are specifically not covered.
B. Exclusions
4. The Employee Indemnification and Employers Liability exclusion is broadened to explain that the time the event occurs has no impact on coverage. It can occur before, during or following employment.
5. The Fellow Employee exclusion is broadened to also exclude coverage for any consequential damage claims by relatives of an injured fellow employee.
A.4. Coverage
Extensions
This is a reduction in coverage because attorney’s fees or expenses taxed against the insured by the courts are specifically not covered.
C. Limits of Insurance
And Deductibles
This adds a clarification stating that the deductible is applied prior to the limit of insurance cap.
B. Exclusions
The last two items of the Excluded Property exclusion have major changes.
2.e. and 2.f . Electronic Equipment And Accessories
The exception for equipment used solely to reproduce sound is eliminated. This is a reduction in coverage for both the equipment and its accessories.
3. Changes to Exclusion 2
This is a new exclusion. It was previously part of Exclusion 2. It details the items excepted from Exclusions 2.c and 2.d. In order for the exception to apply, the item must operate only from the auto’s electrical system and meet any of the following criteria at the time of loss:
7. Other Exclusion
This exclusion is rewritten to apply only if damage is confined to the described causes of loss. It also does not apply when the entire vehicle is stolen. The corresponding exclusion in the previous edition did not use the word confined but it did not apply if any cause of loss occurred first or at the same time. There was no specific reference to the auto being stolen.
C. Limit Of Insurance
A $1,000 sub-limit that applies to the items described as covered under Excluded Property Exclusion 3. Changes To Exclusion 2 is added. This change means that, although coverage might be provided, the total amount of damages paid is limited to $1,000. This could be a significant reduction of coverage.
The definition of Customer’s Auto changed and is both broadened and restricted. The vehicle is now covered even if the customer does not know that it is in the named insured’s possession. This could be considered a broadening of coverage. However, the purpose of the possession having to be lawful might be considered a restriction of coverage.
1. Under the Garage Coverage Form, does the insurance company have to defend the insured if a person sues stating that she was denied a job due to her gender?
2. How was the Fellow Employee exclusion changed?
3. What two major changes affect claims for damage to electronic equipment?
4. Why is the change in the definition of customer’s auto both a broadening and a restriction?
1. The Employee Indemnification And Employers Liability Exclusion excludes all such claims. The 03 10 Edition clarifies that coverage does not apply if the action took place before, during or after hiring.
2. The Fellow Employee exclusion was broadened to exclude consequential injury claims from relatives of an injured fellow employee.
3. The electronic equipment exclusion no longer excepts all equipment that only reproduces sound, although it does cover similar to equipment that receives and transmits data. A $1,000 sub-limit applies to all covered electronic equipment.
4. Under the new definition, the vehicle is now covered even if the customer does not know that it is in the named insured’s possession. This could be considered a broadening of coverage. However, the purpose of the possession having to be lawful might be considered a restriction of coverage.
Garage operations are unusual because the lines between their general liability and automobile liability exposures blur and overlap in some areas. The Insurance Services Office (ISO) developed CA 00 05–Garage Coverage Form covers both exposures under a single coverage form while eliminating coverage gaps and overlaps. It covers premises liability, products liability, automobile liability, and physical damage to covered autos, as well as garagekeepers coverage for customer's autos. A number of endorsements are available to broaden or restrict coverage.
This analysis is based
the 03/06 edition of this coverage form. Changes from the previous edition
are in bold print.
CA 00 05 opens by defining the terms you or your as the named insured and we, us and our as the insurance company providing the coverage. Named insured is not defined. As a result, it means only the entities indicated on the declarations.
Numerical symbols are used to determine the autos insured and the coverages provided. These symbols are defined in the Description Of Covered Auto Designation Symbols.
The sample Garage Declarations has spaces in which to insert the symbol or symbols next to each of the business auto coverages. The only coverages provided are those having a symbol or symbols indicated and only those autos designated by the symbol or symbols are covered autos for that coverage.
A. Description Of
Covered Auto Designation Symbols
21–Any Auto
This is the broadest symbol designation and has no limitations or restrictions. Vehicles defined as autos in this coverage form are covered, subject to certain exclusions and conditions. Because of the broad scope of the coverage provided, many insurance companies are reluctant to use this symbol. Even if a company uses it for liability, it may not do so for physical damage. No other symbol should appear in the same box when Symbol 21 is used.
Note: Section VI–Definitions defines auto as a land motor vehicle, trailer or semitrailer.
22–Owned Autos Only
This symbol means that any auto the named insured owns is covered, including those acquired after the inception date. In addition, any owned or non-owned trailer pulled by an owned vehicle is also covered if this symbol is used with liability coverage.
Note: The definition of trailer includes semitrailers. See Section VI–Definitions.
23–Owned Private Passenger Autos Only
All private passenger type autos that the named insured owns are covered when this symbol is used. This includes any private passenger type vehicle acquired after the inception date.
24–Owned Autos Other Than Private Passenger Autos Only
This symbol indicates that all autos other than private passenger types that the named insured owns are covered, as well as those acquired after the inception date. Similar to Symbol 22 above, the liability coverage provided is extended to any owned or non-owned trailer pulled by this type of owned vehicle.
Example: Paula's Pre-Owned Autos is insured under CA 00 05–Garage Coverage Form. Paula's sells and services autos. A new mechanic takes a one-ton stake truck, visits several junkyards, and purchases some used parts and equipment. By the time he gets to the last one, the truck is already loaded but this is where he needs to pick up an engine block needed that day. The junkyard owner loads the engine block on one of his trailers and attaches it to Paula's truck. As long as it is attached to the truck, it is covered under Paula's Garage Coverage Form. |
25–Owned Autos Subject To No-Fault
This symbol applies to vehicles licensed or garaged in a state where no fault coverage is available but only to autos required to have such coverage. Coverage also extends to such autos acquired after the inception date in addition to those the named insured owned on the inception date.
26–Owned Autos Subject To A Compulsory Uninsured Motorists Law
This symbol applies to any auto the named insured owns garaged or licensed in a state that requires the named insured to carry uninsured motorists coverage. It also applies to any auto acquired after the inception date.
Note: This symbol does not apply to vehicles licensed or operated in states that allow the named insured to formally reject Uninsured Motorists coverage.
27–Specifically Described Autos
Only autos specifically scheduled and for which a premium charge is made are covered. Similar to Symbol 22 above, the liability coverage provided is extended to any owned or non-owned trailer pulled by this type of owned vehicle.
28–Hired Autos Only
This symbol covers autos the named insured leases, hires, rents or borrows. This symbol has a significant limitation. It does not include leased, hired, rented, or borrowed vehicles owned by an employee, partner, LLC member, or members of any of the preceding groups’ households.
29–Non-Owned Autos Used In Your Garage Business
This symbol only applies to autos the named insured uses in its business that it does not own, lease, hire, rent or borrow. Autos owned by employees, partners in the case of a partnership, members in the case of limited liability companies or members of the preceding group’s households are included. Covered status exists only while those non-owned autos are used in the named insured’s garage business.
Example: Paul recently started his job at The Friendly Garage and was learning the ropes and cheerfully agreed to his boss' request to make a run to the deli for lunch. The boss and eight other employees wrote down their orders, Paul called the order in, and then headed out to pick them up. While driving back, a drink lid popped off and he bent over to readjust it. At that exact moment, the car in front of him stopped and Paul rammed it, setting off a chain reaction that eventually damaged six vehicles. The drivers brought claims against Paul and The Friendly Garage upon learning that Paul was traveling on company business. The owner of Friendly Garage and his insurance company are still discussing whether the lunch run qualifies as part of the garage business. |
30–Autos Left With You
For Service, Repair, Storage Or Safekeeping
This symbol applies to customer autos, including autos of employees and
their household members, left with the named insured for service, repair,
storage or safekeeping, and for which a fee for the services provided is
charged.
31–Dealers Autos (Physical Damage Coverages)
This symbol applies to any auto and the interests of any loss payees in
those autos indicated in Item Seven of the declarations.
Note: In the previous edition, this symbol also included Autos Held For
Sale By Non-Dealers Or Trailer Dealers indicated in Item Nine of CA DS
08–Garage Coverage Form–Non-Dealers' And Trailer Dealers' Supplementary
Schedule.
Manuscript Symbol
An additional manuscript symbol that is not mentioned in the Garage Coverage Form is available by adding endorsement CA 99 54–Covered Auto Designation Symbol. Symbol 32 is available for the Garage Coverage Form and the autos considered covered must be listed and described on the endorsement.
Example: Jane’s dealership displays the first automobile it ever sold. It is still in working condition but is driven only in parades and commercials for the dealership. Since it is insured on an antique auto policy, it is not to be covered on Jane’s garage coverage form. The insurance company agrees to provide symbol 22 for liability and symbol 31 for physical damage. Tit also agrees to attach CA 99 54–Covered Auto Designation Symbol with symbol 32 and the wording, “Any autos except the 1906 Ford and the interests in those autos described in Item Seven of the Declarations. |
B. Owned Autos You Acquire After The Policy Begins
1. If Symbols 21–Any Auto, 22–Owned Autos Only, 23–Owned Private Passenger Autos Only, 24–Owned Autos Other Than Private Passenger Autos Only, 25–Owned Autos Subject To No-Fault, or 26–Owned Autos Subject To A Compulsory Uninsured Motorists Law are used for coverages indicated on the declarations, autos of the type described by such symbols that the named insured acquires during the policy period are also covered.
Example: Lincoln Motors uses symbol 23 and 27 for liability coverages. There is no coverage for a new truck it purchases after the inception date. However, a private passenger vehicle purchased after the inception date is covered. |
2. When symbol 27–Specifically Described Autos is used, new autos acquired during the policy period are covered if the insurance company either covers all vehicles the named insured already owns or if the new vehicle replaces a vehicle already scheduled. However, the named insured must inform the insurance company of the acquisition within 30 days of the date it was acquired.
Example: Lincoln Motors purchased the truck in the previous example to replace another truck. As a result, it is covered for up to 30 days. However, coverage ends after 30 days if the insurance company is not notified of the purchase. |
C. Certain Trailers And Temporary Substitute Autos
When liability coverage is provided, several additional categories of vehicles are added as covered vehicles.
1. Utility trailers having a load capacity of 2,000 pounds or less and designed for travel on public roads are covered while being pulled by a covered auto.
Note: A semi-trailer is not covered. There is no requirement that the utility trailer be owned. This means that liability coverage applies to a utility trailer the named insured rents to transport a piece of machinery as long as the load capacity is 2,000 pounds or less.
2. If the named insured's covered, owned auto is temporarily out of service due for repair or service or due to breakdown, repair, servicing, loss or destruction, a non-owned, temporary substitute for it is covered but only if the named insured uses it with the owner's permission.
Example: Scenario One: All of Greatful Garage's autos are insured under CA 00 05–Garage Coverage Form, with its small fleet of marketing representative cars insured using Symbol 22–Owned Autos. Karl, one of the representatives, must drive to another state on business but doesn't believe his company car can make the trip because it is old and has recently had a few mechanical problems. For these reasons, Karl rents a car for the trip. In this case, Karl's rental is not automatically covered. |
Note: Cars temporarily substituting for owned vehicles being repaired, maintained or serviced are covered.
Example: Scenario Two: All of Greatful Garage's autos are insured under CA 00 05–Garage Coverage Form, with its small fleet of marketing representative cars insured using Symbol 22–Owned Autos. Karl, one of the representatives, must drive to another state on business but his company car breaks down shortly after he begins the trip. Karl rents a car to continue the trip. In this case, Karl's rental is automatically covered as a substitute for his regular company car. |
A. Coverage
This coverage form
provides two types of liability coverage. The first is similar to commercial
general liability coverage and the second is similar to business auto coverage.
1. Garage Operations–Other Than Covered Autos
The insurance company pays amounts an insured is legally obligated to pay as damages because of bodily injury or property damage to which this coverage applies caused by an accident and resulting from garage operations. This does not include ownership, maintenance or use of covered autos. It also has the right and duty to defend any insured against suits seeking damages covered by this insurance. It decides how to handle that obligation. It has the right to decide what to investigate, whether the claim is valid and whether settling the claim or contesting it is appropriate. However, the company no longer has to provide a defense once an action is resolved by payment of a settlement or a court award that exhausts the limit of insurance that applies. Coverage applies only to bodily injury or property damage caused by an accident that takes place in the coverage territory during the policy period. In addition, coverage does not apply to a known loss. A loss is considered known if either an insured or an insured’s employee with the responsibility and authority to report losses was aware of a loss before the inception date.
Example: Jamie Phillips works for ABC Garaging. He handles customer personal property that is lost or found on the premises. Jamie has known for a few weeks that a large metal waste container has a broken wheel that causes it to tip over without warning. He simply picks it up when it falls over and has not mentioned it to any of the parking attendants or the shift supervisors. An attendant turns a corner while parking an insured’s BMW, the waste container suddenly tips over and it smashes against the side of the car. The impact startles the attendant, causes her to lose control, and the vehicle crashes into Jamie’s office. Chargmore Insurance Company tries to deny coverage when it discovers that Jamie knew about the hazardous container. However, it changes its decision when ABC Garaging's owner informs it that, while it would have been nice if Jamie had mentioned the problem to somebody in authority, his duties did not include responsibility for such matters. |
Bodily injury or property damage that takes place during the policy period that was not known to have occurred by any insured or authorized and responsible employee includes any continuation, change or resumption of the injury or damage that takes place after the expiration date.
Note: This is consistent with the fact that insurance coverage is intended to insure against fortuitous events. Allowing an insured to purchase coverage for a loss already known to have occurred is unfair to the insurance company and could be fraudulent.
Bodily injury or property damage is considered to have been known at the time any insured or authorized and responsible employee:
Note: This coverage is similar to the coverage provided under CG 00 01–Commercial General Liability Coverage Form in that it provides premises and products liability coverage for garage operations.
2. Garage Operations–Covered Autos
The insurance company pays amounts an insured is legally obligated to pay
as damages because of bodily injury, property damage, and certain pollution
costs and expenses to which this coverage applies caused by an accident and
resulting from garage operations involving ownership, maintenance or use of
covered autos. It only pays covered pollution costs and expenses if there is
covered bodily injury or property damage caused by the same accident.
Example: Greystoke Auto Dealers owns a shuttle that transports customers who have left their cars for service. The Greystoke Shuttle strikes an SUV as it exits the parking lot. The SUV is upended, falls over, and its gas tank ruptures and sprays fuel all over the street, sidewalk and the storefront of a neighboring restaurant. The city sues Greystoke for the expense of cleaning up gas residue, and the restaurant sues for the cost of removing gas smells from its awning, tablecloths and furniture. These losses are covered. |
Now, let’s change
this scenario slightly.
Example: Greystoke Auto Dealers owns a shuttle that transports customers who have left their cars for service. It strikes an SUV as it exits the parking lot. The shuttle driver gets his customers out of the vehicle and then rushes to remove a spare can of fuel from the shuttle as its damaged engine catches fire and places it on the sidewalk. Later, forgetting it was there, he trips over it and falls. The can's loose lid allows five gallons of gas to spill onto the sidewalk and into a sewer drain. The city sues Greystoke for the expense of cleaning up gas residue. This loss is not covered. |
It also has the right and duty to defend any insured against suits seeking damages covered by this insurance. It decides how to handle that obligation. It has the right to decide what to investigate, whether the claim is valid and whether settling the claim or contesting it is appropriate. However, the company no longer has to provide a defense once an action is resolved by a settlement, a court award or exhaustion of the limit of insurance that applies.
Note: The insurance company's defense obligation is identical to that in Garage Operations–Other Than Covered Autos. This liability coverage is similar to that provided in CA 00 01–Business Auto Coverage Form with respect to ownership, maintenance or use of covered autos.
3. Who Is An Insured
a. Insureds for covered
autos are:
(1) The named insured
(2) Anyone else who uses a covered auto the named insured owns, hires or borrows and operates it with the insured’s permission except:
Example: If the named insured rents a car from a rental agency, the rental agency is not considered an insured. |
Example: If the named insured borrows an employee's car to pick a client up at the airport, the employee is not considered an insured. |
Note: The words "parking" and
"storing" in the previous edition were removed.
(3) Anyone liable for the conduct of an insured indicated above, limited to the extent of that liability
(4) An employee of the
named insured while using a covered auto that the named insured does not own,
hire or borrow in its business or personal affairs
Example: Jim is the body shop manager for Marshall’s New Motors. Lana Marshall asks Jim to pick up her daughter from the airport. Jim takes his own auto and picks her up but strikes a pedestrian on the way to the Marshall’s home. The injured person sues Jim and Marshall Motors. Both qualify as insureds in this loss. |
Note: This
coverage was previously provided only by adding CA 99 33—Employees As Insureds.
b. Insureds for garage operations other than covered autos are:
(1) The named insured
(2) The named insured's partners, if the named insured is a partnership, members, if the named insured is a limited liability company, employees, directors or shareholders while acting within the scope of their duties
Note: When compared to Who Is An Insured in the Commercial General Liability coverage Form, this is a very restrictive definition. Neither the named insured's spouse nor partners are insureds.
2. Coverage Extensions
a. Supplementary Payments
Previous editions stated that the supplementary payments were in addition
to the Limit Of Insurance.
Note: The wording was determined to be ambiguous because it was
sometimes interpreted to mean that the payments were contingent on activity
involving the coverage form's stated policy limits. The intent was merely to
inform policyholders that any supplementary payments made did not affect the
stated limits. The coverage form now states that such payments do not reduce
the limits.
The insurance company pays the following on behalf of the insured:
(1) All expenses the insurance company incurs. This clarifies that the insurance company's expenses do not reduce the limit of insurance.
(2) If a bail bond related to a covered accident is required, up to $2,000 is available to pay its cost. The bond could be for a traffic law violation if related to the covered accident. The insurance company does not have to furnish the bond.
(3) The cost of bonds needed to release attachments in a suit filed against the insured that the insurance company defends, but only the amount of such bonds within the limit of insurance.
(4) The insurance company pays reasonable expenses if it asks the insured to participate in any investigation or defense. This includes actual loss of earnings up to $250 a day because of time taken off from work.
(5) All costs taxed against the insured in a suit filed against it that the insurance company defends.
Note: This supplementary payment can provide rather extensive benefits over and above the limits of insurance.
(6) Interest on the full amount of any judgment that accrues after it is entered in a suit against the insured that the insurance company defends.
b. Out-Of-State Coverage Extensions
This section provides two important coverage extensions when an insured is away from the state where the auto is licensed or garaged. They essentially make the insurance provided comply with any state financial responsibility law no-fault or other compulsory coverage. The two extensions are:
(1) The limit of insurance provided is automatically increased as needed to meet the limits required by a compulsory or financial responsibility law in the jurisdiction where the covered auto is being operated. An important note to this extension is that it does not apply to any law governing motor carriers, passengers or property.
Example: The Garage Coverage Form's single liability limit is $50,000. This limit complies with the financial responsibility laws of the state where the vehicle is licensed and garaged. However, that limit is inadequate when the auto crosses the state line into the next state. That state's minimum limit requirement is $75,000. This extension automatically increases the limit to $75,000 for the period the covered auto operates in that state without requiring a separate endorsement. |
(2) The Garage Coverage Form provides the minimum amounts and types of other coverages required of out-of-state autos by the jurisdiction where the covered auto is being operated. One such coverage is no-fault.
Example: The state where the covered auto is garaged and licensed does not require no-fault coverage, but another state where the covered auto operates does. This extension provides the coverage required by that state during the period the auto operates there. |
Note: A statement here clarifies that the insurance company does not pay anyone more than once for the same elements of loss because of these extensions. In other words, they do not duplicate any coverage or allow damages to be collected more than once.
B. Exclusions
The insurance provided by this coverage form does not apply to the
following:
1. Expected Or Intended Injury
Any bodily injury or property damage the insured expects or intends to cause is excluded. However, for garage operations other than covered autos, this exclusion does not apply to bodily injury resulting from using reasonable force to protect persons or property.
Note: This exclusion is intended to protect insurance companies from responding to damages or injuries the insured intentionally causes. It is in the public interest to prevent the insurance coverage from being used for gain, to injure competitors, as an instrument of revenge, or to cause any other deliberate harm. There is no ISO endorsement available to buy coverage for intentional acts or to delete this exclusion at the present time.
2. Contractual
Damages for bodily injury or property damage that result from liability the insured assumed in a contract or agreement are excluded with two exceptions. They are excluded if either the contract or agreement is considered an insured contract or if the insured would have been liable without a contract or agreement. There is no ISO endorsement available to buy back or delete this exclusion at the present time.
3. Workers Compensation
Coverage does not apply to any requirement or obligation the insured or its insurance company must assume due to any workers compensation, disability benefits, unemployment compensation, or similar law.
Note: This exclusion and the one that follows are intended to prevent double indemnification for injury that should be covered under workers compensation or employers liability policies.
Insurers and brokers having to provide coverage on a variety of difficult, unusual or specialty workers compensation situations should refer to the Workers Compensation section in The Insurance Marketplace, a publication of The Rough Notes Company, Inc.
4. Employee
Indemnification And Employers Liability
Any bodily injury to the insured's employee or the spouse, child, parent, brother or sister of that employee due to the employment of that employee or while performing duties of the insured’s business operations is excluded. Coverage also does not apply to bodily injury to a person or the spouse, child, parent, brother or sister of that person arising out of any refusal to employ that person, terminating that person's employment, or employment related practices.
This exclusion applies whether the insured is liable as an employer or in any other capacity, or whether the insured is obligated to share damages with or repay someone else who must pay damages because of the injury. This clarification is important because of the widespread use of contractors, subcontractors, independent contractors or leased employees, and much of the uncertainty with respect to who is responsible.
Note: This exclusion has two exceptions. Coverage applies to bodily injury to domestic employees who are not entitled to workers compensation benefits and to liability the insured assumes in an insured contract. Domestic employees are persons who perform household or domestic work primarily for a residence premises.
5. Fellow Employee
It is important to remember that employees are considered insureds. As a result, exclusions 3 and 4 could be circumvented if the injured employee could sue the fellow employee who actually caused the accident. This exclusion prevents that workaround. Bodily injury to a fellow employee of the insured that occurs as a result of or in the course of that employee’s employment is excluded.
There are two ways to modify this exclusion. An employer may delete the fellow employee exclusion for all employees by using CA 20 55–Fellow Employee Coverage. An employer may delete the fellow employee exclusion for specific employees or specific positions using CA 20 56—Fellow Employee Exclusions For Designated Employees/Positions.
6. Care, Custody Or Control
Property damage to or covered pollution cost or expense to property the insured owns, rents, or occupies, property loaned to the insured, property it holds for sale or transports or that is in its care, custody or control is excluded unless such liability was assumed in a sidetrack agreement.
The Garage Coverage Form protects the insured for its negligence and tort liability to others, not to damages or injury to the insured. As such, it reinforces the need for the insured to maintain its premises and properties in good condition and to use reasonable care to prevent damage or injury, including damage to property in its care, custody or control.
Note: A sidetrack agreement involves the owners of a premises and a railroad with respect to a railroad sidetrack (a transfer or access track) on the insured's premises. The railroad allows the owner of the premises to use the sidetrack as long as it guarantees the railroad access to the sidetrack and agrees to certain conditions of property maintenance. It may also contain specified conditions of hold-harmless between the owner and the railroad.
Note: Section III–Garagekeepers Coverage insures customers’ vehicles in the insured’s care, custody and control. Coverage for property damage to other types of property is not available under this coverage form.
7. Leased Autos
Covered autos leased or rented to others are excluded except for covered autos rented to customers while their autos are left for service or repair.
8. Pollution Exclusion Applicable To Garage Operations–Other Than
Covered Autos
a. There is no coverage for
bodily injury or property damage arising out of any actual, alleged or threatened
discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration, release or escape of pollutants:
(1) At or from any premise or site ever owned or occupied by, or rented or loaned to, any insured
(2) At or from any premises, site or location that is or ever was used by or for any insured or others to handle, store, dispose of, process or treat waste
(3) At or from any location that the insured or contractors or subcontractors working directly or indirectly on the insured's behalf perform operations:
(a) To test for, monitor, clean up, remove, contain, treat, detoxify, neutralize or respond in any way to the effects of pollutants
(b) If the contractor or subcontractor brought the pollutants on or to the premises, site or location in connection with such operations
(4) That are or ever were transported, handled, stored, treated, disposed of or processed as waste by or for any insured or any organization the named insured may be legally responsible for
Paragraphs a. (1) and a. (3) (b) do not apply to bodily injury or property damage that arises out of heat, smoke or fumes from a hostile fire.
Paragraph a. (1) does not
apply to bodily injury sustained in a building and caused by smoke, fumes,
vapor or soot produced by or originating from equipment that heats, cools or
dehumidifies the building, or equipment used to heat water for the
building's occupants or their guests' personal use.
Paragraph a. (3) (b) does not apply to bodily injury or property damage sustained inside a building caused by release of gases, fumes or vapors from material brought inside in conjunction with work done by the named insured or by contractors or subcontractors working on its behalf.
b. There is no coverage for any loss, cost or expense arising out of:
(1) Any request, demand, order or legal requirement to test for, monitor, clean up, remove, contain, treat, detoxify, neutralize, or responding to or assessing the effects of pollutants in any way
(2) Any claim or suit by or on behalf of governmental authorities for damages because of testing for, monitoring, cleaning up, removing, containing, treating, detoxifying, neutralizing or responding to or assessing the effects of pollutants in any way
Insurers and brokers having to provide coverage on a variety of difficult, unusual or specialty pollution situations should refer to the Environmental Risks section in The Insurance Marketplace, a publication of The Rough Notes Company, Inc.
9. Pollution Exclusion Applicable To Garage Operations–Covered Autos
a. There is no coverage for
bodily injury or property damage arising out of any actual, alleged or
threatened discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration, release or escape of
pollutants that are, or that are contained in any property:
(1) Being transported or handled in any way in, on or off a covered auto
(2) In transit otherwise by the insured or on its behalf
(3) Being stored, disposed of, treated or processed in or on a covered auto
b. Before the pollutant or its container is moved from the place where the insured accepts it for movement to the covered auto
c. After the pollutant or its container is moved from the covered auto to its final delivery destination for disposal or to be abandoned
Paragraph a. does not apply to fuels, liquids, lubricants, exhaust gases and similar pollutants needed for normal operations of the covered auto that escape in any way from the compartment intended to contain them.
Paragraphs b. and c. do not apply to accidents that take place away from an insured's premises involving pollutants not in or on a covered auto if the pollutant or its container is upset, overturned or damaged resulting from maintenance of use of a covered auto and the release is directly caused by the upset, overturn or damage.
Example: Mary delivers flowers for Amy’s Florists. She loses control of her van and crashes into the outside oil tank at Jimmy’s Convenience store causing the tank to release all of its contents. Because the tank is not on Mary’s premises and the tank is ruptured by the accident, the damage caused by the pollution release is covered. |
Note: CA 99 55–Pollution Liability–Broadened Coverage for Covered Autos–Garage Coverage Form provides a buyback for pollution coverage. It changes the pollution exclusion by excluding only liability the insured assumes under a contract or agreement.
10. Racing
There is no coverage for any auto while being used in, practicing or being prepared for any professional or organized racing, demolition contest or stunts.
Note: Simply stated, vehicles are troublesome, even under regular operating conditions. They're heavy, difficult to control and can cause an incredible amount of damage. For these reasons, insurance companies are not interested in providing coverage in cases where vehicle owners deliberately operate their property in a reckless or dangerous manner.
11. Watercraft Or
Aircraft
Watercraft or aircraft are excluded except watercraft on shore at the named insured's garage locations where it conducts operations.
12. Defective Products
Coverage does not apply to property damage to any of the named insured's products if a defect in a product or one of its parts was transferred to another.
Note: CA 25 01–Broad Form Products Coverage eliminates this exclusion and covers loss involving an insured's defective products.
13. Work You Performed
Property damage to the named insured’s work or any part of it is excluded if it results from any part of the work itself or from the parts, materials or equipment used in connection with the work.
Example: Paul’s Fine Cars repairs the engine in a customer’s vehicle. The work is defective and causes a vehicle fire. There is no coverage for the engine damage, but coverage may apply for the rest of the vehicle. |
14. Loss Of Use
There is no coverage for loss of use of other property not physically damaged caused by any defect, inadequacy or dangerous condition in the insured’s product or work or caused by any delay or failure of the named insured or anyone acting on its behalf performing the terms of a contract or agreement.
Note: This exclusion has an exception. The Garage Coverage Form responds to loss of use if the loss of use of other property is the result of sudden or accidental injury to either the named insured’s product or work after being used as intended.
15. Products Recall
There is no coverage for damages claimed for any loss, cost or expense the named insured or others incurs for loss of use, withdrawal, recall, inspection, repair, replacement, adjustment, removal or disposal of the named insured’s product. In the same manner there is no coverage if the claims for damages are due to work the named insured performed, or other property of which the named insured's work or product is a part when withdrawn, recalled or removed because of a known or suspected defect, deficiency, inadequacy or dangerous condition.
Note: Coverage does not apply, regardless of which party initiated the withdrawal, recall or removal. If there is reason or cause to suspect that a product, work or property is defective or could cause injury or damage, the expense and cost of the recall, repair or removal is excluded.
Example: Jamie's Car Doctors had a very successful two-week brake inspection and repair promotion, performing nearly 200 brake replacements. A month after the promotion, Jamie began getting complaints about brake malfunctions during sudden stops and had to contact every customer and replace the brake pads. Jamie decided to file a claim for the recall expense. However, his parts department manager admitted that he failed to check the inventory of pads before the promotion began and gave their mechanics pads from their defective parts storage. The first thing Jamie did was to discard the claim form. Then he fired the parts manager. |
16. War
This exclusion is rewritten to unequivocally bar coverage for either
bodily injury or property damage related to war and similar military events. It
is not affected by circumstances such as a formal declaration of war, that the
war is a civil uprising, whether it involves government or civilian
participants. The bottom line is that there is no coverage for loss related
either directly or indirectly to war or warlike activity.
17. Distribution Of Material In Violation Of Statutes Exclusion
Applicable To Garage Operations–Other Than Covered "Autos"
Insurance coverage does not apply to bodily
injury or property damage that arises directly or indirectly out of any act or
omission that violates or allegedly violates the Telephone Consumer Protection
Act (TCPA), including its amendments or additions, the CAN-SPAM Act of 2003,
including its amendments or additions, or any other statute, ordinance or
regulation prohibiting or limiting the sending, transmitting, communicating or
distributing of material or information.
Example: Midtown Car Sales is insured under the Garage Coverage Form. It sends notice to its insurance company and requests that it handle a recently filed claim notice of a class-action lawsuit on behalf of thousands of citizens in the area over receiving e-mail advertisements of Midtown's monthly auto deals. Midtown sent the e-mails based on an e-mail list purchased from a third party. The insurance company rejects the claim request since Midtown's action involved spamming. |
Note: The Liquor
Liability exclusion was removed in the 03/06 Edition.
C. Limit Of Insurance
1. Aggregate Limit Of
Insurance–Garage Operations–Other Than Covered Autos
For these operations, without regard to the number of insureds, claims made, or suits brought, the most paid for the total of all damages resulting from all bodily injury and property damage in any one accident is the aggregate limit indicated on the declarations. These damages do not include ownership, maintenance or use of covered autos because that coverage has its own limit. It does include the following coverages, if provided:
Note: All bodily injury and property damage that is the result of continuous or repeated exposure to essentially the same conditions is considered the result of one accident.
The Aggregate Limit applies separately to each annual 12-month period beginning on the inception date. For any remaining period of less than 12 months, the limit also applies separately to that period unless the policy was extended for that period. In that case, the extended period is part of the preceding policy period for purposes of application of the limit.
Example: Taylor's Custom Carriages Garage Coverage Form runs from 12/01/09 to 12/01/10. Taylor contacts his insurance company and asks it to extend the policy period to 03/01/11 and to then renew for the period 03/01/11 to 03/11/12 in order to match the dates of Taylor's' other policies. Taylor is informed that the same aggregate limit applies to the extended 15-month policy term. |
2. Limit Of
Insurance–Garage Operations–Covered Autos
For these operations, without regard to the number of covered autos, insureds, premium paid, claims made, or vehicles involved in the accident, the most paid for the total of all damages resulting from all bodily injury and property damage in any one accident is the each accident limit indicated on the declarations. Damages and covered pollution costs or expenses are payable only under this coverage.
Note: All bodily injury, property damage, and covered pollution cost or expense that is the result of continuous or repeated exposure to essentially the same conditions is considered the result of one accident.
Note: No party can receive duplicate payments for essentially the same loss under this coverage form and any medical payments, uninsured motorists or underinsured motorists coverage forming a part of this coverage form.
Example: The two named insureds on the Garage Coverage Form are Smith, Inc. and John Smith, Smith Inc.'s owner. Smith, Inc. owns several private passenger vehicles that John uses for both business and pleasure. John causes a serious accident while using one of them on a personal errand. Because of the severity of her injuries, the injured party sues John individually for $500,000 and Smith, Inc. as the vehicle owner for $500,000. The Garage Coverage Form's limit is $500,000 Each Accident for Garage Operations–Covered Autos. The claimant is awarded $1,000,000, or $500,000 from each party named in the lawsuit but the Garage Coverage Form pays only its $500,000 limit. |
D. Deductible
$100 is deducted from the damages in an accident resulting from property damage to an auto resulting from the named insured's work done on that auto.
A. Coverage
1. The insurance company pays amounts the insured is legally obligated to pay as damages for loss or damage to either a customer's auto or its equipment left in the insured's care while attending, servicing, repairing, parking or storing it in the named insured's garage operations. Coverage applies under:
a. Comprehensive Coverage
Coverage applies to any source of damage to a customer's auto except collision with another object and overturn.
b. Specified Causes Of Loss Coverage
This coverage applies only to loss or damage caused by or resulting from fire, lightning, explosion, theft, mischief or vandalism.
c. Collision Coverage
This coverage is very specific. The only covered loss or damage is that caused by the customer's auto's collision with another object or its overturn.
Note: Another object could be another vehicle as well as an animal, bird, person, tree, building or sign, to name a few.
2. The company has both the right and the duty to defend any insured against suits seeking these damages if coverage applies. It can investigate and settle claims and suits in the appropriate manner but its duty to defend when the limit of insurance for the coverage that applies is exhausted by payment of judgments or settlements.
3. Who Is An Insured
The insured for loss or damage to customer's autos and their equipment is the named insured, its partners if the business is a partnership, its members if the business is a limited liability company, and employees, directors or shareholders while acting within the scope of their duties.
4. Coverage Extensions
The insurance company pays the following supplementary payments for the insured. They apply to any claim or suit it defends and do not reduce the limit of insurance.
a. All expenses the insurance company incurs.
b. The cost of bonds needed to release attachments in a suit filed against the insured that the insurance company defends, but only the amount of such bonds within the limit of insurance
c. The reasonable expenses if it asks the insured to participate in any investigation or defense. This includes actual loss of earnings up to $250 a day because of time taken off from work.
d. All costs taxed
against the insured in a suit filed against it that the insurance company
defends
e. Interest on the
full amount of any judgment that accrues after it is entered in a suit against
the insured that the insurance company defends. The duty to pay interest ends
after the company offers the part of a judgment that falls within its limit of
insurance.
B. Exclusions
1. The insurance provided by this coverage form
does not apply to the following:
a. Contractual
Obligations
Liability that results
from any contract or agreement in which the insured accepts responsibility for
a loss is excluded unless the insured would be liable for the loss without a
contract or agreement.
b. Theft
Coverage does not apply to loss due to theft or conversion caused in any way by the named insured, its employees, or shareholders.
Note: This coverage is available under Crime or Employee dishonesty Coverage Forms.
c.
Defective Parts
Loss caused by or resulting from use of defective parts or materials is excluded.
d. Faulty Work
There is no coverage for loss caused by or resulting from the named insured's faulty work performed.
2. The following types of property are excluded:
a. Unless permanently
installed in the customer’s auto, tape decks and other equipment that
produce sound
b. Items designed
for use with sound reproducing equipment such as tapes, records and other
devices that produce sound
c. Equipment that receives sound and designed for use as a citizens' band radio, two-way mobile radio, telephone or scanning monitor receiver. Antennas and accessories used with the equipment are also excluded but coverage applies for equipment permanently installed in the dash or console opening normally used by the car radio.
d. Radar and laser jamming, detecting, eluding or disrupting equipment designed or used to detect speed
Note: There is no reference to increasingly common and sophisticated computing, visual and/or navigational devices.
3. Coverage does not
apply to loss or damage caused by or resulting from the following, regardless
of any other cause or event that contributes concurrently or in any sequence to
the loss.
a. War. This includes
civil war and undeclared war.
b. Warlike actions by
military forces. This includes actions by any government, sovereign or other
authority that uses military personnel or other agents to hinder or defend
against actual or expected attacks
c. Action taken by
governmental authority to hinder or defend against insurrection, rebellion,
revolution or usurped power
C. Limits Of Insurance
And Deductibles
1. For these operations, without regard to the number of customer's autos, insureds, premium paid, claims made, or suits brought, the most paid for each loss at each location is the limit for it indicated on the declarations.
Note: An important
point for the named insured to consider in selecting both the coverage and the
limit is the total number of vehicles in its care at any one time and their
associated values.
Example: A fire damages four vehicles at Handy’s Used Car Lot, for total damages of $65,000. Since Handy’s Garagekeepers limit is only $50,000, only $50,000 is paid. |
This amount is reduced by
a per car deductible indicated on the declarations.
2. The largest deductible for Garagekeepers Coverage Comprehensive or Specified Causes Of Loss Coverages indicated on the declarations is the most deducted for all loss in any one occurrence caused by theft or mischief or vandalism, or all perils.
Example: Handy’s has a $1,000 per car deductible for comprehensive with a $3,000 deductible. Handy's is responsible for $3,000 before the insurance carrier before the insurance company begins to pay. |
3. If the insurance company pays all or part of the deductible in order to settle a claim or suit, the named insured must reimburse the company for any such amounts it paid.
A. Coverage
1. The insurance
company pays for loss to a covered auto and its equipment based on the coverages
indicated on the declarations and the symbols selected. When selected, the
following coverage is provided:
1. The insurance company pays for loss or damage to covered autos or their equipment if a symbol is indicated.
a. Comprehensive
Coverage
This is loss or damage from any cause except the covered auto colliding with another object or overturning.
b. Specified Causes Of
Loss
This is loss or damage caused by only fire, lightning, explosion, theft, windstorm, hail, earthquake, flood, mischief, vandalism, or sinking, burning, collision or derailment of any conveyance transporting the covered auto.
Note: Although these are the most common losses, they are very specific, and many losses are not covered.
c. Collision Coverage
This is loss or damage caused by the covered auto colliding with another object or overturning.
Note: "Another object" could be an animal, bird, person, tree, building, sign, etc., in addition to another vehicle.
Note:
Towing–Non-Dealers Only under Physical Damage Coverage in the previous edition
is removed.
2. Glass Breakage–Hitting A Bird Or Animal–Falling Objects Or Missiles
The insurance company pays for loss or damage caused by or resulting from glass breakage, striking an animal or bird, and by falling objects or missiles if comprehensive coverage applies to the damaged auto. However, the named insured can choose to cover a glass breakage loss as part of collision when the breakage is due to a collision and avoid paying two deductibles.
Note: This clarifies coverage. The three types of losses indicated could be called collisions because an object struck the vehicle. This is important because the named insured might have a smaller deductible on its comprehensive coverage or may only carry comprehensive coverage.
3. Coverage Extension
Note: Transportation
Expenses under Physical Damage Coverage in the previous edition is removed.
Loss Of Use Expenses
The expenses an insured must pay under a written rental contract or agreement for loss of use of the rental car are covered but only if Hired Auto Physical Damage is purchased. Coverage is limited to $20 per day and $600 maximum. Payment is made if the loss of use expenses are caused by:
Note: CA 99 90–Optional Limits–Loss Of Use Expenses can be used to purchase higher limits.
B. Exclusions
Editor’s note: Some exclusions are given titles for analysis purposes. These titles are not a part of the Garage Coverage Form.
1. Coverage does not apply to loss or damage caused by or resulting from the following, regardless of any other cause or event that contributes concurrently or in any sequence to the loss.
a. Nuclear Hazard
This is explosion of any weapon using atomic fission or fusion, or nuclear reaction, radiation or radioactive contamination, regardless of how caused.
b. War Or Military Action
This includes declared or undeclared war, civil war, warlike action by a military force, including acts to defend or hinder an expected or actual attack by any government or authority employing military personnel or agents, as well as insurrection, rebellion, revolution, usurped power or any action to hinder or defend against these.
Note: Damage or loss involving nuclear or war-like activities is excluded even if other loss factors contribute to an incident. In other words, these losses are excluded regardless of how caused or whether or not they combine with any other cause of loss.
2. The insurance company does not pay for loss or damage to the following:
a. Leased Or Rented
Autos
Coverage does not apply to any covered auto leased or rented to others.
Note: This exclusion has an exception for autos rented to customers who left their autos with the named insured for service or repair.
b. Racing
There is no coverage for any covered auto while used in or practicing or being prepared for any professional or organized racing, demolition contest or stunting activity.
c. Tapes, Records,
Discs
Tapes, records, discs and similar property or devices designed for use with audio, visual, or electronic equipment are excluded. This exclusion is extremely broad because of changes in media. Tapes and CD’s are excluded as well as DVD’s and equipment that can be attached to any media system within the auto.
Note: In this exclusion ISO uses a term “data electronic” which is not defined or in common usage. The term is used to describe devices that are excluded and also to describe equipment to which any of these excluded items could be designed for. Although it appears to be an all-inclusive term, its lack of clear meaning could make this exclusion ambiguous.
d. Speed Detection
Devices
There is no coverage for radar and laser jamming, detecting, eluding or disrupting equipment designed or used to detect speed.
e. Electronic
Equipment
Coverage does not apply to any type of electronic equipment used to receive or transmit audiovisual or data signals that is not designed only to reproduce sound, whether or not permanently installed
f. Other Equipment
All accessories used with electronic equipment described in paragraph e
However, paragraphs e. and f. of this exclusion do not apply to:
a. Permanently installed sound reproducing equipment and its accessories, subject to it being permanently installed in the covered auto at the time of loss. The same equipment is covered even if it can be removed as long as the auto has a permanently installed housing unit for it. Coverage applies only if the property is designed to operate only from the auto’s electrical system.
b. Other electrical equipment normal to the operation of the covered auto or that monitors the operating system is covered. Coverage also applies if it is integrated into the items described above and is permanently installed in the area normally used for a radio.
Two endorsements can be used to provide coverage for the items excluded above:
3. False Pretense
There is no coverage for loss to a covered auto caused by or resulting from another party causing the named insured to voluntarily part with it under false pretenses or because of a trick or scheme, or because the named insured acquired an auto from a seller who did not have legal title to it.
Example: Suburban Motors turns in a loss on a pre-owned vehicle it purchased from an individual two weeks earlier. When investigating the loss, the adjuster discovers that the seller did not have legal title to it because it was actually stolen and used falsified papers in effecting the sale. The insurance company denies the claim. |
CA 25 03–False Pretense Coverage covers dealers and garage operations that receive used vehicles for trade-ins. It covers the insured up to the specified limit for vehicles acquired from customers engaging in false pretense.
4. Specific Exclusions
a. Coverage does not apply to the named insured's expected profit, loss of market or resale value.
b. The insurance company does not pay for loss to any covered auto stored or displayed at any location not indicated on the declarations 45 or more days after the named insured begins using that location.
c. Collision coverage does not apply to any covered auto driven or transported more than 50 miles between the purchase or distribution point and the destination.
CA 25 02—Dealers Driveaway Collision Coverage is used with dealers and garage operations with driveaway exposures that may need additional collision coverage by eliminating the 50 mile limitation. The insured must provide additional information with the periodically required reports if this endorsement is used.
d. Specified Causes Of Loss coverage does not apply to loss or damage to any covered auto caused by or resulting from collision or upset of the vehicle transporting it.
5. Diminution Of Value
Loss of a covered auto's value because it was involved in an accident is not covered. Diminution Of Value is defined in Section VI–Definitions.
Example: The insured has a collision loss and the vehicle is repaired. The repair shop tells the insured that the auto is now worth less than before the loss just because people are unwilling to pay as much for an auto that has been in an accident. The insured presents a claim for the perceived loss of value to the insurance company which is denied. |
6. Other Exclusions
Coverage does not apply to loss or damage caused by or resulting from wear and tear, freezing, mechanical or electrical breakdown, blowouts, punctures or other road damage to tires. This exclusion does not apply if such losses are caused by a loss otherwise insured by this coverage form.
Note: There are no current ISO endorsements available to buy back or delete this exclusion. The insured interested in insuring some of these exposures should check into the special warranty, labor and replacement programs available through many dealerships.
C. Limits Of Insurance
1. The most paid for loss or damage to any one covered auto is the lesser of:
a. The actual cash value of the stolen or damaged property
Note: The value is based on what the property was worth at the time of the loss, not at the time of adjustment or when it was purchased.
b. The cost to repair or replace the stolen or damaged property with property of like kind and quality
2. In case of a total loss, adjustments are made for the auto's depreciation and physical condition to establish the actual cash value.
3. If repairing or replacing the auto increases its value, the insurance company does not pay for that increase.
Note: CA 99 28–Stated Amount Insurance amends the limit of insurance for physical damage coverages. For vehicles indicated on the endorsement schedule, the limit for physical damage coverage is changed to the least of the actual cash value, the cost to repair or replace, or the limit specified on the endorsement schedule. This endorsement should be used with caution because it could decrease the settlement amount.
4. Additional
Provisions
a. The most paid for
all loss or damage at any one location is the limit for that location indicated
on the declarations, regardless of the number of covered autos damaged or
involved in the loss. Similarly, the most paid for all loss in transit is the
limit indicated on the declarations for loss in transit, regardless of the
number of covered autos damaged or involved in the loss.
b. Quarterly Or
Monthly Reporting Premium Basis
If the actual value of the covered autos at the loss location exceeds the value indicated on the latest report, the insurance company pays only a percentage of the loss. It arrives at this percentage by dividing the total reported value for the involved location by the actual value on the date of the last report. If the first report has not been submitted on time, the most paid is not more than 75% of the limit of insurance indicated on the declarations for the involved location.
c. Non-Reporting
Premium Basis
If the actual value of the covered autos at the loss location exceeds the value indicated on the declarations, the insurance company pays only a percentage of the loss. It arrives at this percentage by dividing the limit by the total values at risk at the time of loss.
D. Deductible
The amount the insurance company pays for, to repair, return, or replace damaged or stolen property is reduced by the deductible amount indicated on the declarations. The Comprehensive or Specified Causes Of Loss Coverage can have a deductible only for theft and vandalism or for all perils. The per-loss deductible is capped at the maximum deductible indicated for that location on the declarations.
Note: The collision deductible is a per loss deductible and there is no maximum.
Note: The distinction
between Auto Dealers Only Special Deductible Provisions and Non-Dealers Only
Special Deductible Provisions in the previous edition is removed because
Non-Dealers can no longer be insured under this coverage form.
The conditions in this section are in addition to the conditions in IL 00 17–Common Policy Conditions.
A. Loss Conditions
1. Appraisal For Physical Damage Loss
If the insurance company and the named insured fail to agree to the amount of a loss, either may demand an appraisal. When this occurs, each party selects a competent appraiser, both of whom then select a competent and impartial umpire. Each appraiser separately states the actual cash value and amount of loss. If the two appraisers do not agree, they submit their differences to the umpire. When any two of the three agree, that decision is binding on all parties. The insurer and the named insured each pay the cost of the appraisers and share the expense of the umpire and costs of the appraisal equally.
Note: Even if the insurance company participates in the appraisal process, it still retains the right to deny the claim.
2. Duties In The Event Of Accident, Claim, Suit Or Loss
The insurance company has no duty to provide any coverage under this coverage form unless the named insured fully complied fully with the following duties:
a. In case of an accident, claim, suit or loss, the named insured must provide either the insurance company or its authorized representative with prompt notice of how, when and where the accident or loss occurred, the insured’s name and address and the names and addresses of any injured persons or of any witnesses, if known.
b. The named insured and the involved insured must not commit the insurance company to any payment, obligation or expense. However, the insured can make any commitments it wants at its own expense. The named insured and the insured involved must cooperate with the insurer during investigating or settling the claim or defending the suit. They must also provide copies of all documents the insurance company requests as well as provide it with all necessary authorizations so it can obtain medical records or other pertinent information and submit to examination by a physician the company chooses as long as it is reasonable and at the insurer’s expense.
c. The named insured has additional duties in case of a physical damage loss to a covered auto or its equipment. The police must be notified promptly if the loss is due to theft. In other loss situations and within reason, the named insured must protect the covered auto from further damage and record the expenses incurred to do so because they can be considered when the claim is settled. The insurer must be able to inspect the damaged auto and obtain information about the loss before the auto is repaired or disposed of. If requested by the insurer, the named insured must agree to be examined under oath and sign any statement of answers.
Failure to cooperate can have serious consequences. Although it does not involve commercial auto, this case illustrates what can happen to a party who does not comply with such provisions.
3. Legal Action Against Us
No one may bring legal action against the insurance company until all coverage form terms have been complied with. In addition, under liability coverage, the insurance company must agree that the insured has an obligation to pay a third party or a court has determined that there is such an obligation The insurance company cannot be brought into any action to determine the insured’s liability.
4. Loss Payment–Physical Damage Coverages
The insurance company determines the method to use to settle a physical damage loss. It can:
a. Pay to repair or replace the damaged or stolen property
b. Return the stolen property but bear the expense of returning it. It also pays any damages the auto incurred due to the theft.
c. Pay the appraised or agreed value of the damaged or stolen property and then take any or all of it
Note: Any payment made includes any required sales tax.
5. Transfer Of Rights Of Recovery Against Others To Us
If the insurance company made payments to a party under this coverage form, any rights that party may have to recover from another transfer to the insurer. The party that was paid must do everything necessary to secure the insurer's rights to recover and do nothing to impair those rights.
B. General Conditions
1. Bankruptcy
Bankruptcy of the insured or its estate does not relieve the insurance company of its obligations under this coverage form.
2. Concealment, Misrepresentation Or Fraud
Coverage is void in any case of fraud by the named insured at any time relating to this coverage form. It is also void if the named insured or any insured at any time intentionally conceals or misrepresents material facts relating to this coverage form, the covered auto, the named insured’s interest in the covered auto, or any claim made under this coverage form.
Example: Nigh-Eve Mutual issues a garage coverage form to Acme Autos. Acme turns in a claim involving losses to more than a dozen new cars it alleges were vandalized on its lot. The loss investigation reveals that Acme actually deals in used, older vehicles and targets persons with poor credit instead of being the dealer in high-value new cars indicated on the application. The loss is denied. |
3. Liberalization
Any broadened or additional coverage the insurance company provides without an additional premium charge automatically applies to this coverage form. It is effective on the date that the coverage is effective in the named insured’s state.
4. No Benefit To Bailee–Physical Damage Coverages
If a party, such as a bailee, holds or transports property for a fee and requires an assignment of coverage, the insurance company does not recognize that assignment, regardless of any other provision in this coverage form.
5. Other Insurance
a. This insurance is primary if the named insured owns the covered auto. Otherwise, it is excess over any other insurance that can be collected. Trailer coverage is similar but is based on the vehicle it is attached to. If the trailer is attached to the named insured's covered auto, coverage for the trailer is primary. However, coverage is excess when the trailer is attached to a motor vehicle the named insured does not own.
b. Under hired auto physical damage coverage, a covered auto the named insured leases, hires, rents or borrows is considered an owned covered auto. The one exception is when such autos come with a driver.
Note: CA 20 54–Employee Hired Autos is available to add coverage when an employee hires an auto in his or her own name as an individual intending to perform business-related duties and activities for the named insured.
c. This coverage is always primary when liability is assumed in an insured contract.
Note: This supersedes the provisions of paragraph 5.a above.
d. The insurance company pays only its share when any other insurance covers the loss on the same basis, regardless of whether that coverage is on a primary or excess basis. The insurer’s share is the proportion that this limit of insurance bears to the total of the limits of all coverage forms and policies that apply on the same basis.
Note: Ratios are determined based on each insurer’s limits as a percentage of all limits available. Losses are proportioned among the insurers accordingly.
6. Premium Audit
a. The initial premium payment is an estimated premium based on the exposures the named insured indicated at inception. The insurance company calculates the final premium based on the insured's actual exposures. Once that is done, the estimated premium is subtracted, and the first named insured is either billed for the additional amount owed or receives a refund if it overpaid. The billing statement indicates the date additional premium is due.
b. When coverage is issued for longer than a one-year term, the premium is calculated annually based on the insurance company's rates in effect at the beginning of each annual period.
7. Policy Period, Coverage Territory
Only bodily injury,
property damage and losses that occur during the policy period are covered.
Only covered pollution cost or expense that arise from accidents that occur
during the policy period is covered. The occurrence or accident must take place
within the coverage territory. The coverage territory is the United States of
America and its territories and possessions, Puerto Rico and Canada.
Worldwide coverage is provided if the covered private passenger auto is leased, rented or hired for a period of less than 30 days and the responsibility to pay is determined in the territories listed in the first paragraph of this condition.
The coverage territory is extended to anywhere in the world if the bodily injury or property damage is caused by one of the insured’s products sold for use in one of the coverage territories indicated above. The original suit for damages resulting from the bodily injury or property damage must be first brought in a described coverage territory.
Note: CA 01 21–Limited Mexico Coverage is available to minimally broaden the coverage territory. However, it should be read carefully and evaluated completely before being used because of its very limited nature.
8. Two or More Coverage Forms Or Policies Issued By Us
Except for coverage forms or policies issued specifically as excess, if this coverage form and any other coverage form or policy issued to the insured by the insurance company or any of its affiliates apply to the same accident, the most paid for the total limit of insurance under all the coverage forms or policies does not exceed the highest applicable limit of insurance under any one coverage form or policy.
A. Accident includes continuous or repeated exposure to the same conditions that result in bodily injury or property damage.
B. Auto is a land motor vehicle, trailer or semitrailer.
C. Bodily injury is not only bodily injury sustained by a person but also sickness or disease sustained by a person, including resulting death from any of these.
D. Covered pollution cost or expense is any cost or expense arising out of requests, demands, orders, statutory or regulatory requirements, claims or suits by or on behalf of a governmental authority demanding that the insured or others test for, monitor, clean up, remove, contain, treat, detoxify, neutralize, or in any way respond to or assess the effects of pollutants. This includes suits or claims brought by the governmental authority or others for any of these.
It does not include cost or expense that arises out of the actual, alleged or threatened discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration, release or escape of pollutants:
a. Being transported, towed by, handled or handled for movement into, onto or from a covered auto, are otherwise in the course of transit by or on behalf of the insured, or are being stored, disposed of, treated or processed in or on a covered auto. This includes any pollutants contained in any property during any of the previously indicated conditions.
This paragraph has an exception. Coverage may apply if fuels, lubricants, fluids, exhaust gases or other similar pollutants needed for or as a result of the normal electrical, hydraulic or chemical function of the covered auto or its parts causes the pollution. The pollutants must escape, seep, migrate or be discharged, dispersed or released directly from an auto part designed by the manufacturer to hold, store, receive or dispose of the pollutants.
b. Prior to moving the pollutant generating property to the place where the insured receives it in order to move it either into or on a covered auto
c. After moving the pollutant generating property from the covered auto to the point of the insured’s final delivery
Paragraphs b and c do not apply if an accident occurs away from a premises any insured owns or rents and the pollutants are not in or on a covered auto, but only if the pollutant generating property is upset, overturned or damaged resulting from maintenance or use of a covered auto and upset, overturn or damage causes the polluting event.
E. Customer's auto is a customer's land motor vehicle, trailer or semitrailer or any auto left with the named insured for safekeeping, service, repair or storage. The named insured's employees and members of their households are also customers but only if they pay for services provided.
F. Diminution in value is the loss of market value solely due an accident. This loss of value can be actual or perceived.
G. Employee includes leased workers but not temporary workers.
H. Garage operations are the ownership, maintenance or use of locations for garage business and portions of roads or other accesses adjoining them. It also includes the ownership, maintenance or use of autos indicated in Section I as covered autos as well as all operations necessary or incidental to a garage business.
I. Insured is any party who qualifies as an insured under Who Is An Insured. Coverage applies separately to each insured seeking coverage or against whom a claim or suit is brought. The one exception is that the limit of insurance does not apply per insured.
J. Insured contract includes the following:
1. Leases of premises
2. Sidetrack agreements
3. Easement or license agreements. However, any contract in conjunction with construction or demolition operations on or within 50 feet of a railroad is not an insured contract.
4. Obligations required by ordinance when the purpose is to indemnify a municipality. However, this does not apply to any work being done for the requesting municipality.
5. The portion of a contract or agreement that relates to the named insured’s business, including any municipal indemnification in connection with work being done for the municipality, where the named insured assumes the tort liability of another party. The tort liability must be to pay for bodily injury or property damage to a third party or organization. Tort liability is liability the named insured would have had without a contract or agreement.
6. Elevator maintenance agreements
7. The portion of an auto rental or lease contract or agreement the named insured or an employee enters into that relates to the named insured’s garage business. Any obligation the named insured or its employee has to pay for property damage to the auto is not considered an insured contract.
These contracts or agreements are not considered insured contracts:
1. Ones that pay an architect, engineer or surveyor for damages due to making maps, drawings, opinions, designs and related activities or from giving or failing to give directions or instructions
2. Ones that indemnify any party for fire damage to locations rented or loaned to the named insured
3. Ones that pertain to loaning, leasing or renting an auto to the named insured or its employees if done so with a driver
4. Ones that hold a party in the business of transporting property by auto for hire harmless for the named insured’s use of covered autos over routes or territories it is authorized to serve by public authority
5. Ones that indemnify a railroad for losses that result from construction or demolition within 50 feet of any railroad property, or that affects any railroad bridge, trestle, track, road-bed, tunnel, underpass, or crossing
K. Leased worker is a person the named insured leases from a labor-leasing firm to work in its business. It requires an agreement between the leasing firm and the named insured. Temporary workers are not considered leased workers.
L. Loss is direct and accidental loss or damage. Garagekeepers Coverage is broadened to include any resulting loss of use.
M. Pollutants are any solid, liquid, gaseous, or thermal irritant or contaminant, including smoke, vapor, soot, fumes, acids, alkalis, chemicals and waste. Waste includes materials to be recycled, reconditioned or reclaimed. This definition is consistent in all ISO coverage forms.
N. Products are goods or products the named insured made or sold in a garage business. This includes warnings or instructions that were given or should have been given.
O. Property damage is not limited to just the damage to tangible property. It also includes any loss of its use.
P. Suit is not limited to just civil proceedings alleging damages. It also includes any arbitration or alternative resolution proceedings as long as the insurance company consents to the proceedings. All allegations must be due to covered bodily injury, property damage or covered pollution costs or expenses.
Q. Temporary worker is neither a leased worker nor an employee. The named insured uses these workers as substitutes for permanent employees or to help out in short-term situations. The named insured must understand that temporary workers are not considered an insured. For this reason, temporary workers should not drive any company vehicles or use their vehicles for company business.
R. Trailer includes semitrailers as well as small utility trailers.
S. Work you performed is not only the work performed by the named insured, including work another party performed on the named insured's behalf. This includes warnings or instructions that were given or that should have been given.
Garage operations are somewhat unusual with respect to the liability exposures they represent. The lines between the general liability for the operations and the automobile liability exposures blur and overlap in a number of areas. The garage policy was developed to provide comprehensive liability coverage to protect both the general liability and automobile liability exposures in one coverage form. It is also intended to prevent gaps and overlaps. The Garage Coverage Form contains premises liability coverage, products liability coverage, automobile liability coverage, and physical damage protection to vehicles. Endorsements are available to broaden and further protect the insured and to make the Garage Coverage Form more comprehensive in nature.
Any commercial or business venture with an auto liability and/or physical damage exposure is eligible for one of the business auto coverage forms. Each of the business auto coverage forms may be used as stand-alone monoline policies or as a coverage part in conjunction with a Commercial Package Policy (CPP). Four coverage Forms exist that combine both liability and/or physical damage, while an additional physical damage only form is available. One of the five coverage forms should be able to meet the needs of any commercial operation.
Those operations that should be protected with the Garage Coverage Form—CA 00 05, include both franchised and nonfranchised auto dealers, truck dealers, motorcycle dealers, snowmobile and recreational vehicle dealers, new and/or used, franchised and nonfranchised trailer dealers, repair shops, service stations, storage garages and public parking places.
The make-up of a garage policy must contain more than just the Garage Coverage Form. To complete an ISO Garage Policy, there must be:
· Common Policy Declarations
· Common Policy Conditions
· Garage Declarations
· Supplementary Schedule
· Garage Coverage Form
· Endorsements
The following is an analysis of the Insurance Services Office (ISO) Garage Coverage Form—CA 00 05. A recap of each section of the CA 00 05 will be reviewed.
Note: In addition to the garage conditions built into the coverage form, the garage policy is also subject to the common policy conditions found in IL 00 17, which are not included in this analysis.
Section VI—DEFINITIONS contains defined words. Defined words have been placed in quotation marks.
Note: Changes that have occurred over prior versions are in bold.
10 01 CHANGES
The key word used
throughout this change is "consistency." Since much of the garage
policy covers premises, the intent is to closely align the Garage with the
Commercial General Liability policy. The three major General Liability changes
are:
1. Coverage territory and policy period wording is in the insuring
agreement
2. Montrose issue amendments are added to the insuring agreement
3. Pollution exclusion is amended and broadened
a. Loss of Use – Rental Vehicle Coverage. This is added to the policy
in Section III – Physical Damage – A. Coverage - 4. Coverage Extension – b. Loss
of Use Expenses. This provides payment of up to $20 per day or a maximum of
$600 to a rental operation due to damage incurred by the insured.
b. Limited Worldwide Coverage for Hired Autos. This is added to the
policy in Section IV- Business Auto Conditions – B. General Conditions – 7.
Policy Period, Coverage Territory – paragraph e. This provides liability
coverage for private passenger autos that are leased or rented for less than 30
days anywhere in the world. The suit must be adjudicated in the standard
territory.
c. Insured Contract definition change. This is accomplished in Section
V- Definitions – H. Insured Contract – paragraph 6.a. The term ‘any person or
organization’ is replaced by the term ‘a railroad’. By doing this, an insured
contract only excludes contracts with railroads for damages arising out of
construction or demolition operation within 50 feet of railroad property.
2. Exclude payment for diminution of value because of the subjective nature of the claim. A diminution claim states that an auto loses value merely because it has been in an accident. The auto policy is not designed to deal with subjective issues and therefore will deny any such claim.
3. Revise the Limit of Insurance section to clarify how the actual cash value is determined so that the insured will not receive any payment beyond like kind or quality.
4. Add a note that
applicable sale tax is to be included in the loss payment
5. Revise definition of temporary worker. The definition is reworded dramatically but intent remains the same.
The garage only
changes are:
1. The addition of and definition of the term "customer's
auto" to Garagekeepers Coverage.
2. Ability to have split deductibles for Theft and all perils under
Auto Dealers.
The coverage form begins with covered "auto" symbols. In order to determine which "autos" are considered covered "autos" for each of the coverages provided in the policy, numerical symbols are used. These symbols correspond to a definition to specify what is a covered "auto."
In the declarations, there is a place to show a symbol or symbols next to the liability, garagekeepers and physical damage coverages. Only those coverages that have a symbol(s) shown in the declarations are applicable and only those "autos" as designated by the symbol(s) are covered "autos" for that coverage.
The Garage Coverage Form has the eleven symbols developed specifically for the types of "autos" and exposures inherent to a garage operation. These symbols are as follows:
21 = Any "Auto"—Symbol 21 is the broadest of all the symbols and as it states, it provides the insured with the designated coverage for any "auto."
22 = Owned "Autos" Only—This symbol triggers coverage for only those "autos" that are owned by the insured and includes any "auto" the insured has acquired after the policy begins. An extension of the definition of owned "autos" is made for liability coverage with respect to a "trailer," whether it is owned or not by the insured. As long as it is attached to an "auto" or power unit owned by the insured, it is considered an owned "auto."
23 = Owned Private Passenger "Autos" Only—Use of this symbol triggers coverage for only those private passenger type "autos" that are owned by the insured. It also includes any private passenger type "auto" the insured acquires after the policy begins.
24 = Owned "Autos" Other Than Private Passenger "Autos" Only—This symbol triggers coverage for only those "autos" that are owned by the insured which are not private passenger type. It also includes any "auto" the insured has acquired after the policy begins, except for private passenger type. An extension of the definition of owned "autos" is made for Liability Coverage with respect to a "trailer," whether it is owned or not by the insured. As long as it is attached to an "auto" or power unit owned by the insured and not private passenger type, it is considered an owned "auto."
25 = Owned "Autos" Subject To No-Fault—When this symbol is used, it triggers coverage for only those "autos" that are owned by the insured and are also required to carry any No-Fault insurance or benefits in the state that the "autos" are principally garaged. This also includes any "autos" the insured has acquired after the policy begins that are also subject to the no-fault requirements or benefits of the state where the "autos" are principally garaged.
26 = Owned "Autos" Subject To A Compulsory Uninsured Motorists Law—Use of this symbol triggers coverage for only those "autos" that are owned by the insured and are also required to carry uninsured motorists coverage and not allowed to reject the uninsured motorists coverage, in the state that the "autos" are principally garaged. This also includes any "autos" the insured has acquired after the policy begins that are also subject to the uninsured motorists coverage. The insured cannot reject that coverage in the state where the "autos" are principally garaged.
27 = Specifically Described "Autos"—By using this symbol, it allows the insured to select those "autos" that coverage is needed for on an individual basis. Only those "autos" specifically listed in one of the two supplementary schedules, either in Item Seven of the Non-Dealers and Trailers Dealers or in Item Nine of the Dealers Schedule. No automatic coverage is provided for newly acquired "autos" when this symbol is used. Each new "auto" must be specifically endorsed onto the policy. The extension for "trailers" does apply to this symbol. With respect to liability coverage, "trailers" are considered as long as they are attached to an "auto" or power unit specifically described as covered in the appropriate Supplementary Schedule.
28 = Hired "Autos" Only—This symbol provides coverage only for those "autos" that the insured has leased, hired, rented or borrowed. No coverage for owned "autos" is provided. Of important note is a significant limitation posed by the use of this symbol. Any "auto" that the insured has leased, hired, rented or borrowed from any employee, partner or member of an employee’s or partner’s household is not included or covered.
29 = Nonowned "Autos" Used in Your Garage Business—Any "auto" that is not leased, hired, rented or borrowed by the insured, that is also used in the insured’s garage business as stated in the declarations, is covered. This symbol also will cover those "autos" that the insured has leased, hired, rented or borrowed from any employee, partner (when the insured is a partnership), a member (when the insured is a limited liability company) or member of an employee’s or partner’s household.
Example: Paul really liked his job at The Friendly Garage. He had just started and was learning the ropes, so when his boss asked that he make the deli run for lunch he was all for it. The boss plus 8 other employees put in orders. Paul called them in and then headed out to pick them up. As he was returning with the items, a drink lid popped off and he bent over to readjust it. At that same moment, the car in front of him stopped. He plowed into the car which set off a chain reaction, eventually damaging 6 vehicles. All drivers brought claim against Paul and The Friendly Garage (once they learned Paul was traveling on company business). The owner of Friendly Garage and his insurance company are still arguing over whether the lunch run qualifies as being part of their garage business.
30 = "Autos" Left With You for Service, Repair, Storage or Safekeeping—When a customer leaves an "auto" with the insured’s "garage operation" for service, storage or safekeeping, use of this symbol will provide coverage for those customers’ vehicles. In this context, “vehicles” refer to a land motor vehicle, trailer, or semitrailer. The meaning of "customer" has been extended to include any employee or employee’s family members who pay for the services performed by the insured.
31 = Dealers "Autos" and "Autos" Held for Sale by Non-Dealers or Trailer Dealers (Physical Damage Coverage)—This symbol provides coverage for "autos" and other interests in the "autos" of dealers that have been specifically described in one of the two supplementary schedules; either in Item Seven of the Non-Dealers and Trailers Dealers Supplementary Schedule or in Item Nine of the Dealers Supplementary Schedule.
Several considerations on the use of symbols should be explored. In some cases, more than one symbol may be used.
Example: Regarding liability coverage, the insured may wish to have all private passenger vehicles covered, as well as any hired or nonowned vehicles, so symbols 23, 28 and 29 would be shown by the liability coverage on the declarations page. However, if symbol 21 is used for liability, no other symbol is needed, as 21 covers any "auto."
Symbol 21 is the broadest of all the symbols, providing coverage for any "auto." This symbol may be used for liability only. Because of the degree of protection this symbol offers, however, many insurers use it judiciously.
Symbols can be different for coverage within the same policy. Symbol 21 may be used for liability, but symbol 27 used for physical damage coverages.
Manuscript Symbol. Not mentioned in the garage coverage form, but available by endorsement, is an additional manuscript symbol. This symbol may be added by the use of endorsement CA 99 54—Covered Auto Designation Symbol. For the business auto coverage form, manuscript symbol 32 is available. A complete description of the "autos" that are to be considered covered "autos" must be shown in the endorsement.
Example: An insured wants liability coverage for all of his owned vehicles and physical damage coverage on all owned vehicles except a collection of very high value antique cars. For physical damage purposes, the antique cars are in a specialty market and have their own policy for the physical damage coverages. Symbol 21 is used to designate the covered autos for liability coverage and Symbol 32 should is used to designate the covered autos for comprehensive and collision coverages. The definition used for Symbol 32 is: All owned autos except the collection of antique cars covered by policy CAXXXXXXX.
For insurers and brokers that have access to coverage for a variety of difficult business auto, garage or trucking situations, refer to the section for Automobiles, Trucks or Recreational Vehicles in The Insurance Marketplace, published by The Rough Notes Company, Inc.
1. If the symbols 21 = Any Auto, 22 = Owned Autos Only, 23 = Owned Private Passenger Autos Only, 24 = Owned Autos Other Than Private Passenger Autos Only, 25 = Owned Autos Subject To No-Fault or 26 = Owned Autos Subject To A Compulsory Uninsured Motorists Law are used for coverages as shown in the declarations, then "autos" acquired by the insured during the policy period, of the type described by the symbol, are also covered.
If Symbol 23 (Owned Private Passenger Autos Only) is used and the insured purchases a new private passenger vehicle during the policy period, coverage is automatic. However, if Symbol 24 (Owned Autos Other Than Private Passenger "Autos" Only) is used and the insured purchases the same private passenger vehicle, there is no automatic coverage. The insured would have to specifically request coverage for this vehicle to be added and change the policy symbol.
When Symbol 27 (Specifically Described Autos) is used, coverage for newly acquired "autos" within the policy period may be covered if the insurer either covers all the vehicles that the insured already owns or the new vehicle is a replacement for a vehicle already scheduled, and if the insured notifies the insurer within 30 days of the acquisition of the new vehicle regarding the coverages or changes desired.
When liability coverage has been selected in the declarations, several additional categories of vehicles are considered covered:
"Trailers" of the utility type that have a load capacity of 2,000 pounds or less and which have been designed for travel on public roads are covered while being towed by a covered "auto."
Example: A semi-trailer is not covered; however, the liability for a utility trailer which the insured rented to transport a piece of machinery is covered while towed by an "auto," as long as the load capacity is under 2,000 pounds.
When a covered, owned "auto" of the insured is temporarily out of service due to breakdown, repair, servicing, loss or destruction, then the nonowned, temporary substitute is covered if the insured is using it with the proper permission of the vehicle owner.
Example: The insured has to drive to another state on business but does not want to chance driving long-distance in his company’s older vehicle which has had mechanical problems. The insured decides to rent a car for the trip. The rental is not automatically covered by the insured’s business auto policy (if any symbol other than 1 or 8 was selected for liability). On the other hand, if the car was rented as a temporary substitute while the owned vehicle was in a repair shop for servicing, then liability coverage is provided.
Two liability coverages are provided in the garage liability coverage portion of the coverage form. They include:
"GARAGE OPERATIONS"—OTHER THAN COVERED "AUTOS"
This coverage obligates the insurer to pay for "bodily injury" or "property damage," when those damages are accidental. However, they must also be related to an "insured’s" "garage operations." Not covered under this portion of the coverage form are any damages that result from the ownership, maintenance or use of a covered "auto."
The insurer has the right and the duty to defend any "suit" for covered damages. The insurer may at any time and at the insurer’s discretion, investigate or settle any claim or "suit." The insurer can terminate its defense of a lawsuit if either it settles the case or pays a judgment that uses up the policy’s stated "Garage Operations"—Other Than Covered "Autos" Limit of Insurance.
The coverage form’s
latest edition now incorporates wording that was created in response to the
Montrose Chemical Corporation vs. Admiral Insurance Company case in California.
The language, which has been a part of the CGL since 1999, was added to the
Garage form for consistency. The Insurance Services Office’s position is that
the language change does not represent a change in coverage, merely a
clarification of intent. In certain jurisdictions the modified wording may be
considered a change since it could be interpreted as a reduction of coverage.
Essentially the
wording clarifies how coverage is triggered. The greatest emphasis has been
placed upon the insured’s level of knowledge regarding a possible loss. In
order to qualify for coverage, an “accident” has to occur in the “coverage
territory” and the “bodily injury” and “property damage” must occur during the
policy period.
The "bodily
injury" and "property damage" liability does not apply to a
known loss. A loss is considered to be known if either an insured or an
insured’s employee were aware of a loss before the policy’s inception date.
However, the note about an employee only extends to one who has a
responsibility (authority) to handle accident or claim notices.
Example: Jamie Pail works for Ambiguous Garaging. He handles customer personal property that is lost or found on the premises. Jamie knows about a large metal waste container that has a broken wheel that makes it tip over unexpectedly. He’s known about it for a few weeks and he just picks it up when it falls over. He never mentions it to any parking attendants or the shift supervisors. On Feb. 11th, an attendant rounds a corner while parking an insured’s BMW. As he makes the turn, the heavy waste container tips over, smashing against the side the car. The impact startles the attendant, causing her to lose control and the vehicle smashes into Jamie’s Lost and Found Office. Chargmore Insurance Company, which has just issued a policy on Feb. 1, tries to deny coverage when they find out that Jamie knew about the hazardous container. Ambiguous Garaging’s owner changes his mind when he points out that, while it would have been nice if Jamie had mentioned the problem, his duties did not include responsibility for such matters.
Another facet of a
known loss extends to knowledge of a claim that begins before a policy
effective date and continues through that date. Finally, a loss circumstance
that occurs before a policy period and then, either re-occurs or changes in
scope after the policy period begins, is considered to be a known loss. Such
losses would be disqualified for coverage. This is consistent with the fact
that insurance policies are meant to protect against fortuitous events.
Allowing coverage to an insured who buys insurance to handle a loss he or she
already knows about is not fair to an insurer.
“Bodily injury"
or "property damage" qualifies as known by the insured (or authorized
"employee") when:
· any insurer receives notice of any injury or damage
·
an
insured receives any demand or claim for damages
· any moment at which an insured becomes aware that injury or damage has occurred or has begun to occur
The added wording
significantly changes the policy view of either a known loss or a loss in
progress. Since the previous wording made it possible for certain “known”
losses to be covered, the change does represent modified coverage.
The coverage provided under this portion of the liability coverage is similar to that of the Commercial General Liability Coverage Form—CG 00 01. It is meant to provide premises and products liability coverage for "garage operations."
The second portion of the liability coverage under Coverage A of the garage coverage form is:
"GARAGE OPERATIONS"—COVERED "AUTOS"
This portion of the liability coverage responds to eligible "bodily injury" or "property damage" that involves the "insured’s" "garage operations" and the ownership, maintenance or use of a covered "auto.” This section also makes the insurer responsible for paying for certain losses and expenses related to pollution. This coverage only applies to such losses that are part of a covered accident.
Example: Greystoke Motor Motel owns a shuttle that carries customers to the nearby airport. Just as the Greystoke Shuttle exits the garage, it slams into an SUV. The other vehicle is upended and, as it falls over, its gas tank ruptures, spraying fuel all over the street, sidewalk and the storefront of a neighboring restaurant. The city sues Greystoke for the expense of cleaning up gas residue, and the restaurant sues for the cost of removing gas smells from its awning, tablecloths and furniture. These would be covered losses.
Let’s slightly change this scenario.
Example: Greystoke Motor Motel owns a shuttle that carries customers to the nearby airport. Just as the Greystoke Shuttle exits the garage, it slams into an SUV. The shuttle driver gets his customers off the vehicle and then rushes out onto the street. The shuttle’s wrecked engine catches fire, so he removes a full, spare gas can from the rear of the shuttle. He places the can on the sidewalk and later, forgetting it’s there, he trips over it and falls. Since it takes him a minute to recover, the can, which had a loose cap, spills all five gallons of gas onto the sidewalk and into a sewer drain. The city sues Greystoke for the expense of cleaning up gas residue. This would not be a covered loss.
The insurer’s defense obligation is identical to the one
found above in "GARAGE OPERATIONS"—OTHER THAN COVERED "AUTOS"
This portion of the liability coverage is very similar to that provided in the Business Auto Policy for the ownership, maintenance, or use of covered "autos."
1. WHO IS AN INSURED
The following are insured for covered "autos":
The named insured.
Anyone else using a covered "auto" that is owned, hired or borrowed by the named insured and who is operating with the insured’s permission is an insured except:
a. The owner or anyone else that the insured has hired or borrowed a covered "auto" from is not covered. In other words, if the insured rents a car from a rental agency, the rental agency is not considered an insured. The exception to this is any "trailer" connected to a covered, owned "auto."
b. Employees of the insured are not covered if the employee or members of the employee’s household own the “auto.” So, when the insured borrows an employee's car to pick a client up at the airport, the employee is not considered an insured.
c. Anyone using a covered "auto" while working in the business of selling, servicing, repairing, parking or storing "autos" are not covered unless that business is the insured’s. To illustrate, when an employee borrowed a company vehicle to use one night in that employee's part-time auto repair business, that employee was not considered an insured.
d. Anyone other than the insured’s employees, partners, lessee or borrower or their employees, are not covered while moving property to or from a covered "auto."
Example: The insured allowed a friend to use one of the insured’s company trucks to move household items to a new location. In this case, the friend is not an insured during the loading and unloading process.
e. Partners of the insured (if the insured is a partnership) and members (if the insured is a limited liability company) are not covered if the partner or members of the partner’s household own the “auto.” When a partner borrows a spouse’s car for company business, the spouse is not considered an insured. Anyone that is held liable for the conduct of an insured is also considered an insured, but only to the extent of that liability for the insured.
Partners (if the insured is a partnership), members (if the insured is a limited liability company), employees, directors or shareholders of the insured, but only with respect to the scope of their duties pertaining to the covered "garage operation," are insured.
An available endorsement that extends Who Is An Insured is CA 99 33—Employees as Insureds. Use of this endorsement extends liability coverage to employees while using covered nonowned "autos" for business or personal affairs of the insured. Normally, no charge is associated with this endorsement.
An endorsement is available to add coverage should an employee hire an auto in their own name as an individual to perform business-related duties and activities for his/her employer. The endorsement is CA 20 54—Employee Hired Autos. This form modifies the definition of Who Is An Insured to also include the "employee" while operating the vehicle that is owned or rented in that employee’s name.
2. COVERAGE
EXTENSIONS
Six supplementary payments are part of this coverage form. They are in addition to the limits stated in the Limits of Insurance. These apply to any claim or "suit" the insurer defends. They are as follows:
1. All expenses the insurer incurs are covered. This item clarifies that the limit of insurance is not reduced by the insurer’s expenses.
2. If a bail bond is required because of accidents or traffic law violations based on the use of any vehicle covered by the bodily injury liability coverage, up to $2,000 is available for the cost of such bonds. Special notation is made to clarify that the insurer is not responsible for furnishing these bonds.
3. Cost of bonds needed to release attachments is provided for when a suit is filed against the insured, if the amount of the bond is within the applicable policy limit. Again, clarification is made that the insurer is not responsible for providing the bonds
4. If the insurer asks the insured to help with any investigation or defense, his or her reasonable expenses are reimbursed. This includes any actual loss of earnings, up to $250 a day, if the insured must take time off work.
5. All costs taxed against the insured in the "suit," cases where the court assesses the costs and expense of the trial against the negligent party are covered. This supplementary payment can provide some extensive benefits, over and above the policy limits.
6. Interest on the amount of the judgment against the insured, that has accrued after the judgment has been entered, but before the insurer has paid the judgment or the policy limits, is covered in full.
When an insured is away from the state where the "auto" is licensed or garaged, two very important coverage extensions are provided. These extensions make the insurance provided by the garage policy comply with any state financial responsibility law, no-fault or other compulsory coverage. The two extensions are as follows:
1. The limit of liability provided is automatically increased, as necessary, to meet the limits specified by a state compulsory or financial responsibility law of the jurisdiction where the covered "auto" is being operated. One important note to this extension is that it does not cover or comply with any law that governs motor carriers of passengers or property.
Example: A garage policy has a single liability limit of $50,000. This limit complies with the financial responsibility laws of the state where the vehicle is licensed and garaged, but when the "auto" crosses the state line into the next state, that limit is inadequate. The second state requires a limit of at least $75,000. This extension will automatically increase the limit, without further endorsement, to $75,000 for the temporary period the covered "auto" is being operated in the second state.
2. The second part of the extension indicates that this policy will provide the minimum amounts and types of other coverages, such as no-fault, that are required by the jurisdiction where the covered "auto" is being used.
Example: The state where the covered "auto" is garaged and licensed does not require no-fault coverage, but when the vehicle crosses into the second state, no-fault coverage is required. With this extension, during the period the "auto" is operated in the second state, the garage coverage form provides the coverage as required by that state.
A note of clarification states that the insurer will not pay anyone more than once for the same elements of loss because of the extensions provided. In other words, the extensions do not duplicate any coverage, nor do they allow for the collection of damages more than once.
Seventeen exclusions are found in the garage coverage form. Listed below are the seventeen exclusions; where applicable, information is provided regarding how this coverage may be "bought-back" by endorsement or otherwise covered.
1. Expected or Intended Injury—Except for any "bodily injury" that may result from reasonable force used by any insured to protect or defend any person or property, any "bodily injury" or "property damage" that the insured expects or intends to cause, is not covered by this insurance.
The purpose of this exclusion is to protect insurers from being called upon to respond to damages or injuries that an insured intentionally caused. This exclusion is in the public interest to make sure an insured is not using the insurance contract for gain (such as theft), to inflict injury to competitors, using it as an instrument of revenge or to cause any other purposeful harm.
There are no current ISO endorsements available to buy back or delete this exclusion.
2. Contractual: Damages for "bodily injury" or "property damage" that result from liability the insured has assumed in a contract or agreement, are not covered unless either the contract or agreement is considered to be an "insured contract," or if the insured would have been liable even if the contract or agreement had never occurred.
There are no current ISO endorsements available to buy back or delete this exclusion.
3. Workers Compensation: This insurance does not apply to any requirement or obligation that the insured must assume resulting from any workers compensation, disability benefits, unemployment compensation or similar type laws. The extent of this exclusion and the one that follows is to prevent double indemnification for injury that should be covered under workers compensation or employers liability policies.
For insurers and brokers that have access to coverage for a variety of difficult, unusual or specialty Workers Compensation situations, refer to the section for workers compensation in The Insurance Marketplace, published by The Rough Notes Company, Inc.
4. Employee Indemnification and Employers Liability: Excluded is any "bodily injury" to an employee of the insured, or the spouse, child, parent, brother or sister of that employee, as a consequence or result of employment of that employee by the insured.
It is further clarified that the exclusion applies whether the insured is liable as an employer or in any other capacity; or whether the insured is obligated to share damages with or repay someone else, who must pay damages because of the injury. This is a particularly important clarification because of the widespread use of contractors, subcontractors, independent contractors or leased employees, and much of the uncertainty with respect to who is responsible.
There are two exceptions to this exclusion: any "bodily injury" to domestic employees who are not entitled to workers compensation benefits are covered, and liability assumed by the insured in an "insured contract" is covered.
5. Fellow Employee: Excluded is any "bodily injury" to any fellow employee of the insured that occurs as a result of, or in the course of, that employee’s employment. This exclusion complements exclusions number 3 and 4 which states that injury to an employee during the course of employment or as a result of employment is not covered, even if caused by a fellow employee.
The Fellow Employee Exclusion can be modified in two ways. By attachment of endorsement CA 20 55—Fellow Employee Coverage, an employer may delete the fellow employee exclusion for all employees. By attaching CA 20 56—Fellow Employee Exclusions For Designated Employees/Positions, an employer may delete the fellow employee exclusion for specific employees or specific positions.
6. Care, Custody or Control: "Property damage" or "covered pollution cost or expense" involving any property owned or transported by the insured or in the insured’s care, custody or control is excluded, except for liability assumed under a sidetrack agreement.
The garage coverage form is intended to protect the insured for negligence and tort liability to others; it does not apply to damages or injury suffered by an insured. As such, it reinforces the need of the insured to maintain their own premises and properties in good condition and use reasonable care to prevent damage or injury, including damage to property in the insured’s care, custody or control. However, if liability is assumed in a "sidetrack agreement" for property loaned to the insured or for personal property in the care, custody or control of the insured, the exclusion does not apply, so there is coverage.
A "sidetrack agreement" is one between the owners of a premises and a railroad with respect to a railroad sidetrack (transfer or access track) on the premises of the insured. The railroad will allow use of the sidetrack as long as the property owner guarantees access by the railroad to the sidetrack and agrees to certain conditions of property maintenance. It may also contain specified conditions of hold-harmless between the railroad and property owner.
Although the ISO garage policy does not have an endorsement to cover items in the insured’s care, custody, control or transported by the insured, inland marine insurance may be purchased for cargo, transportation or motor carrier coverage on the property of customers or clients. There are various forms of these coverages available through ISO and AAIS (American Association of Insurance Services), as well as company specific forms, depending on the needs and operations of the insured. For insurers and brokers that have access to coverage for a variety of difficult, unusual or specialty property situations, refer to the section for inland marine in The Insurance Marketplace, published by The Rough Notes Company, Inc.
7. Leased Autos: if a covered "auto" has been leased or rented to another party, there is no longer any protection under the garage coverage form for that "auto." An exception to this exclusion is for "autos" that are rented to customers of the insured while their "autos" have been left with the insured for servicing or repair. There are no current ISO endorsements available to buy back or delete this exclusion.
8. Pollution Exclusion Applicable To "Garage Operations"—Other Than Covered Autos: To get a better understanding of what pollution is, we will first look at Section VI—Definitions. That section identifies pollution as: any solid, liquid, gaseous or thermal irritant or contaminant. Elements such as fumes, smoke, acids (and their fumes), vapor, soot, alkalis, chemicals and waste; are all pollutants. All facets of waste are another type of pollutant, even if they exist in some phase of recycling or reclamation.
ISO uses a very broad definition for this exclusion, excluding virtually every type of potential occurrence, regardless whether the event is accidental or gradual. Incidents of pollution are not covered by the garage form.
The garage form excludes BI and PD related to the actual, alleged or threatened discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration, release or escape of pollutants:
· from any premise or site ever owned, occupied or controlled by any insured;
· from any premise, or location that is or was used by anyone for handling, storing, disposing, processing or treating waste;
· which were ever transported, handled, stored, treated, disposed of or processed as waste by any insured or any other party;
· at or from any location that the insured or persons with any working relationship with the insured are working or performing operations, where such persons have brought pollutants onto that location or from any location that the insured or persons with any working relationship with the insured are working or performing operations, where such persons are working or performing operations to test for, monitor, cleanup, remove, contain, treat, detoxify, neutralize or in any way respond to or assess the effect of pollutants.
This coverage form does not apply to any loss, cost or expense resulting from any request, demand, order or statutory or regulatory requirement requiring the insured or any other to test for, monitor, cleanup, remove, contain, treat, detoxify, neutralize or in any way respond to or assess the effect of pollutants. The exclusion further states that insurance does not apply to any claim or suit by or on behalf of a governmental authority for damages because of any of the above stated circumstances.
The 10 01 edition adds additional circumstances where the exclusion is inapplicable. This brings it more in line with the Commercial General Liability Pollution exclusion, but they still are not identical exclusions
The three potential pollution events that have been excepted from the pollution exclusion are "bodily injury" or "property damage" which results from heat, smoke or fumes (from a hostile fire), soot, fumes, vapor or smoke from heating equipment and pollutant brought onto the premises by contractors working for the named insured. Hostile fire is defined in the pollution exclusion to mean any fire that has become uncontrollable or breaks out from where it was intended to be.
For insurers and brokers that have access to coverage for a variety of difficult, unusual or specialty pollution situations, refer to the section for Environmental Risks in The Insurance Marketplace, published by The Rough Notes Company, Inc.
9. Pollution Exclusion Applicable To "Garage Operations"—Covered Autos: Excluded is any "bodily injury" or "property damage" that arises out of the actual, alleged or threatened discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration, release or escape of "pollutants:"
a. that are being transported, towed by, handled or handled for movement into, onto or from a covered "auto;" that are otherwise in the course of transit by or on behalf of the insured; or being stored, disposed of, treated or processed in or upon a covered "auto." This includes any "pollutants" that are contained in any property during any of the previously mentioned conditions. There is an exception to this portion of the exclusion. This item does not apply to fuels, lubricants, fluids, exhaust gases or other similar "pollutants" needed for or as a result of the normal electrical, hydraulic or chemical function of the covered "auto" or its parts; if the "pollutants" escape, seep, migrate or are discharged, dispersed or released directly from an "auto" part designed by the manufacturer to hold, store, receive or dispose of such "pollutants."
b. before the "pollutants" or any property containing the "pollutants" are physically moved to the point or place where it is accepted by the insured to be moved into or onto the covered "auto."
c. after the "pollutants" or any property containing the "pollutants" is moved from the covered "auto" at the point of final delivery by the insured.
The exclusions shown in paragraphs b and c do not apply to any "accident" that occurs away from a premises owned by or rented to any insured with respect to "pollutants" not in or upon a covered "auto" if the "pollutants" or any property containing the "pollutants" is upset, overturned or damaged as a result of the maintenance or use of a covered "auto" and the discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration, release or escape of the "pollutants" is caused directly by that upset, overturn or damage.
One endorsement is available to provide a buyback for Pollution Coverage under a Garage Policy: CA 99 55—Pollution Liability—Broadened Coverage for Covered Autos—Garage Coverage Form—Using this endorsement changes the pollution exclusion for liability in the coverage form by excluding only the liability assumed under a contract or agreement. This endorsement is not applicable in Maine. Any additional charge for the use of this endorsement is at the discretion of the insurer.
10. Racing: No coverage exists under the Garage Policy for any covered "auto" while it is used in, practicing for or being prepared for any professional or organized racing, demolition contest or stunting activity.
There are no current ISO endorsements available to buy back or delete this exclusion.
For insurers and brokers that have access to coverage for a variety of difficult business "auto" or trucking situations such as racing activities, refer to the section for Automobiles, Trucks or Recreational Vehicles in The Insurance Marketplace, published by The Rough Notes Company, Inc.
11. Watercraft or Aircraft: Excluded is any coverage for watercraft or aircraft, except for watercraft that is ashore at the premises where the insured conducts their "garage operations."
There are no current ISO endorsements available to buy back or delete this exclusion.
For insurers and brokers that have access to coverage for a variety of difficult watercraft, boating, aviation or aircraft situations, refer to the sections for either Marine or Aircraft, in The Insurance Marketplace, published by The Rough Notes Company, Inc.
12. Defective Products: "Property damage" to any of the insured’s products because of damage caused by a defect in the product or any part of it, is not covered.
Example: The insured replaces an engine in a vehicle and the engine has a defective part causing the vehicle to catch fire. There is no coverage under this policy for the engine damage.
To delete this Exclusion, use CA 25 01—Broad Form Products Coverage. This endorsement modifies the Products portion of the Coverage Form for Defective Products by eliminating that exclusion and thus providing additional coverage. Any increase in premium for the use of this endorsement is at the discretion of the insurer.
13. Work You Performed: "Property damage" to the insured’s work or any part of it is excluded if the "property damage" results from any part of the work itself or from the parts, materials or equipment used in connection with the work. There are no current ISO endorsements available to buy back or delete this exclusion.
14. Loss Of Use: Loss of use of other property is excluded when that other property has not been physically damaged; if the Loss of Use is caused by any defect, inadequacy or dangerous condition in the insured’s product or work; or has been caused by any delay or failure of the insured or anyone acting on the insured’s behalf in the performance of the terms of a contract or agreement. Wording is added to clarify that the exclusion does not apply if the loss of use of other property is the result of sudden or accidental injury to either the insured’s product or work, after it is being used as intended.
There are no current ISO endorsements available to buy back or delete this exclusion.
For insurers and brokers that have access to coverage for a variety of difficult, unusual or specialty product situations, refer to the section for Products Liability in The Insurance Marketplace, published by the Rough Notes Company, Inc.
15. Products Recall: Damages for any loss, cost or expense, whether incurred by the insured or by others, because of loss of use, withdrawal, recall, inspection, repair, replacement, adjustment, removal or disposal of the insured’s product, the insured’s "work you performed," or other property that the insured’s work or product is a part of, is excluded when withdrawn, recalled or removed because of a known or suspected defect, deficiency, inadequacy or dangerous condition. It does not matter what party initiates the withdrawal, recall or removal, there is no coverage. Basically, if the insured knows or has reason to suspect that a product, work or property is defective or could cause injury or danger, there is no coverage for the expense and cost of the recall, repair or removal.
There is currently no standard ISO endorsement available to buy back this coverage or delete this exclusion.
16. War: No "bodily injury" or "property damage" for any liability assumed under a contract or agreement, resulting from any act, incident or condition of war, whether declared or undeclared, is covered by the Business Auto Policy. War is clarified to include in its definition acts such as civil war, insurrection, rebellion or revolution.
17. Liquor Liability: When the insured uses any premises, in whole or in part to serve or furnish alcoholic beverages for a charge, whether or not a license is required and whether or not it is done for the purposes of financial gain or livelihood, there is no coverage for "bodily injury" or "property damage" the insured may be held liable for caused by:
a. causing or contributing to the intoxication of any person;
b. furnishing alcoholic beverages to a person under the legal drinking age, or furnishing alcoholic beverages to a person under the influence of alcohol;
c. any statute, ordinance or regulation that relates to the sale, gift, distribution or use of alcoholic beverages.
This exclusion also applies if the insured serves or furnishes alcoholic beverages, without a charge, if a license is required for that activity.
One endorsement is available to add Host Liquor Coverage only, by use of CA 25 14—Broadened Coverage—Garages. This endorsement may be added to the Garage Coverage Form approximate to the coverages more in line with the commercial general liability policy. Some of the additional coverages added by this endorsement are: fire legal liability, personal injury and advertising injury liability, host liquor, incidental medical malpractice, non-owned watercraft, incidental worldwide liability, and newly acquired. Any increase in premium for the use of this endorsement is at the discretion of the insurer.
For an optional method of handling the insured’s Liquor Liability exposure, a Liquor Liability Coverage Form is available for a separate Liquor Liability Policy. Two versions of the Liquor Liability Policy, Occurrence Policy Coverage Form, CG 00 33, or Claims-Made Policy Coverage Form—CG 00 34, may be used.
For insurers and brokers that have access to coverage for a variety of Liquor Liability situations, refer to the section for Drugs and Alcohol Risks in The Insurance Marketplace, published by The Rough Notes Company, Inc.
The Limits of Insurance for the two liability portions of the Garage Coverage Form are handled differently. As explained below, the "Garage Operations"—Other Than Covered "Autos" is subject to two Limits of Insurance. One is an Each Accident Limit, which is the most that will be paid as a result of any one "accident." The other is the Aggregate Limit of Insurance or the total amount that will be paid for the sum of each "individual accident." For "Garage Operations"—Covered "Autos," only the Each Accident Limit of Insurance applies and is not subject to an Aggregate Limit of Insurance.
An endorsement, CA 99 38—Split Liability Limits—Garages is available with reference to the Limits of Insurance. By using this endorsement, the Limit of Insurance for the Liability Coverages is changed from a single limit to a split limit for Bodily Injury Liability Each Person, Bodily Injury Each Accident and Property Damage Each Accident. The formula for the computation of the increase in premium is found in the ISO Business Auto Rating Program.
1. AGGREGATE LIMIT OF INSURANCE—"GARAGE OPERATIONS"—OTHER THAN COVERED "AUTOS"
No matter how many insureds are involved, how many claims are made, "suits" brought, parties bringing "suits" or claims, with respect to "garage operations" other than the maintenance or use of covered "autos," the most the insurer will pay for the total sum of all damages is the Aggregate Limit of Insurance shown in the Declarations for "Garage Operations"—Other Than Covered "Autos."
If the following coverages have been added to the policy by means of endorsement:
· "Personal Injury" Liability Coverage;
· "Personal and Advertising Injury" Liability Coverage;
· Host Liquor Liability Coverage;
· Fire Legal Liability Coverage;
· Incidental Medical Malpractice Liability Coverage;
· Non-Owned Watercraft Coverage; or
· Broad Form Products Coverage;
then the Aggregate Limits of Insurance also include the sum of any damages that result from these coverages with respect to "Garage Operations"—Other Than Covered "Autos."
A clarification is made at this point in the coverage form. It states that those damages payable under the Each Accident Limit of Insurance for "Garage Operations"—Other Than Covered "Autos" must be paid under that portion of the liability section and Each Accident Limit and cannot be paid under the "Garage Operations"—Covered "Autos" Each Accident Limit of Insurance. This clarification has been used for two reasons: first to make sure that a "Garage Operations"—Other Than Covered "Autos" is applied to the proper Each Accident Limit of insurance and subject to the appropriate aggregate limit of insurance. If incorrectly applied to the "Garage Operations"—Covered "Autos" Each Accident Limit of Insurance, no aggregate limit would apply. The second purpose of this clarification is to make the two each accident limits mutually exclusive and avoid collecting twice under the same policy for the same "accident."
Example: An insured is found liable for a total of $2,000,000 in damages for an other than covered "auto" loss, but the garage policy declarations show only a limit of $1,000,000 for the each accident limit of insurance for an other than covered "auto" loss and also $1,000,000 for the each accident for a covered "auto" loss, the policy would not make available a total of $2,000,000. The $1,000,000 for the each accident for a covered "auto" loss would not apply to that other than covered "auto" "accident."
The most that will be paid for damages from "bodily injury" and "property damage" that result from any one "accident" is the Each Accident Limit of Insurance that has been indicated in the declarations for "Garage Operations"—Other Than Covered "Autos."
The Coverage Form clarifies the intent of "accident" by expanding its meaning to include all "bodily injury" and "property damage" that results from a continuous or repeated exposure to substantially the same conditions, to be considered a result for one "accident."
An explanation is made regarding the application of the Aggregate Limits of Insurance for "Garage Operations"—Other Than Covered "Autos." The limits apply separately to each annual 12 month policy period, starting at the inception of the policy. If there is any remaining period of less than 12 months, the limits apply separately to that period also, unless the policy was extended for that period, in which case, the extended period is part of the preceding policy period for purposes of application of the limits.
Example: The insured starts with a policy that was originally issued with January 1 to January 1 inception and expiration dates. In the second policy period, the insured requests that the policy expiration be extended from January 1 until July 1 to match the insured's accounting year. The policy limits apply separately to the first annual 12 month policy period of January 1 to January 1. They also apply separately to the second policy period which has been extended and is now 18 months long, from January 1, extended past the following January 1 to July 1. From that point, the annual 12 month period of July 1 to July 1 will each have their own separate application of policy limits.
2. LIMIT OF
INSURANCE—"GARAGE OPERATIONS"—COVERED "AUTOS"
The most the insurer will pay, for the total of all damages including any "covered pollution cost or expense" that results from any one covered "accident" as a result of "garage operations" involving the ownership, maintenance or used of covered "autos," is the Each Accident Limit of Insurance for "Garage Operations"—Covered "Autos," as shown in the Declarations. This limit is applied, no matter how many insureds are shown, how many "autos" are covered, how many vehicles are involved in the "accident," the premium paid, or the number of claims made.
Example: The two named insureds on a Garage Policy are Smith, Inc. and the individual who owns the corporation, John Smith. The corporation owns several private passenger vehicles that John uses for both business and pleasure. One evening while using a vehicle on a personal errand, John causes a serious accident that is his fault. The injured party sues both John as an individual and Smith, Inc. as the vehicle owner, for $500,000 each, because of the severity of the injury. The Garage Policy has a limit of liability of $500,000, Each Accident for “Garage Operations” – Covered “Autos”. The claimant is awarded $1,000,000 or $500,000 from each of the named insureds; however, the insurance under the Garage Policy pays a total of $500,000.
No matter how many named insureds are shown, the Each Accident Limit of Liability for "Garage Operations"—Covered "Autos" is the maximum that will be paid in any one covered accident.
The "Garage Operations"—Covered "Autos" Limit of Insurance has the same clarification as explained above, indicating that if the "accident" is a result of "Garage Operations"—Covered "Autos," it should be paid under the Each Accident Limit of Insurance for "Garage Operations"—Covered "Autos" and not under the Each Accident Limit of Insurance for "Garage Operations"—Other Than Covered "Autos."
The definition of "accident" also includes all "bodily injury," "property damage," or "covered pollution cost or expense" that occurs as a result of continuous or repeated exposure to substantially the same conditions.
The final paragraph of the section applying to Limit of Insurance clarifies that no one is entitled to receive duplicate payments for the same elements of "loss" under the Garage Coverage Form, any coverage part, or any endorsement attached to this Coverage Part.
D. DEDUCTIBLE
A $100 deductible applies in limited circumstances. The deductible is triggered by accidental property damage suffered by an "auto" caused by work performed by the insured, on that "auto."
A. COVERAGE
The insurer agrees to pay the amounts that the insured becomes liable for, as a result of damages to a customer’s auto or to a customer’s auto equipment, while the customer’s auto or auto equipment has been left in the care of the insured. This endorsement further specifies the valid circumstances of care that are covered. These are: attending, servicing, repairing, parking or storing at the insured’s garage operations.
Three Physical Damage Coverage options are:
A. Comprehensive Coverage—damage from any cause except the customer’s auto’s collision with another object or the customer’s auto’s overturn.
B. Specified Cause of Loss Coverage—damage from fire, lightning, explosion, theft, mischief or vandalism.
C. Collision Coverage—damage caused by the customer’s auto’s collision with another object or the customer’s auto’s overturn.
The insurer has the right and the duty to defend the insured for any suit for those damages that are covered by this insurance. The insurer has no right or obligation to defend against any suit for damages not covered by this insurance. The insurer may at any time and at the insurer’s discretion investigate or settle any claim or suit. The option to settle the claim or loss out-of-court is the insurer’s. The insurer is no longer obligated to provide defense, and the insurer’s right and duty to defend ends, when the Limit of Insurance is spent in payments of either judgments or settlements. Once the policy limits have been paid in settlement of claims, awards or judgments, the insurer no longer is obligated to provide any additional defense, even if additional claims, losses or suits are filed against the insured.
WHO IS AN INSURED
The named insured is an insured along with partners of partnerships, members of limited liability companies, employees, along with directors or shareholders of the named insured, while they are acting within the scope of their duties to the named insured.
COVERAGE EXTENSIONS
Five supplementary payments are provided for in this endorsement. These supplementary payments are in addition to the Limits of Insurance stated in the declarations. They are as follows:
a. All expenses the insurer incurs. This item clarifies that the limit of insurance is not reduced by the insurer’s expenses.
b. Cost of bonds needed to release attachments in a suit are provided for, if the amount of the bond is within the applicable policy limit.
c. If the insurer requests the insured to participate in any investigation or defense, reasonable expenses are provided for the insured. This includes any actual loss of earnings, up to $250 a day, if the insured must take time off work. All costs taxed against the insured in the suit; in cases where the court assesses the costs and expense of the trial against the negligent party, this supplementary payment can provide some extensive benefits, over and above the policy limits. Interest on the amount of the judgment that has accrued after the judgment has been entered, but before the insurer has paid the judgment or the policy limits, is covered in full.
EXCLUSIONS
Some significant exclusions apply to the coverage provided in this endorsement and should be carefully reviewed. The first group of exclusions explains the types of damages not covered, and the second group explains the types of property or equipment not covered.
Excluded are:
a. Contractual Obligations and any liability that may result from any agreement in which any insured has accepted responsibility for loss.
b. Theft or conversion caused in any way by the insured, employees of the insured, or shareholders of the insured.
c. Defective Parts or materials.
d. Faulty Work performed by the insured.
Also excluded is loss to any of the following types of equipment:
· Tape decks or other sound reproducing equipment unless permanently installed in a customer’s auto.
· Tapes, records or other sound reproducing devices designed for use with sound reproducing equipment.
· Sound receiving equipment designed to use as a citizens' band radio, two-way mobile radio, telephone or scanning monitor receiver, including related antennas and accessories, unless permanently installed in the dash or console opening normally used by the manufacturer for the installation of a radio.
·
Any equipment designed or used to detect or
locate radar including jamming apparatus
and laser detectors.
LIMIT OF INSURANCE AND DEDUCTIBLE
Three clarifications exist with regard to the Limits of Insurance and the application of the deductible as they apply to the Garagekeepers Coverage:
1. The most the insurer will pay for each loss at each location is the limits shown in the Garagekeepers Endorsement schedule for that specified location, for the coverages designated, minus the deductible shown for that coverage. The limit shown is the maximum amount available for any one loss regardless of the number of customers’ autos, insureds, claims or suits that may result, or the amount of premium that has been paid.
Example: To illustrate, a fire damages 4 vehicles in one loss, for a total of $65,000 in damages. If the limit shown is $50,000, then the maximum that will be paid for this loss is $50,000. It is very important that one of the considerations the insured makes in selecting both the coverage and the limit is the total number of vehicles in the insured’s care at any one time and the current cost of those types of automobiles.
2. The maximum deductible stated in the Garagekeepers Coverage schedule for Comprehensive or Specified Causes of Loss Coverage is the most that will be deducted for all the claims, losses or damages that result from any one event of theft, mischief or vandalism.
When Comprehensive or Specified Causes of Loss Coverage has been selected, two deductibles need to be designated. The first is a deductible for each auto, and the second is the maximum for a theft, mischief or vandalism loss.
Example: If the same four vehicles were damaged in the same vandalism loss, the deductible would be handled as follows: If a $100 deductible was selected for each, subject to a $500 maximum, then $100 times the four vehicles would equal $400 total in deductibles and the maximum would not come in to play. If, however, the maximum was $250 instead of $500, then only a $250 deductible would be the responsibility of the insured based on the maximum or deductible cap for theft, mischief or vandalism loss.
This maximum or cap does not apply to any other causes of loss other than theft, mischief or vandalism. Any other cause of loss, such as fire, will be assessed for each auto's deductible.
3. At times, the insurer will pay all or a part of the deductible in order to settle or handle a claim or suit to everyone’s best advantage. In those cases, the insured is obligated to reimburse the insurer for the deductible or any portion of the deductible that the insurer has paid.
A. COVERAGE
The insurer will pay for "loss" to a covered "auto" and its equipment for the following coverages if they have been selected in the Declarations and a symbol has been inserted showing the covered "autos":
Comprehensive Coverage - any cause except collision by the covered "auto" with another object or overturn of the covered "auto." This coverage is similar in response to the Special Cause of Loss provided in Property or Inland Marine Policies and covers all types of physical damage losses unless excluded.
Specified Causes of Loss Coverage: caused by:
·
fire,
lightning or explosion
·
theft
·
windstorm,
hail or earthquake
·
flood
·
mischief
or vandalism
· sinking, burning, collision or derailment of any conveyance transporting the covered "auto"
This coverage is a limited Physical Damage Coverage, in that only those causes of loss that are specified are covered, unlike the Comprehensive which covers all causes of loss unless excluded.
c. Collision Coverage: caused by the covered "auto's" collision with another object or overturn of the covered "auto."
When used in this portion of the Coverage Form, "another object" is not limited to just another vehicle, but could be an animal, bird, person, tree, building, sign or so forth.
Towing—Non-Dealers Only: The insurer will pay up to the limit shown in the Declarations for towing and labor costs incurred as a result of the disablement of a covered private passenger type "auto"; however, the labor must be performed at the place of disablement. This coverage applies only if the insured, as listed in the Declarations, is not an "auto" dealer.
An endorsement available for additional or broader coverage is CA 99 23—Rental Reimbursement Coverage. When a covered "auto" that has been scheduled in the endorsement has suffered a physical damage loss from a covered cause of loss, as indicated in the endorsement by the insertion of a premium, rental reimbursement is provided for that "auto" subject to the maximum limit shown for any one day, the number of days indicated, and the total amount shown for any one period. Several limitations or exclusions apply, such as the exclusion stating that if other spare or reserve "autos" are available, the coverage does not apply. The formula for the computation of the increase in premium is found in the ISO Garage Rating Program.
Glass Breakage—Hitting a Bird or Animal—Falling Objects or Missiles: When Comprehensive Coverage is carried by the insured, the insurer will pay for glass breakage, "loss" caused by hitting a bird or animal, and "loss" caused by falling objects or missiles, under the Comprehensive Coverage. If a glass "loss" occurs as a result of the covered "auto’s" collision or overturn, the insured has the option of covering the glass "loss" under the Collision Coverage.
4. Coverage Extension:
Transportation: If a covered private passenger type "auto" carries comprehensive or specified causes of loss coverage and a theft occurs to that covered "auto," this extension provides coverage for temporary transportation costs when the theft is a total theft of the covered vehicle. If items such as tires are the only things taken, this extension is not available. Coverage is available for the period that begins 48 hours after the theft and ends when the covered "auto" is returned to use or the insurer pays for its "loss," regardless of when the policy expires. The amount of coverage is up to $20 per day with a maximum amount available of $600. Changes: Note that the rates have gone from $15 to $20 per day and the maximum amount increased from $450 to $600.
Loss of Use Expenses: If Hired Auto Physical Damage has been purchased then this policy will pay the expenses an insured must pay under a written rental contract or agreement. The coverage depends on the coverage selected for any covered "auto" on the policy declarations. This is limited to $20 per day and $600 maximum. Higher limits may be purchased with endorsement CA 99 90.
1. Excluded is any coverage for, caused by, or resulting from the following, regardless of any other cause, event that contributes concurrently, or in any sequence to the "loss":
a. Nuclear Hazard: the explosion of any weapon using atomic fission or fusion, or nuclear reaction, radiation or radioactive contamination; no matter how caused.
b. War or Military Action: war, whether declared or undeclared, civil war, warlike action by a military force which includes acts of defense or to hinder any such insurrection, rebellion, revolution, usurped power or any action to hinder or defend against such.
The wording in the first sentence of this exclusion is intended to clarify that the doctrines of concurrent causation and proximate cause do not apply to the Nuclear Hazards and War or Military Action Exclusions. These type "losses" are excluded no matter how caused or whether or not in combination with any other cause of "loss."
2. No coverage is available for a covered "auto" that has been leased or rented to others, except in those cases where it is rented to a customer while that customer’s "auto" has been left with the insured for servicing or repair.
No coverage exists under the Garage Policy for any covered "auto" while it is used in, practicing for or being prepared for any professional or organized racing, demolition contest or stunting activity.
For insurers and brokers that have access to coverage for a variety of difficult business "auto" or trucking situations such as racing activities, refer to the section for Automobiles, Trucks or Recreational Vehicles in The Insurance Marketplace, published by The Rough Notes Company, Inc.
The following types of property are not covered:
· tapes, records, discs or other similar audiovisual equipment or data electronic devices designed for use with such type equipment;
· equipment designed or used to detect, locate, jam or disrupt any type of speed measurement devices including but not limited to radar or laser devices;
· any electronic equipment, whether or not permanently installed, that receives or transmits audiovisual or data signals and that is not designed solely for sound reproduction;
· any accessories used with the electronic equipment described in the paragraph above.
However, the exclusions above for electronic equipment, whether or not permanently installed, that receives or transmits audiovisual or data signals and that is not designed solely for sound reproduction; and accessories used with electronic equipment, do not apply to:
a. equipment and its accessories, designed only for sound reproduction, that is permanently installed in the covered "auto" at the time of "loss" or if that equipment is removable from a permanently installed housing unit, and which the equipment is designed to operate only off the power of the "auto’s" electrical system; and
b. any other electrical equipment that is normal to the operation of the covered "auto," that monitors the operating system, or that is an integral part of the same unit housing any sound reproduction equipment and permanently installed in the opening of the dash or console normally used by the manufacturer for installation of a radio.
An endorsement available to provide this coverage is CA 99 30—Tapes, Records and Discs Coverage. For the additional premium stated, this endorsement extends Physical Damage Coverage for tapes, records and discs in covered "autos" for up to $200. The formula for the computation of the increase in premium is found in the ISO Garage Rating Program.
An option to the above is CA 99 60—Audio, Visual and Data Electronic Equipment Coverage. This is a buyback endorsement for Physical Damage Coverage to audiovisual and data electronic equipment that is excluded in the Coverage Form. This buyback applies only to the equipment that is permanently installed or which is removable from a housing unit that is permanently installed. Those "autos" that are covered by this endorsement must be scheduled and a $100 deductible applies. The formula for the computation of the increase in premium is found in the ISO Garage Rating Program.
For a complete list of endorsements that apply to the garage policy, refer to PF&M section 220.4-3.
3. False Pretense: No coverage is available for any "loss" to a covered "auto" that is caused by or that results from either someone causing the insured to voluntarily part with the "auto" by trick or scheme or under false pretenses; or if the insured acquires an "auto" from a seller who did not have legal title to that "auto."
Refer to endorsement CA 25 03—False Pretense Coverage. Dealers and garage operations that receive used vehicles for trade-in may purchase False Pretense Coverage by using this endorsement. The insured would be protected up to the specified limit for vehicles acquired from customers by the false pretense of the customer. The formula for the computation of the increase in premium is found in the ISO Business Auto Rating Program.
4. When the insured is shown as an "auto" dealership in the Declarations, there is no coverage for:
a. the expected profit of the insured, and there is no coverage for the loss of market value or resale value. This diminution of value most often happens when a new auto suffers some type of physical damage such as paint damaged from a hailstorm. The vehicle is repaired but market value has diminished, as it can no longer be sold as a new vehicle. The garage form did not specifically address diminution of value in the past, but now it is made clear that there is no such coverage.
b. any "loss" to a covered "auto" that is displayed or stored at a location that is not listed as a covered location for Physical Damage in the Declarations, when that loss occurs more than 45 days after the insured’s use of that location begins. This allows 45 days of temporary coverage for a newly acquired location, but once that location has been in the insured’s use more than 45 days, no coverage exists unless added or endorsed to the policy;
c. Collision Coverage is excluded when driven or transported more than 50 road miles away from either the point of purchase or distribution; and
d. loss to a covered auto that is caused by or resulting from the collision or upset of a vehicle transporting it. This exclusion only applies to Specified Causes of Loss Coverage.
Refer to endorsement CA 25 02—Dealers Driveaway Collision Coverage. Dealers and garage operations that have a driveaway exposure may need additional Collision Coverage that may be provided through this endorsement, which eliminates the 50 mile cap; however, if this endorsement is used, the insured must provide additional information with the periodically required reports. Any increase in premium for the use of this endorsement is at the discretion of the insurer.
5. The diminution of
value does not add to the loss. The term diminution of value is defined in
Section V Definitions.
Example: The insured has a collision loss and the vehicle is repaired. The repair shop explains to the insured that their car is now worth less than before the loss just because people will not pay as much for a car that has been in an accident. The insured presents that perceived loss of value to the company and is denied.
6. Other Exclusions: Excluded is coverage for "loss" caused by or that results from the following: wear and tear, freezing, mechanical or electrical breakdown; or from blowouts, punctures or other road damage to tires; however, if any of the previous are caused by a "loss" that is covered by this coverage form, then the exclusion does not apply.
There are no current ISO endorsements available to buy back or delete this exclusion. The insured should consider checking into the special warranty, labor and replacement programs that are available through many dealerships for this protection.
This section has been revised significantly as an attempt to clarify. Two new sentences are added to make sure the insured is only brought back to the condition the car was in prior to any accident.
1. The maximum amount that the insurer will pay for "loss" in any one "accident" is the lesser of the following:
a. The actual cash value of the damaged or stolen property, at the time of the "loss"
b. The cost to repair or replace the damaged or stolen property with other property of like kind and quality.
Adjustments must be
made for physical condition and depreciation to determine the actual cash value.
If fixing the auto increases the value, the company does not pay for that betterment.
One endorsement, CA 99 28—Stated Amount Insurance, is available to amend the limit of liability for physical damage coverages. For those vehicles that are scheduled in the endorsement, the limit for the physical damage coverages is changed to the least of the actual cash value, the cost to repair or replace, or the limit that is specified in the endorsement schedule. The formula for the computation of the increase in premium is found in the ISO Garage Rating Program.
2. Additional provisions apply to those insureds who are shown as auto dealerships in the declarations:
a. the most that will be paid at any one location, regardless of the number of "autos" involved, is the amount that is shown in the Auto Dealers Supplementary Schedule for that location. If the loss is a transit loss, no matter how many vehicles have been damaged or suffer loss, the most that will be paid is the amount shown in the Auto Dealers Supplementary Schedule for loss in transit;
b. when the policy is on a Reporting Basis, whether monthly or quarterly, if the actual value on the date of a report exceeds the reported value as of that date, the insured is only obligated to pay a percent of the loss. That percent is determined by dividing the total reported value for the involved location, by the value the insured actually had on the date of the last report. For delinquent reports, the most the insurer will pay is 75% of the Limit of Insurance shown in the Auto Dealers Supplementary Schedule for that location; and
c. for non-reporting policies, if the actual value is greater than the stated value, the insurer is not obligated to pay the entire limit. Only a percent will be paid based on stated limit, divided by the actual limit the insured had on the date of the "loss."
D. DEDUCTIBLE
The insurer will pay for repair, return or replacement of damaged or stolen property for each covered "auto," minus the deductible shown in the Declarations, subject to the following:
1. "Auto" Dealers Only Special Deductible Provisions:
a. if the insured is shown as an auto dealer in the Declarations, the Comprehensive or Specified Causes of Loss Coverage deductible applies only to those losses that are caused by theft, mischief or vandalism; and
b. no matter how many autos are involved, the per loss deductible shown in the Declarations for Comprehensive or Specified Causes of Loss is the maximum that will apply to any one event caused by theft, mischief or vandalism.
2. Non-Dealers Only Special Deductible Provisions:
If the insured is shown as something other than an auto dealer in the Declarations, the deductible that applies to the Comprehensive Coverage does not apply to any "loss" caused by fire or lightning.
Two groups of Conditions are found in this section of the Coverage Form. One is Loss Conditions and the other is General Conditions. Both of these sets of Conditions apply in addition to the Common Policy Conditions that should be attached to the Garage Coverage Form in the development of a Garage Policy.
A. LOSS CONDITIONS
1. APPRAISAL FOR PHYSICAL DAMAGE LOSS: If the insurer and the insured do not agree to the amount of the "loss," either party may demand an appraisal. When this occurs, each party selects a competent appraiser, both of whom will select together a competent and impartial umpire. Each appraiser will separately state the actual cash value and amount of "loss." If the two appraisers do not agree, they will submit their differences to the umpire. When any two of the three agree, that decision is binding on all parties. The insurer and the insured will each pay the cost of the appraiser that they selected but will bear the expense of the umpire and costs of the appraisal equally.
Even though the insurer has submitted to an appraisal, the insurer retains the right to deny the claim.
2. Duties In the Event Of Accident, Claim, Suit or Loss: The insurer has no duty to provide any coverage under this coverage form unless the insured has complied fully with the following duties: a. When any of these events occur, the insured must give either the insurer or an authorized representative of the insurer prompt notice of such, including:
1. how, when and where the "accident" or "loss" occurred
2. the insured’s name and address
3. if known, the names and addresses of any injured persons or of any witnesses
b. any involved insured must:
1) under no circumstances, make any obligation, payment or incur any expense without the insurer’s consent. To do so is at the insured’s expense.
2) immediately send the insurer copies of any request, demand order, notice, summons or legal paper received regarding the claim or "suit"
3). cooperate with the insurer in the investigation, settlement of the claim or defense of the "suit”
4) provide the insurer with authorization to obtain all medical records or other pertinent information
5) as often as the insurer reasonably requires, the insured must submit to examination by a physician of the insurer’s choice and at the insurer’s expense
c. or physical damage losses to a covered "auto" or its equipment, the insured must also do the following items:
1) notify the police promptly of any theft of a covered "auto" or its equipment
2) take all reasonable steps to protect the covered "auto" from further damage and keep a record of any expenses to be considered in the settlement of the claim
3) before the insurer repairs or provides disposition of the claim, the insured must allow the insurer to inspect the covered "auto" or any necessary records to prove "loss"
4) agree to examination under oath if requested by the insurer and provide the insurer with a signed statement of those answers
3. Legal Action Against Us: No one may bring legal action against the insurer under this coverage form until:
a. there has been full compliance with all terms of this coverage form
b. with respect to any liability coverage provided in this insurance, the insurer agrees in writing that the insured has an obligation to pay, or the amount of that obligation has been determined by judgment after trail. No one has the right under this policy to bring the insurer into any action to determine the insured’s liability.
4. Loss Payment—Physical Damage Coverages: The insurer has the option to determine which of the following methods will be used for payment of "loss":
a. to pay for, repair or replace the damaged or stolen property
b. return the stolen property, at the insurer's expense; the insurer will also pay for any damages that result to the "auto" from the theft
c. take all or any part of the damaged or stolen property at an agreed or appraised value.
Any payment made will include sales tax, where applicable.
5. Transfer Of Rights Of Recovery Against Others To Us: If the insurer has made payments to a party under this coverage form, any rights that party may have to recover from another are transferred to the insurer, and that party receiving payment must do everything necessary to secure the rights of the insurer to recover, doing nothing to impair those rights.
1. Bankruptcy: Even if the insured or the estate of the insured becomes bankrupt or insolvent, the insurer is still obligated under this coverage part and not relieved of any responsibilities.
2. Concealment, Misrepresentation or Fraud: This coverage form is void in any case of fraud by the insured at any time as it relates to this coverage form. It is also void if the insured or any other insured at any time intentionally conceals or misrepresents material facts concerning:
a. this coverage form
b. the covered "auto"
c. the insured’s interest in the covered "auto"
d. a claim under this coverage form
3. Liberalization: If the insurer revises this coverage form by providing broader or more coverage without an additional premium charge, the insured’s policy will automatically provide the additional coverage as of the day the revision is effective in the insured’s state.
4. No Benefit To Bailee—Physical Damage Coverages: The insurer does not recognize any assignment or grant any coverage for the benefit of any party while holding, storing or transporting property for a fee, regardless of any other provision of this coverage form.
5. Other Insurance:
a. For covered "autos" owned by the insured, this insurance is primary. For covered "autos" not owned by the insured, this insurance is excess over any other collectible insurance. When a "trailer" that is considered a covered "auto" is connected to another vehicle, the liability coverage provided for the "trailer" is excess when connected to a vehicle not
owned by an insured.
b. If hired auto physical damage coverage applies, then any covered "auto" the insured leases, hires, rents or borrows is considered an owned, covered "auto," unless that "auto" is leased, hired, rented or borrowed with a driver.
An endorsement is available to add coverage should an employee hire an auto in their own name as an individual to perform business-related duties and activities for his/her employer. The endorsement is CA 20 54—Employee Hired Autos.
c. Regardless of the provisions of paragraph a, liability coverage in this coverage form is primary for any liability that has been assumed in an "insured contract."
d. When any other insurance covers the "loss" on the same basis, regardless of whether primary or excess, the insurer will only pay their share. The insurer’s share is the proportion that the limit of insurance of this coverage form bears to the total of the limits of all coverage forms and policies that apply on the same basis.
Ratios will be determined based on each insurer’s percent of limits to the total limits applicable. The "loss" will be proportioned among the insurers accordingly.
Example: Policy A has a limit of $50,000. Policy B has a limit of $100,000 and Policy C has a limit of $1,000,000. The total of all limits available to pay claims is $1,150,000. Company A has 50,000/1,150,000 of the obligation or roughly 4%. Company B has 100,000/1,150,000 of the obligation or about 9%. The remaining 87% is attributed to Company C with 1,000,000/ 1,150,000. The total amount that the insured is judged liable for is $500,000. Company A pays $20,000, Company B pays $45,000, and Company C pays the remaining $435,000.
6. Premium Audit:
a. The deposit or estimated premium charged for this coverage form has been based on the exposures the insured conveyed to the insurer at policy inception. The insurer will compute the final premium based on the actual exposures of the insured. The estimated premium will be credited against the actual final premium and the first named insured will be billed for any balance. If the estimated premium exceeds the actual final premium, the first named insured will receive any refund.
b. If the policy is issued for more than one year, the premium charged will be computed annually based on the rates of the insurer that are in effect at the beginning of each year of the policy.
7. Policy Period, Coverage Territory: The insurer will cover "accidents" and "losses" under this coverage form involving a covered "auto" that occur:
· during the policy period shown in the declarations
· within the coverage territory
The coverage territory, including while being transported between any of these places, is:
a. the United States of America
b. the territories and possessions of the USA
c. Puerto Rico
d. Canada
Example: An insured covered by a garage policy has a vehicle stolen from a salesperson at a hotel in Arizona. The insured carried comprehensive coverage, so the theft of the vehicle was covered since it occurred in Arizona during the policy period. However, the thief drove the vehicle into Mexico where the thief was involved in a major accident. One of the parties injured in the accident in Mexico tried to make a claim against the vehicle owner under the owner’s business auto policy. The claimant alleged that the owner was negligent in not properly preventing theft from occurring. The vehicle had no anti-theft devices or alarms. Whether or not the insured was found to be negligent and liable, the garage policy would not respond to the liability claim because the accident occurred in Mexico (outside the covered territory). The insurer denied the liability claim on that basis but made payment for the theft of the vehicle.
e.
Worldwide
coverage is provided if:
The covered auto is
leased, rented or hired for a period of less than 30 days
The responsibility to
pay is determined in the territories listed in a., b., c. or d. above
Example: An insured travels to England for a 3 week vacation. He doesn’t want to be limited by a tour bus, so he rents a car for the trip. As he is going through the lake country, he comes upon a flock of sheep crossing the road. He is mesmerized and forgets where the brake pedal is and runs into the flock and the shepherd. He provides all of his information and is allowed to return to the States. The shepherd decides to sue, and the papers are received at the insured’s office. The insurance company will take on the defense and payment PROVIDED the suit is tried and damages determined in the United States, Puerto Rico, or Canada.
For the Garage Coverage Form, the coverage territory is extended to anywhere in the world if the "bodily injury" or "property damage" is caused by one of the insured’s "products" sold for use in one of the described coverage territories. The original "suit" for damages that result from the "bodily injury" or "property damage" must be first brought in a described coverage territory.
One endorsement is available to minimally expand the coverage territory. The endorsement is CA 01 21—Limited Mexico Coverage. However, because of the very limited nature of this endorsement, it should be read and evaluated carefully before use.
8. Two or More Coverage Forms or Policies Issued by Us: Except for those policies issued specifically as excess policies, if this coverage form and any other coverage form or policy issued to the insured by the insurer and any company affiliated with the insurer apply to the same "accident," the maximum amount that will be paid for the total limit of insurance under all the coverage forms or policies shall not exceed the highest applicable Limit of Insurance under any one coverage form or policy.
Example: The insured has three policies with the insurer, all carrying symbol 1—Any Auto for Liability Coverage. Policy one has a liability limit of $1,000,000, policy two has a liability limit of $500,000 and policy three has a liability limit of $750,000. The total amount available to pay losses from any one accident is the highest of any one of the three policies or $1,000,000 and not the accumulated limit of $2,250,000.
The words shown in quotation marks throughout this analysis of the Garage Coverage Form are defined in Section VI.
"Accident": includes continuous or repeated exposure to the same conditions that result in "bodily injury" or "property damage."
"Auto": a land motor vehicle, trailer or semitrailer.
"Bodily Injury": bodily injury, sickness or disease sustained by a person, including death resulting from any of these.
"Covered Pollution Cost Or Expense": any cost or expense resulting from:
· Any request, demand or order; or
· Any claim or "suit" by or on behalf of a governmental authority demanding that the "insured" or others test for, monitor, clean up, remove, contain, treat, detoxify, neutralize or in any way respond to or assess the effects of "pollutants."
"Covered pollution cost or expense" does not include any cost or expense arising out of the actual, alleged or threatened discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration, release or escape of "pollutants":
a. That are, or that are contained in any property that is:
1. Being transported or towed by, handled or handled for movement into, onto or from the covered "auto";
2. Otherwise in the course of transit by or on behalf of the "insured"; or
3. Being stored, disposed of, treated or processed in or upon the covered "auto"; and does not apply to fuels, lubricants, fluids, exhaust gases or other similar "pollutants" that are needed for or result from the normal electrical, hydraulic or mechanical functioning of the covered "auto" or its parts; if the "pollutants" escape, seep, migrate or are discharged, dispersed or released directly from an "auto" part designed by its manufacturer to hold, store, receive or dispose of such "pollutants"; or
b. Before the "pollutants" or any property in which the "pollutants" are contained are moved from the place where they are accepted by the "insured" for movement into or onto the covered "auto"; or
c. After the "pollutants" or any property in which the "pollutants" are contained are moved from the covered "auto" to the place where they are finally delivered, disposed of or abandoned by the "insured."
Paragraphs b. and c. above do not apply to "accidents" that occur away from premises owned by or rented to an "insured" with respect to "pollutants" not in or upon a covered "auto" if:
1. The "pollutants" or any property in which the "pollutants" are contained are upset, overturned or damaged as a result of the maintenance or use of a covered "auto"; and
2. The discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration, release or escape of the "pollutants" is caused directly by such upset, overturn or damage.
"Customer's
auto" is a land motor vehicle, trailer or semitrailer that a customer
leaves with the named insured for safekeeping, service, repair or storage. An
employee may also be a customer and his family if they pay to have service
performed.
"Diminution in value" is the loss of market value solely due an accident. This loss of value can be actual or perceived.
"Employee": a leased worker is considered as an employee, but a temporary worker is not.
"Garage Operations": the ownership, maintenance or use of locations for garage business and that portion of the roads or other accesses that adjoin these locations. "Garage operations" includes the ownership, maintenance or use of the "autos" indicated in SECTION I of this Coverage Form as covered "autos." "Garage operations" also include all operations necessary or incidental to a garage business.
"Insured": any person or organization qualifying as an insured in the Who Is an Insured provision of the applicable coverage. Except with respect to the Limit of Insurance, the coverage afforded applies separately to each "insured" who is seeking coverage or against whom a claim or "suit" is brought.
"Insured contract" refers to any of the following:
1. a lease of premises
2. a sidetrack agreement
3. any easement or license agreement, except in connection with construction or demolition operations on or within 50 feet of a railroad
4. an obligation required by ordinance with the purpose of indemnifying a municipality, unless it is in connection with work being performed for a municipality
5. That part of any other contract or agreement relating to the named insured's garage business (including an indemnification of a municipality in connection with work performed for a municipality) where the insured assumes the tort liability of another party to pay for "bodily injury" or "property damage" to a third party or organization. Tort liability means a liability that would be imposed by law in the absence of any contract or agreement.
6. elevator maintenance contract
7. That part of any contract or agreement entered into as part of the named insured's garage business that pertains to the rental or lease by the named insured or "employees," of any "auto." However, such contract or agreement shall not be considered an "insured contract" to the extent that it obligates the named insured or "employees" to pay for "property damage" to any "auto" rented or leased.
An "insured contract" does not include that part of any contract or agreement:
· that pays an architect, engineer or surveyor for damages due to making maps, drawing, opinions, designs and other similar activities or from giving or failing to give directions or instructions.
· indemnifies any one for fire damage to the premises rented or loaned to the named insured.
· that pertains to the loan, lease or rental of an "auto" to the insured or any of the insured’s "employees," if the "auto" is loaned, leased or rented with a driver
· that holds a party engaged in the business of transporting property by "auto" for hire, harmless for the insured’s use of a covered "auto" over a route or territory that party is authorized to serve by public authority.
·
that
indemnifies a railroad for losses that result from construction or demolition
within 50 feet of any railroad property, or that affects any railroad bridge,
trestle, track, road-bed, tunnel, underpass, or crossing.
"Leased Worker": a person leased to the insured employer by a labor leasing firm in which there is an agreement between the insured and that labor leasing firm for that employee to perform specified duties relevant to the conduct of the insured’s business operations. Not included as a leased worker is a “temporary worker."
"Loss": direct and accidental loss or damage. But for Garagekeepers Coverage only, "loss" also includes any resulting loss of use.
"Pollutants": any solid, liquid, gaseous or thermal irritant, or contaminant, including smoke, vapor, soot, fumes, acids, alkalis, chemicals and waste. Waste includes materials to be recycled, reconditioned or reclaimed.
"Products": the goods or products made by the insured or sold in a garage business of the insured.
"Property Damage": damage to or loss of use of tangible property.
"Suit": a civil proceeding in which:
1. Damages because of "bodily injury" or "property damage," or
2. A "Covered Pollution Cost or Expense," to which this insurance applies, is claimed.
"Suit" includes:
a. An arbitration proceeding in which such damages or "covered pollution costs or expenses" are claimed and to which the "insured" submits with the insurer’s consent; or
b. Any other alternative dispute resolution proceeding in which such damages or "covered pollution costs or expenses" are claimed and to which the insured submits with the insurer’s consent.
"Temporary Worker": a person furnished or used by the insured to substitute for a permanent employee or to meet short-term situations. (This wording has been changed significantly in 10 01 but the overall intent remains unchanged.)
"Trailer": includes semitrailer.
"Work You Performed": includes
a. Work another party has performed on the insured’s behalf; and
b. The providing of or failure to provide warnings or instructions.
This is a brief summary
of the changes in CA 00 01–Business Auto Coverage Form 03 10 edition compared
to the
03 06 edition. Most of the changes reduce coverage.
A.2. Supplementary
Coverage
This is a reduction in coverage because attorney’s fees or expenses taxed against the insured by the courts are specifically excluded.
B. Exclusions
The Fellow Employee exclusion is broadened to also exclude coverage for any claims for consequential damages by relatives of an injured fellow employee.
B. Exclusions
The last two items under Excluded Property have changed significantly.
3. Wear And Tear And Tire Damage
This exclusion is
rewritten to apply only if damage is confined to the described causes of loss.
It also does not apply when the entire vehicle is stolen. The previous edition
did not use the word confined but the exclusion did not apply if any cause of
loss occurred first or at the same time. There was no specific reference to
theft of the auto.
4. Receiving And Transmitting Equipment
The exception for equipment used solely to reproduce sound is eliminated. This reduces coverage for both the equipment and its accessories.
5. Changes to Exclusion 4.
This is a new exclusion. It was previously part of Exclusion 4. It explains the equipment to which exclusions 4.c and 4.d. do not apply. In order for the exclusion to not apply, the equipment must operate only from the auto’s electrical system and meet any of the following criteria at the time of loss:
C. Limit Of Insurance
A $1,000 sub-limit is added that applies to the equipment described as covered under Excluded Property Exclusion 4. Changes to Exclusion 4. This change means that, even though coverage applies, recovery is limited to not more than $1,000. This could be a significant reduction of coverage.
1. What change was made to the Fellow Employee exclusion under Liability coverage?
2. What reduction in coverage was introduced in Supplementary Payments?
3. How did the Wear And Tear And Tire Damage exclusion change?
4. If a radio in a covered auto is damaged, what was the maximum amount of loss covered under the 03 06 edition compared to the 03 10 edition?
1. The Fellow Employee exclusion was broadened to also exclude coverage for any claims for consequential damages by relatives of an injured fellow employee.
2. The reduction in coverage under supplementary payments excludes attorney's fees or expenses taxed against the insured by the courts.
3. The Wear And Tear And Tire Damage exclusion was rewritten to apply only if damage is confined to the described causes of loss. It also does not apply when the entire vehicle is stolen. The previous edition did not use the word confined but the exclusion did not apply if any cause of loss occurred first or at the same time. There was no specific reference to theft of the auto.
4. The 03 06 edition did not restrict coverage on radios and the limit of insurance applied. The 03 10 edition limits coverage to $1,000.
This Comparison of the ISO CGL and the ISO Garage policies will follow the CGL format. For additional information on the basic coverage forms and the related endorsement:
Policy Feature |
ISO CGL CG 00 01 10 01 |
ISO Garage CA 00 05 10 01 and Broadened
Endorsement CA 25 14 10 01 |
Bodily Injury And
Property Damage Liability |
All sums the insured is legally obligated to pay due to BI or PD. The insurance coverage form must be applicable. |
Same, except the BI or PD must be related to the garage operations and NOT covered autos. |
BI And PD Liability –
cont. |
Legal defense provided for eligible occurrences. The company will decide on investigating/settling any claim, but efforts end when insurance has been exhausted by the payments of judgments. |
Same |
BI And PD Liability –
cont. |
The bodily injury or property damage must be due to an occurrence that happens in the coverage territory and during the policy period. |
The bodily injury or property damage is covered if the accident happens in the coverage territory during the policy period. |
BI And PD Liability –
cont. |
Prior knowledge limitations and damages due to loss of services, loss or care and death are included as damages from bodily injury. |
Same regarding prior knowledge limitations, but no references to consequential loss of service |
Expected and Intended
Injury Exclusion |
No coverage if damages are due to BI and PD which was expected on the part of the insured unless due to reasonable force for protection. |
Same |
Contractual Liability
Exclusion |
No coverage for assumed liability from a contract except: ·
If
liability existed regardless of contract · An insured contract prior to the loss Note: Defense costs for the insured contract parties are included provided they were assumed as part of the signed contract. |
Same regarding assumed liability but no similar reference to assumption of defense costs. |
Liquor Liability
Exclusion |
Only applies if the insured is in the business of liquor sales, distribution, service, manufacturing or furnishing. |
Only applies when a license is required for serving liquor. Refer to host liquor liability coverage for additional coverage. |
Workers Compensation
Exclusion |
No coverage for any workers compensation, disability benefits or similar obligations. |
Same |
Employers’ Liability
Exclusion |
Injuries while working/performing duties, or for injured employee’s family –excluded. Coverage is applicable if assumed through insured contract. |
Same |
Policy Feature |
ISO CGL CG 00 01 10 01 |
ISO Garage CA 00 05 10 01 and Broadened
Endorsement CA 25 14 10 01 |
Employers’ Liability Exclusion – cont. |
Not mentioned |
The entire exclusion does not apply to domestic employees not subject to WC. |
Employers’ Liability
Exclusion – cont. |
No mention – similar to Employment Practices Exclusion – CG 21 47 |
No coverage for any employment related practices such as termination, refusal to employ, harassment, etc. |
Pollution Exclusion |
No coverage except for hostile fire, equipment to heat the building, material brought to a premises in connection with operations performed by named insured or on named insured’s behalf. No coverage for expenses due to any regulatory requirements to test, etc. |
Essentially the same. |
Aircraft, Auto, or
Watercraft Exclusion |
No coverage for any aspect of aircraft, auto or watercraft ownership or operation. No coverage for any of the above even if due to improper supervision.
|
Similar provision, but aircraft and watercraft only – no reference to either auto or to improper supervision. |
Aircraft, Auto, or Watercraft Exclusion – cont. |
There is coverage for: 1) Watercraft on shore 2) Non owned watercraft under 26 feet long 3) Parking of nonowned auto on premises 4) Liability assumed with insured contract 5) Mobile equipment |
Also makes exception to allow coverage for watercraft that is on shore or is nonowned and shorter than 26”. Does not mention other 3 items. |
Mobile Equipment |
No coverage for transporting equipment by owned or rented auto or when using mobile equipment for racing events and other similar activities. |
No such exclusion |
War |
No war coverage but only for assumed liability. (This is changing with new mandatory endorsements). |
Same |
Damage to Property |
No coverage for property damage to: 1. Any property owned, rented or occupied including costs to improve safety. |
Same, except no mention of improved safety costs. |
Damage to Property – cont. |
No coverage for property damage to: 2. Any property sold, abandoned or given away unless built by named insured and never occupied. |
Not mentioned |
Damage to Property – cont. |
3. Any loaned property |
Same |
Damage to Property – cont. |
4. Care, custody or control or personal property. 5. Real property being worked on if damaged by insured’s work except assumed sidetrack liability. |
Similar as it is applicable to all, rather than just personal, property. There is no reference to real property. |
Damage to Property – cont. |
6. Any property damaged because of the insured’s faulty work, unless covered under the products/completed operations hazard. or assumed sidetrack liability |
Same but no exceptions. |
Policy Feature |
ISO CGL CG 00 01 10 01 |
ISO Garage CA 00 05 10 01 and Broadened
Endorsement CA 25 14 10 01 |
Damage to Property – cont. |
There is coverage for items 1, 3, and 4 that rented to a named insured (if rental lasts less than a week). Max. coverage is the applicable Damage to Premises Rented to you Limit. |
Refer to Fire Legal Liability Coverage |
Damage to Property – cont. |
There is coverage for item 2 if the property is built to sell and never occupied. |
Not mentioned |
Damage to the named insured’s product |
No coverage for property damage to own product due to it or any part of it. |
Similar |
Damage to the named insured’s work |
No coverage for property damage to named insured’s work, which comes from the work or any part of it. |
Similar |
Damage to Impaired Property or Property not Physically Impaired |
No coverage for loss of use of property if there is no property damage |
Same |
Recall of Products, Work or Impaired Property |
No coverage for any type of product recall |
Same |
Personal and Advertising Injury Liability |
No coverage for any bodily injury coming from Personal and Advertising Injury |
Refer to Personal and Advertising Injury coverages. Reads the same. |
Fellow Employee |
Not mentioned |
No coverage for injuries to fellow employees |
Personal And Advertising Injury Liability |
Company pays damages an insured must pay that involve personal injuries or certain advertising-related activities that qualify for coverage, including cost of legal defense. Any investigation or payment is at the insurer’s discretion with payment and defense obligations ending when the policy limits are used up. To be eligible for protection, an incident has to take place within the coverage territory and during the policy period. |
Refer to Personal and Advertising Injury coverages. Coverage is the same. |
Knowing Violation of Rights of Another |
No coverage for an insured who knows that he or she has injured a person by violating that person’s rights |
Same |
Material Published with Knowledge of Falsity |
No coverage for communicating (in any way) information that an insured knows is false. |
Same |
Material Published Prior to Policy Period |
Damage or injury related to publication date that is earlier than the policy period is not covered. |
Same |
Criminal Acts |
No coverage for any criminal action by any insured or at any insured’s direction. |
Same |
Breach of Contract |
No coverage for breaching a contract unless it was due to an implied contract regarding the use of advertising ideas. |
Same |
Quality or Performance of Goods – Failure to Conform to Statements |
No coverage if the products being advertised do not do what they are supposed to do. |
Same |
Policy Feature |
ISO CGL CG 00 01 10 01 |
ISO Garage CA 00 05 10 01 and Broadened
Endorsement CA 25 14 10 01 |
Wrong Description of Prices |
No coverage due to a mistake in the price of items in advertisements. |
Same |
Infringement of Patent, Copyright, demark or Trade Secret |
No coverage for infringements except in the named insured’s advertisements |
Not mentioned |
Insureds in Media and Internet Type Businesses |
No coverage for anyone in the business of advertising or media, web designers, internet search providers. (Certain web design aspects are included.) There is coverage for these businesses for “personal injury” only type offenses. |
Same but only as regard the media businesses. |
Electronic Chatrooms or Bulletin Boards |
No coverage for anything that happens on bulletin boards, chatrooms or any similar area hosted or controlled by the insured |
Not mentioned |
Unauthorized Use of Another’s Name Or Product |
No coverage if using another’s name in any of the internet communications in order to mislead the marketplace. |
Not mentioned |
Pollution |
No coverage for pollution |
Same |
Pollution-Related |
No coverage for
pollution cleanup costs or expense |
Same |
Employment Related |
Not mentioned but often excluded using CG 21 47 |
No coverage for employment related offenses. |
Medical Payments
Coverage |
All medical expenses incurred due to an accident either on or next to owned/rented premises or due to operations. The accident must happen during the policy
period and in the coverage territory. All expenses and reports must be in within a year. Any injured person must submit to an independent physical examination. Payment is regardless
of fault and includes first aid, necessary medical services including funeral
services. |
There is no Medical Payments coverage in the policy and the Broadened endorsement does not include it. Attach CA 25 04 to obtain coverage. |
Med Pay Exclusion - Any insured |
The only insured who will receive medical payments is a volunteer worker |
No coverage under forms. |
Med Pay Exclusion - Hired Person |
No coverage for any one hired to work for any insured or any tenant |
No coverage under forms. |
Med Pay Exclusion - Injury on Normally Occupied Premises |
No coverage for someone who is injured in space they normally occupy – such as an apartment tenant |
No coverage under forms. |
Med Pay Exclusion - Workers Compensation And Similar Laws |
No coverage if the injured party is eligible for WC or other benefits due to the loss |
No coverage under forms. |
Med Pay Exclusion - Athletic Activities |
No coverage if the injured party was injured while participating in athletic activities |
No coverage under forms. |
Med Pay Exclusion - Products-Completed Operations Hazards |
No coverage if the accident is part of the products-completed operations hazard |
No coverage under forms. |
Policy Feature |
ISO CGL CG 00 01 10 01 |
ISO Garage CA 00 05 10 01 and Broadened
Endorsement CA 25 14 10 01 |
Med Pay Exclusion -
Coverage A Exclusions |
No coverage if injury is a type that is excluded under the BI
and PD Coverage |
No coverage under forms. |
Med Pay Exclusion - War |
No coverage due to war |
No coverage under forms. |
Insurer expenses |
All paid |
Same |
Bail bonds |
Up to $250 but doesn’t furnish bonds |
Up to $2,000 but doesn’t furnish bonds |
Release attachment bonds |
The cost for a bond up to the limit of insurance |
Same |
Insured expenses |
All reasonable plus loss of earnings up to $250 per day – if insured requests assistance |
Same |
Costs of suit |
All paid |
Same |
Prejudgment interest |
Pay all unless made offer of full limits |
Not mentioned |
Interest after judgment |
Pay all based on limit of insurance |
Same |
Third party supplementary payments |
Paid provided many stipulations are met. However – all payments are within the policy limits |
Not mentioned |
Insured – individual |
Named insured and spouse |
Same |
Insured - partnership |
Named insured, partners and partners spouses |
Similar, but partners and spouses not covered for Pers. and Ad Injury |
Insured - joint venture |
Named insured and members |
Not mentioned |
Insured - limited liability company |
Named insured, members and managers |
Same and includes spouses but does not mention managers |
Insured - Other organization |
Named insured, executive officers, directors and stockholders |
Same |
Insured - Trust |
Named insured and trustees |
Not mentioned |
Insured - Volunteer workers and employees |
Covered but with significant limitations |
Employees covered but no mention of volunteer workers. No limitations. |
Insured - Mobile equipment |
Any person driving named insured’s mobile equipment is an insured with limitations |
Not mentioned |
Insured - Newly Acquired or Formed Organizations |
Coverage is applicable for up to 90 days following the acquisition or formation but not for any prior occurrences or offenses. |
Similar |
Limits on the declarations page |
Declarations limits are most to be paid regardless of number of insureds, suits or claims. |
Same |
The General aggregate |
General Aggregate Limit is to be paid during the policy period for BI, PD, Personal Injury and Medical Payments. A separate limit applies to Prod./Comp. Ops. |
Same except med pay is a separate endorsement and not part of the aggregate. All of the CA 25 14 coverages are part of the aggregate. |
Products/completed operations aggregate limit |
Prod/Compl. Work Aggregate is most to be paid during policy period for all such damages. |
No separate aggregate. Products/completed operations are subject to the general aggregate |
Personal and Advertising Injury Limit |
Personal and Advertising Injury Limit is the most to be paid for all such damage. Also, payments are subject to the deductible and the General aggregate. |
Same |
Policy Feature |
ISO CGL CG 00 01 10 01 |
ISO Garage CA 00 05 10 01 and Broadened
Endorsement CA 25 14 10 01 |
Occurrence Limit |
This is the maximum paid for all damages for all BI, PD, Med Pay and Fire Legal under a single incident and subject to either of the two aggregates. |
Garage uses an Ea. Accident Limit and it is the most to be paid for all damages under all coverages. Medical Payment would remain separate. |
Fire Legal Liability Limit |
Fire Legal Liability occurrence limit is $50,000 and is subject to the occurrence limit. Limit can be increased on Declarations |
Same. Subject to the Aggregate Limit. |
Applicability of Aggregate Limit |
Aggregates apply for the duration of the policy term, whether it is: - 12 months - less than 12 months - more than 12 months - an
extended policy period. |
Same |
Deductible |
No deductible mentioned |
A $100 PD deductible applies to damage caused by work performed by the named insured on a vehicle. |
Bankruptcy |
Bankruptcy of the insured does not impact coverage |
Same |
Duties in the Event of Occurrence, Offense, Claim or Suit |
A number of duties to make sure the insurer’s rights are protected and the insurer is promptly notified |
Similar |
Legal Action Against Us |
Until all conditions of policy are met, the insured cannot sue the company |
Same |
Other Insurance |
This policy is primary unless other coverage is for fire, extended coverage, builders’ risk, installation risk, insured’s work or for loss due to maintenance or use of aircraft, autos or watercraft. If other insurance is primary, this insurer shares the loss by contribution until limit is exhausted. If other policy does not follow contribution, the insurer will pay no one than the fair contribution. If this policy is excess, the insurer has no duty to defend but will do so if no one else does and will take the insured’s rights against the other insurers. The insurer will pay only the amount over the sum of what the other insurers should have paid plus self-insured amounts and deductible owed by the insured. The remaining loss is to be shared with any other excess insurer other than actually purchased “excess insurance.” |
Primary, but the insurer will pay only the fair proportion of the loss whether other coverage is primary or excess |
Premium Audit |
Premiums are estimates and may be audited. |
Similar- however, if policy issued for more than one year, premium must be recomputed at the beginning of each policy year. |
Policy Feature |
ISO CGL CG 00 01 10 01 |
ISO Garage CA 00 05 10 01 and Broadened
Endorsement CA 25 14 10 01 |
Representations |
The insured agrees that the policy matches all statements made by them and that the policy was based on those representations. |
Policy is void if there is any fraud on the part of the named insured. It is also void if there is an intentional concealment or misrepresentation regarding the coverage or any claims. |
Separation of Insureds |
Each insured is treated as if they were the only insured (except regarding max. limit payable) The first named insured has certain assigned rights, but it does not impact the handling of claims. |
The definition of “insured” includes a separation of insured statement. |
Transfer of Rights of Recovery Against Others to Us |
All rights of recovery of the insureds are transferred to the insurer and the insured is not to interfere with them. |
Same except they don’t apply for medical payments coverage |
When We Do Not Renew |
Insurer will give at least 30 days notice to the First Named insured before non-renewal. |
Not mentioned. |
Liberalization |
Not mentioned |
Any free revision will automatically extend to coverage effective as of its approval. |
Two Or More Coverage Forms Or Policies Issued By Us |
Not mentioned |
Regardless the number of policies or forms, the highest applicable limit acts as the single, maximum limit. |
Advertisement |
Information that is publicly broadcast (in any medium) to attract customer sales. If on the internet – only the customer attracting portion on the website is considered advertisement. |
Same except no mention of website or electronic publications |
Auto |
A vehicle that is powered by a motor and is meant for land use, trailers and semi-trailers (meant for public road use). It also includes attached machinery but not mobile equipment. |
Similar but no limitation for public road and no mention of machinery and equipment or mobile equipment. |
Bodily Injury |
Any sickness, disease or other injury to the body of a person including death of that person that results from an injury, sickness or disease. |
Same but also includes incidental medical malpractice provided the insured is not in the heath care business |
Coverage Territory |
United States, Puerto Rico, Canada plus U.S. possessions and territories (Suits MUST occur in these locations). Any int’l space – air or water – between the places above but only during the travel. Worldwide if: 1) Products or goods were made in the above locales 2) The traveler lives in the above and on short term business elsewhere 3) Personal and advertising injury caused by the internet |
Not a defined term – part of the policy conditions. Similar except no mention of the internet. |
Employee |
Leased workers are considered employees, but temporary workers are not |
Same |
Policy Feature |
ISO CGL CG 00 01 10 01 |
ISO Garage CA 00 05 10 01 and Broadened
Endorsement CA 25 14 10 01 |
Executive Officer |
Any person who is in an officer’s position as stated in the company charters, by-laws or similar document |
Not mentioned |
Hostile Fire |
Any fire that escapes its confines |
Not mentioned |
Impaired Property |
Property made useless because it has a product of the named insured that is defective or dangerous or the named insured has not fulfilled a service contract and the property can regain usefulness if the named insured fixes the problem. |
Not mentioned |
Insured Contract |
Insured contract includes: 1) Lease 2) Sidetrack 3) Easements 4) As required by ordinance 5) Elevator maintenance 6) Contractually assuming tort liability Doesn’t include easements to Railroads within 50 ft. of railroad or architects or engineers |
Same except adds that a contract which loans, leases or rents a car with a driver is not an insured contract and that any contract that holds someone harmless who has a public authority to transport goods and the insured is hired to transport for that firm is also not an insured contract. |
Leased Worker |
A person contracted to work for the named insured through a leasing agency but not a temporary worker |
Same |
Loading or unloading |
The handling of items starting at the point of acceptance and ending at the point of delivery. This does not include the use of mechanical devices not attached to aircraft, watercraft or auto. |
Not mentioned |
Mobile Equipment |
A variety of land vehicles that are meant for off road use. |
Not mentioned |
Occurrence |
An accident including continuous exposure to the same conditions |
Not mentioned but the definition of accident is very similar |
Personal and Advertising Injury |
False arrest, wrongful prosecution, improper invasion of tenants rights, slander, libel, violation of rights, use of others ideas in advertising, infringing on copyright, etc., of others in advertising. |
Same |
Pollutants |
Any irritant – solid, liquid, thermal or gas, including waste. |
Same |
Products-completed operations hazards |
Any BI or PD due to products or work except products still in possession and work uncompleted. |
Not mentioned |
Property damage |
Physical damage to property and the loss of use of the property. Also, the loss of use of property even if the property is not physically damaged. Electronic data are not considered tangible property. |
Tangible property damage or loss of use. |
Policy Feature |
ISO CGL CG 00 01 10 01 |
ISO Garage CA 00 05 10 01 and Broadened
Endorsement CA 25 14 10 01 |
Suit |
Any civil proceeding including arbitration and other alternative dispute resolutions where BI, PD, PI or AI are alleged. |
Same |
Temporary worker |
A person who is a substitute for a regular employee or is hired for a short term or seasonal situation |
Same |
Volunteer worker |
Any one who works as an employee but does not receive any type of compensation for any source |
Not mentioned |
Your Product |
Goods that are sold, made, handled, distributed or disposed of by the named insured (or named insured’s behalf), plus the containers for the goods. All warranties and instructions are part of the products. |
Similar but defined as “product.” All goods must be part of the garage business. Does not mention warranties. |
Your work |
Any work done by the named insured or by another for the named insured and all materials that are a part of the process. Includes warranties and instructions. |
Similar but defined as “work you performed.” It does not mention the warranties or materials and parts. |
Accident |
Not mentioned |
Similar to “occurrence” |
Covered pollution cost or expense |
Not mentioned |
Part of the CGL pollution exclusion |
Customers auto |
Not mentioned |
Any auto left by a customer including employees and their family who leave vehicles and will pay for services. |
Diminution in value |
Not mentioned |
Loss of value of a vehicle due to accident. Loss may be actual or perceived. |
Garage operations |
Not mentioned |
All premises associated with a garage business and the adjoined roadways. Also, the operations that are necessary in running a garage business. |
Insured |
Not mentioned |
Refer to the “Who is an insured” section and the “Separation of insured” Condition. |
Loss |
Not mentioned |
Any accidental but direct damage or loss. Under Garagekeepers loss of use is considered part of loss. |
Products |
Not mentioned |
Refer to CGL “Your product” |
Trailer |
Not mentioned |
Any time the work trailer is used it includes the term semi-trailer. |
Work you performed |
Not mentioned |
Refer to CGL “Your Work” |
Host Liquor Liability Coverage |
Not mentioned – but coverage is similar due to the wording of the liquor liability exclusion |
Any serving of alcohol which is incidental to the garage operations is covered for BI and PD provided the named insured is not in the liquor selling, serving, distributing or manufacturing business. |
Policy Feature |
ISO CGL CG 00 01 10 01 |
ISO Garage CA 00 05 10 01 and Broadened
Endorsement CA 25 14 10 01 |
Incidental Medical Malpractice Liability Coverage |
Not mentioned but also no exclusions regarding these activities. A professional exclusion would need to be attached to exclude professional health care services. |
Coverage is provided for injury due to: 1) The providing or failure to provide health care services 2) Giving food/drink for heath care services 3) Giving drugs or other medical devices but no coverage for any insured who is in the business of providing any of the above. |
The ISO Garage Program has recently been revised to add clarity and make the programs more consistent and compatible with other commercial and business policies, such as the Commercial General Liability Policy and the NCCI Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance Policy.
The revised coverage forms and endorsements carry a July 1997 edition date, with the first batch of states implementing the program revisions as of October 1, 1997.
The following are a list of the changes made, grouped by the affected area of the contract that the change was made to. The state supplements are not reviewed here.
Under the Physical Damage Coverage—Coverage Extensions, a change was made to the coverage extension for Transportation Expense. The addition of the word temporary makes it clear that, if transportation expenses are incurred by an insured after a total theft of a covered vehicle, the coverage extension provides only temporary transportation expenses. Although this may appear to be a reduction in coverage, the change was announced (by ISO) as only a clarification (having no rating impact). One question still arises, however. Temporary has not been defined. What is the explanation of temporary, a week, a month, a quarter, a year? Hopefully, future revisions will provide clarity.
The Supplementary Payments coverage has been corrected to read that the protection is for suits against the insured clarifying that it is the insured, not the suit, that is covered. Similar wording in the condition outlining the Duties In the Event Of Accident, Claims, Suit or Loss has been amended. The insured must cooperate with the insurer in any investigation or settlement of the claim or defense against the suit. (“Defense against the suit” is the added wording.)
An increase in coverage has been made to Supplementary Payments. The maximum daily payment for loss of earnings by the insured under this item has been increased from $100 per day to $250 per day. The limit for the cost of bail bonds has also been raised to $2,000 from the previous $250.
Who Is An Insured has been amended to include protection for Limited Liability Companies (LLC).
Symbol 30 of the
Garage Coverage Form has been revised to track with the definition of what is a
customer’s auto as found in Garagekeepers Coverage Form—CA 99 37. The amended
definition now states: “Symbol 30=AUTOS
LEFT WITH YOU FOR SERVICE, REPAIR, STORAGE OR SAFEKEEPING. Any customer’s land
motor vehicle or trailer or semitrailer while left with you for service,
repair, storage or safekeeping. Customers include your employees and members of
their households who pay for the service performed.”
Under the Garage
Coverage Forms, the excess coverage option is amended to clarify that the Direct Coverage Options are not
mutually exclusive of the underlying legal liability coverage. Further,
coverage may apply even when the insured is not legally liable, thus giving the
ability to provide a no-fault type coverage.
Exclusion #4 applies to Employee Indemnification and Employer’s Liability. Within this exclusion, there is an exclusion to the exclusion, which basically means that the exclusion does not apply to domestic employees. However, the term domestic employee has never been defined within the contract. A definition has been added to the exclusion to spell out what is meant by the term “domestic employee.” It refers to anyone who performs duties related to the regular operation of a private residence and would include cooking, cleaning, laundering, gardening, etc.
This exclusion has also been further strengthened by adding new wording to clarify that not only is bodily injury to an employee resulting from employment by the insured excluded, but so is bodily injury to an employee while “performing the duties related to the conduct of the “insured’s“ business.”
Exclusion #5—Fellow Employee has been similarly strengthened and revised by the addition of almost identical wording.
A change to an exclusion found only in the Garage Coverage Form—CA 00 05, is the exclusion dealing with physical damage to an auto dealership. This exclusion previously stated that expected profit was not covered after a physical damage loss. Now it also states that there is no coverage for the loss of market value or resale value. This diminution of value most often happens when a new auto suffers some type of physical damage such as paint damaged from a hail storm. The vehicle is repaired but market value has diminished as it can no longer be sold as a new vehicle. The garage form did not specifically address diminution of value in the past, but now it is made clear that there is no such coverage.
Under the Physical Damage Exclusions, the item pertaining to radar equipment or other such equipment that is designed to detect or locate radar, has been revised to further exclude not only devices to locate or detect speed (which now include both radar and laser equipment), but also any jamming devices which are designed or intended to elude or disrupt speed measurement.
Under the conditions that refer to the Duties in the Event of Accident, Claim, Suit Or Loss, the obligations and duties of the insured have been outlined and the language strengthened to make clear that the insurer has no duty or obligation under the contract until the insured has fully complied with the outlined duties. This is referred to as “conditions precedent” language.
The following new definitions have been added:
EMPLOYEE—although an actual definition for employee itself has not been added, it is made clear that a leased worker is considered an employee, but a temporary worker is not.
LEASED WORKER—means a person that has been leased to the insured by a labor leasing firm where there is an agreement between the insured and the labor leasing firm for that employee to perform the duties necessary to the insured’s business operations.
TEMPORARY WORKER—is a person furnished to the insured for a specific or finite time period, the purpose being to support or supplement the insured’s work force for a special work-related situation. These special work-related situations are defined to include employee absences, temporary skill shortages, and seasonal workloads.
CA 20 47—Additional
Insured—Lessor of Leased Equipment
Provides protection for the owner of leased equipment for the existence hazard only, as it applies to the non-auto exposure under the Garage Coverage Form, for equipment that has been leased to an insured garage or repair shop.
CA 20 48—Designated
Insured
Allows an additional insured to be specifically named as an additional insured for vicarious liability. Note that this coverage is already provided under the WHO IS AN INSURED provision in the business auto policies as protection is granted for any party that is liable for the actions or conduct of a covered insured, but only for the extent of that particular liability, so this endorsement only allows that party to be scheduled or specifically named. This endorsement may be used with any of the business auto coverage forms.
CA 20 49—Additional
Insured - Garages - Grantor of Franchise
Additional insured coverage may be added for the vicarious liability of the grantor of a franchise with respect to the named insured. This endorsement applies only to the Garage Coverage Form.
CA 23 24—Agricultural
Produce Trailers - Seasonal
Use of this endorsement provides liability coverage for farm
trailers that are used only seasonally to haul agricultural produce but not
livestock. The 2,000 pound limit does not apply to this endorsement. The dates
of the seasonal period and the specific produce must be scheduled.
CA 23 25—Coverage For
Injury To Leased Workers
Coverage for bodily injury to leased workers is added by changing the definition of employee in Exclusion #4, Employee Indemnification and Employer’s Liability. The revised definition for employee, for the purposes of this endorsement, does not mean leased employee. The end result of the change is that while the insured’s employees are excluded, leased workers are not (and are thus covered). This endorsement may be used with any of the business auto coverage forms.
CA 02 40—Suspension
of Insurance
Wording has been added with respect to underinsured motorist coverage (UIM), to make it flexible enough to apply whether combined with uninsured motorist coverage (UM) or as a stand-alone option. The following three endorsements are also amended accordingly.
·
CA 20
15—Mobile Equipment
·
CA 20
21—Snowmobiles
·
CA 20
27—Registration Plates Not Issued For A Specific Auto
Further, the Suspension of Insurance endorsement has added a
blank line in order for an insurer to insert a coverage not listed that may
also be suspended by that particular state law.
CA 20 19—Repossessed
Autos
A simple correction has been made to this endorsement to add space to show a limit for any unlisted locations and to specify how the coverage applies to the specific locations listed.
CA 23 17—Truckers -
Intermodal Interchange Uniform Endorsement Form UIIE-1
Various changes have been made in response to the Uniform
Intermodal Interchange and Facility Access Agreement (UIIA) by the Intermodal
Association of North America (IANA).
CA 25 03—False
Pretense Coverage
Previous versions of the endorsement have restricted coverage to only those circumstances where a warrant has been issued for the arrest or detainment of the guilty party; however, since the actual issuance of a warrant is out of the control of the insured, revisions have been made, requiring the insured to make all steps reasonably possible to do such.
An exclusion has been added. Excluded is coverage if a bank or other drawee fails to pay. A second exclusion has been revised to grant coverage for vehicles on consignment.
Under the LIMITS OF INSURANCE, the reference to $25,000 for
this coverage is replaced by the amount shown either in the schedule or in the
declarations.
CA 25 14—Broadened Coverage - Garages
The commercial general liability coverage forms and endorsements have been changed to state that the professional services excluded in the CGL are in fact, professional health care services. CA 25 14 has been revised accordingly.
Further revisions include clarification that the coverages provided by this endorsement apply only to the non-auto exposures or the garage operations only. This is particularly important as there have been attempts to use the LIMITED WORLDWIDE LIABILITY COVERAGE portion of the policy to provide worldwide auto liability protection. That was not the original intent of the endorsement and revisions have been made accordingly.
This endorsement may only be used with the Garage Coverage Form.
CA 99 10—Drive Other
Car Coverage—Broadened Coverage For Named Individuals
The mandatory $50 collision deductible has been deleted.
CA 99 28—Stated
Amount Insurance
A simple revision has been made to clarify that the stated deductible applies to this endorsement.
CA 99
37—Garagekeepers Coverage
The excess coverage option is amended to clarify that the
Direct Coverage Options are not mutually exclusive of the underlying legal
liability coverage. Further, coverage may apply even when the insured is not
legally liable.
CA 99
59—Garagekeepers Coverage—Customers Sound Receiving Equipment
As with the Garagekeepers Coverage, the excess coverage option is amended to clarify that the Direct Coverage Options are not mutually exclusive of the underlying legal liability coverage. Further, coverage may apply even when the insured is not legally liable.
Numerous other editorial changes, corrections, and clarifications have been made to many of the coverage forms and endorsements. Those discussed above are just the most significant. Please review all of the new forms and endorsements prior to using to make sure that the changes and revisions are clearly understood.
1. Explain the change that occurred to the definition of Symbol 30.
2. Discuss the change in the valuation of physical damage coverage that has occurred in the Garage Coverage Form for dealers. What may be its impact?
3. Discuss the change in condition in the False Pretense Endorsement—CA 25 03.
4. Discuss the change in endorsement CA 25 14—Broadened Coverage—Garages.
5. Specify the two dollar amount increases in the Supplementary Payments coverage extensions.
1. Symbol 30 of the Garage Coverage Form has been revised to track with the definition of what is a customer’s auto as found in Garagekeepers Coverage Form—CA 99 37. The amended definition now states: “Symbol 30=AUTOS LEFT WITH YOU FOR SERVICE, REPAIR, STORAGE OR SAFEKEEPING. Any customer’s land motor vehicle or trailer or semitrailer while left with you for service, repair, storage or safekeeping. Customers include your employees and members of their households who pay for the service performed.”
2. A change to an exclusion found only in the Garage Coverage Form—CA 00 05, is the exclusion dealing with physical damage to an auto dealership. This exclusion previously stated that expected profit was not covered after a physical damage loss. Now it also states that there is no coverage for the loss of market value or resale value. This diminution of value most often happens when a new auto suffers some type of physical damage such as paint damaged from a hail storm. The vehicle is repaired but market value has diminished as it can no longer be sold as a new vehicle. The garage form did not specifically address diminution of value in the past, but now it is made clear that there is no such coverage.
3. CA 25 03—False
Pretense Coverage
Previous versions of the endorsement have restricted coverage to only those circumstances where a warrant has been issued for the arrest or detainment of the guilty party; however, since the actual issuance of a warrant is out of the control of the insured, revisions have been made, requiring the insured to make all steps reasonably possible to do such.
An exclusion has been added. Excluded is coverage if a bank or other drawee fails to pay. A second exclusion has been revised to grant coverage for vehicles on consignment.
Under the LIMITS OF INSURANCE, the reference to $25,000 for this coverage is replaced by the amount shown either in the schedule or in the declarations.
4. CA 25 14—Broadened Coverage—Garages
The commercial general liability coverage forms and endorsements have been changed to state that the professional services excluded in the CGL are, in fact, professional health care services. CA 25 14 has been revised accordingly.
Further revisions include clarification that the coverages provided by this endorsement apply to the non-auto exposures or the garage operations only. This is particularly important as there have been attempts to use the LIMITED WORLDWIDE LIABILITY COVERAGE portion of the policy to provide worldwide auto liability protection. That was not the original intent of the endorsement and revisions have been made accordingly.
This endorsement may only be used with the Garage Coverage Form.
5. An increase in coverage has been made to Supplementary Payments. The maximum daily payment for loss of earnings by the insured under this item has been increased from $100 per day to $250 per day. The limit for the cost of bail bonds has also been raised to $2,000 from the previous $250.
The Insurance Services Office, Inc. (ISO) has made and filed a group of changes and revisions to the various commercial auto programs. The changes have been labeled the 1998 Multistate Commercial Auto Revisions, which may be a little confusing as state approvals do not start until February 1, 1999 at the earliest, and the new or revised endorsements carry a February 1999 edition date.
The 1998 revisions contain three new mandatory coverages, a limited number of new optional coverages, as well as editorial corrections. The mandatory changes broaden the coverage offered. The 1998 revisions are not extensive; however, they are beneficial.
The editorial updates and corrections will not be discussed in this analysis.
A new mandatory multistate endorsement, CA 00 22—Changes in Commercial Auto Coverage Forms, has been developed and must be attached to all five commercial auto coverage forms including the Business Auto Coverage Form, the Business Auto Physical Damage Coverage Form, the Garage Coverage Form, the Motor Carrier Coverage Form and the Truckers Coverage Form.
Two coverage grants are added along with a change in the definition of Insured Contract, all of which broaden the protection offered.
Loss of Use—Rental Vehicle Coverage has been added. If an insured rents or leases a private passenger type vehicle and that vehicle is damaged, the lease or rental agreement usually obligates the insured to reimburse the rental or lease operation for the loss of use that operation experiences while the vehicle is out of service being repaired. This coverage adds payment for expenses an insured may be legally obligated to pay to the rental or lease operation—up to $15 per day with a maximum of $450.
Again, the vehicle must be a private passenger type only and must be hired without a driver.
Limited Worldwide Coverage for Hired Autos is a second new coverage added for private passenger type vehicles that are hired without a driver. If an insured rents or leases a private passenger type auto for 30 days or less, anywhere in the world, there is coverage for damages that an insured incurs and is legally obligated to pay based upon a suit brought within the United States, its territories, possessions, Puerto Rico or Canada. There is also coverage for any settlement that the insurer agrees to.
Definition of Insured Contract has been amended in all of the commercial auto programs to make it consistent and compatible with the similar definition found in the commercial general liability policy.
The area of change revolves around the exception for demolition and construction operations within 50 feet of railroad property. Previously in commercial auto, any person or organization involved in a demolition and construction operation that an insured was obligated to indemnify was excluded. The general liability definition and now the new business auto definition exclude only indemnity for railroads.
The endorsements listed below are new optional coverages that may be purchased and apply to all five of the commercial auto programs except the Fellow Employee Coverages, which do not apply to the Business Auto Physical Damage Coverage Form as it does not provide liability coverage.
CA 01 21—Limited
Mexico Coverage
If the insured travels into Mexico on a trip that is 10 days or less and not more than 25 miles from the United States border, this endorsement is available to limited coverage. The intent of this endorsement is to extend the coverage territory to the border towns of Mexico.
Liability insurance must be purchased separately through a licensed Mexican insurance company. To be covered by this policy, any suit must be brought in the United States. The insurance provided by the endorsement is excess over the Mexican insurance and other collectible insurance.
CA 20 54—Employee Hired Autos
Should an employee hire an auto in his/her own name as an individual to perform business-related duties and activities for his/her employer, there would be liability coverage via this endorsement if the hire was done with the permission and approval of the employer.
CA 20 55—Fellow Employee Coverage
If an employer wishes to delete the fellow employee exclusion for all employees from the commercial auto coverage form, this endorsement may be purchased.
CA 20 56—Fellow Employee Exclusions For Designated Employees/Positions
If an employer wishes to delete the fellow employee
exclusion for specific employees or specific positions only from the commercial
auto coverage form, this endorsement may be purchased.
1. How have the 02/99 updates been accomplished?
2. Explain the change regarding Loss of Use on rental vehicles.
3. Explain the limited worldwide coverage provided for autos.
4. How has the definition of Insured Contract been changed?
5. Discuss the Limited Mexico Coverage.
6. Discuss the Employee Hired Autos.
7. Discuss the Fellow Employee Coverage.
8. Discuss the endorsement for Fellow Employee Exclusions For Designated Employees/Positions.
1. A new mandatory multistate endorsement, CA 00 22—Changes in Commercial Auto Coverage Forms, has been developed and must be attached to all five commercial auto coverage forms including the Business Auto Coverage Form, the Business Auto Physical Damage Coverage Form, the Garage Coverage Form, the Motor Carrier Coverage Form and the Truckers Coverage Form.
Two coverage grants are added along with a change in the definition of Insured Contract, all of which broaden the protection offered.
2. Loss of Use—Rental Vehicle Coverage has been added. If an insured rents or leases a private passenger type vehicle and that vehicle is damaged, the lease or rental agreement usually obligates the insured to reimburse the rental or lease operation for the loss of use that operation experiences while the vehicle is out of service being repaired. This coverage adds payment for expenses an insured may be legally obligated to pay to the rental or lease operation—up to $15 per day with a maximum of $450. Again, the vehicle must be a private passenger type only and must be hired without a driver.
3. Limited Worldwide Coverage for Hired Autos is a second new coverage added for private passenger type vehicles that are hired without a driver. If an insured rents or leases a private passenger type auto for 30 days or less, anywhere in the world, there is coverage for damages that an insured incurs and is legally obligated to pay based upon a suit brought within the United States, its territories, possessions, Puerto Rico or Canada. There is also coverage for any settlement that the insurer agrees to.
4. Definition of Insured Contract has been amended in all of the commercial auto programs to make it consistent and compatible with the similar definition found in the commercial general liability policy.
The area of change revolves around the exception for demolition and construction operations within 50 feet of railroad property. Previously in commercial auto, any person or organization involved in a demolition and construction operation that an insured was obligated to indemnify was excluded. The general liability definition and now the new business auto definition exclude only indemnity for railroads.
5. CA 01 21—Limited
Mexico Coverage
If the insured travels into Mexico on a trip that is 10 days or less and not more than 25 miles from the United States border, this endorsement is available to limited coverage. The intent of this endorsement is to extend the coverage territory to the border towns of Mexico.
Liability insurance must be purchased separately through a licensed Mexican insurance company. To be covered by this policy, any suit must be brought in the United States. The insurance provided by the endorsement is excess over the Mexican insurance and other collectible insurance.
6. CA 20 54—Employee
Hired Autos
Should an employee hire an auto in his/her own name as an individual to perform business-related duties and activities for his/her employer, there would be liability coverage via this endorsement if the hire was done with the permission and approval of the employer.
7. CA 20 55—Fellow
Employee Coverage
If an employer wishes to delete the fellow employee exclusion for all employees from the commercial auto coverage form, this endorsement may be purchased.
8. CA 20 56—Fellow
Employee Exclusions For Designated Employees/Positions
If an employer wishes to delete the fellow employee exclusion for specific employees or specific positions only from the commercial auto coverage form, this endorsement may be purchased.
The Insurance Services Office (ISO) advisory CA DS 09–Garage Declarations has ten different items or sections. However, it is only advisory in nature and each insurance company develops its own declarations. The information below follows the ISO advisory form. Forms that various insurance companies develop, and use are probably quite similar to it, but variations are likely, especially if a given company targets different garage and dealer market segments.
General Information
This section identifies and provides basic information about the named insured and other general information, such as:
Note: Two endorsements are listed in this section but there are spaces for more:
Schedule Of Coverages
And Covered Autos
This section describes the coverages provided and the autos covered. They apply to every covered auto unless modified elsewhere.
If coverage is desired, one or more symbols must be placed in the space provided next to the coverage and a value indicated in the spaces provided.
When liability coverage is provided, two limits of insurance are required. One is per accident and the other is an aggregate limit. One is for auto coverage. The other is for other than auto coverage.
Personal Injury Protection coverage requires entry of a deductible, but the limit is part of the endorsement.
Medical Payments coverage requires a limit of insurance.
Note: Medical payments coverage is provided only when CA 25 05–Garage Locations And Operations Medical Payments Coverage and/or CA 99 03–Auto Medical Payments Coverage is also attached.
Uninsured and underinsured motorists coverages require that limits of insurance be entered.
Garagekeepers coverage symbols and premium are in this item but the values and deductibles are entered in Item 6.
Physical damage coverage requires entry of a deductible for each coverage, but an additional entry is needed in Item 7 for all Dealers Autos.
The symbols on the declarations are:
21–Any Auto
22–Owned Autos Only
23–Owned Private Passenger Autos Only
24–Owned Autos Other Than Private Passenger Autos Only
25–Owned Autos Subject To No-Fault
26–Owned Autos Subject To A Compulsory Uninsured Motorists Law
27–Specifically Described Autos
28–Hired Autos Only
29–Non-Owned Autos Used In Your Garage Business
30-Autos Left With You for Service, Repair, Storage or Safekeeping
31–Dealers’ Autos (Physical Damage Coverages)
Locations Where You
Conduct Garage Operations
Beginning with the named insured's main business location, the location number and address of each location where garage operations are conducted is entered in the spaces provided. A separate endorsement must be used if there are more than three locations.
Liability
Coverage–Premiums
This section contains the rating information for the auto dealership.
The total number of Class 1 regular employees, Class 1 all other employees, Class II non-employees under age 25, and Class II non-employees age 25 and over must be entered by location. These are converted to rating units based on Rule 49 in the ISO Commercial Lines Manual, Division One Automobile.
The premium is then developed and entered by location for Liability Premium and Personal Injury Protection. The premiums are added together for a total.
The definition of Class I regular operator is any employee furnished with an auto or whose main duty is to operate an auto. Active proprietors, partners, officers and salespersons, as well as general and service managers, are also included.
Class I all other employees are any employees not defined as Class I regular operators.
Employees who work 20 or more hours a week are considered one rating unit and those who work less are considered ½ rating unit each.
Class II non-employees are proprietors, partners or officers considered inactive but who are furnished with autos. It also includes their relatives and also the relatives of any class I employee.
Liability Coverage For
Your Customers
Coverage for customers is limited, even customers driving a covered vehicle with the named insured’s permission. The limitation is removed when the box is checked, and the customer becomes an insured when driving the dealership's vehicles. This is subject to an additional premium charge.
Garagekeepers Coverage
And Premiums
Each location with Garagekeepers Coverage is entered in this item. Coverages at different locations can be different but all vehicles at a particular location must have the same coverages. The three options available are Comprehensive, Specified Causes Of Loss, and Collision. Selecting only one is acceptable. The coverages usually selected are Comprehensive and Collision. A limit of insurance and a deductible must be entered at the location for the coverage selected.
There are two different deductible options under Comprehensive and Specified Causes Of Loss coverages. The deductible can apply only to Theft Or Mischief Or Vandalism or it can apply to all perils. There is a per-auto deductible and also a maximum deductible for a single occurrence.
Collision coverage has only a single per-auto deductible.
Note: This is legal liability coverage unless one of the direct coverage options is selected. The options available apply on a primary or an excess basis. The primary option is more expensive because it responds to losses before any other available source of coverage. The excess option keeps coverage on a legal liability basis for the primary coverage but does not impose legal liability restrictions on an excess basis.
Physical Damage
Coverage–Types Of Covered Autos And Interests In These Autos–Premiums–Reporting
Or Non-Reporting Basis
This item applies only to dealers' autos. Coverage is selected by placing an “x” in the grid by the coverage, the type of auto, and the interests to be covered.
A limit of insurance and a deductible must be entered at the location if Comprehensive or Specified Causes Of Loss coverage is selected. There are two different deductible options. The deductible can apply to only Theft Or Mischief Or Vandalism or it can apply to all perils. There is a per-auto deductible and maximum deductible for a single occurrence.
Collision Coverage is not location-specific but covers all vehicles at all locations. The collision deductible is per vehicle and is not subject to a maximum. This section also has a provision for a limit at locations where the named insured stores covered autos not in Item Three. A separate limit applies to property in transit.
The Premium Basis can be monthly or quarterly and reports must be provided according to the requirements indicated. Coverage can also be on a non-reporting basis subject to the stated limit of insurance indicated.
The Loss Payee section indicates the entity or entities that have a financial interest in the covered autos in addition to the named insured.
Medical Payments
Coverage
If Medical Payments Coverage is indicated in Item Two, this section must be completed to indicate if it applies to Auto Liability, Premises Liability, or both. The premium charge is entered in the spaces provided to indicate the coverage that applies.
Note: It is
important to remember to attach the appropriate coverage form if making an
entry for this coverage.
CA 99 03–Auto Medical Payments Coverage and/or CA 25 05–Garage Locations And
Operations Medical Payments Coverage are the coverage forms available.
Schedule Of Covered
Autos Which Are Furnished To Someone Other Than A Class I Or Class II Operator
Or Which Are Insured On A Specified Car Basis
This section is used to indicate the covered auto, its principal garaging location, classification information for rating purposes, and the coverages, limits, deductibles and premiums that apply. Space is available to enter three vehicles. A schedule or endorsement is used for additional autos.
Note: This section is often left blank because the coverage form usually covers most autos.
Liability Premium For
Pick Up And Delivery Of Autos–Non-Franchised Dealers Only
This section is completed only for non-franchised dealers that pick up and deliver autos beyond 50 miles.
The Insurance Services Office (ISO) Garage Coverage Form combines premises liability, products and completed operations liability with auto coverages. However, the premises liability coverage provided is not as broad as that of the ISO Commercial General Liability Coverage Form. Some of the coverages in the Commercial General Liability Coverage Form not in the Garage Coverage Form are:
Adding CA 25 14–Broadened Coverage–Garages to the Garage Coverage Form closes the gap between it and the Commercial General Liability Coverage Form and is actually slightly broader in some respects. This endorsement applies only to garage activities and not to liability involving ownership, maintenance or use of any covered vehicles.
This analysis is based
the 03/06 edition of this coverage form. Changes from the previous edition
are in bold print.
This section states that the coverages this endorsement provides apply only to garage operations, not including ownership, maintenance or use of covered autos, that the provisions of the Garage Coverage Form apply unless this endorsement modifies any of them, and is effective on the policy inception date, unless a different date is indicated. The Named Insured, Endorsement Effective Date (if different than the policy inception date), and the Authorized Representative Countersignature information are indicated in the spaces provided.
Note: This section is rearranged slightly from the previous edition but is essentially unchanged.
Two coverages indicated in this section must have limits of insurance entered in the spaces provided:
Note: This limit is $50,000 for any one fire unless a different limit is indicated.
This section also has a space to indicate the premium for this endorsement.
A. Coverage
The insurance company pays amounts the insured is legally obligated to pay as damages because of personal and advertising injury caused by offenses committed in the coverage territory and during the policy period that arise out of its garage business.
Note: There is no personal or advertising injury liability coverage for any offense related to non-business or personal activities.
Example: Jim Smith files a claim under his garage coverage form for his business, Epitome Garage. The claim is for a personal injury lawsuit. Jim’s neighbor is suing him, claiming that Jim defamed him during a hot argument at a local school board meeting. The insurance company tells Jim that there is no coverage because the incident had nothing to do with Epitome Garage. |
The insurance company has both the right and the duty to defend any insured against suits requesting such damages covered by this insurance. It can investigate and settle claims and suits as it sees fit but its obligations end when the Personal And Advertising Injury Limit Of Insurance is exhausted by payment of judgments or settlements.
1. Who Is An Insured
This section has three categories of insureds.
a. The named insured and his or her spouse
b. The named insured's partners and their spouses if the business is a partnership, and members and their spouses if the business is a limited liability company.
Note: None of these parties is an insured for personal and advertising injury resulting from operations of other partnerships.
c. The named insured's employees, executive officers, directors and stockholders.
Note: Each of these parties is an insured only while performing activities within the scope of their duties as such.
2. Coverage
Extensions–Supplementary Payments
The insurance company pays on behalf of the insured:
a. Expenses it incurs in the course of handling a claim
b. Costs of bonds to release attachments. However, the attachment must relate to the suit being defended and the costs are limited to the amount of the bond equal to or less than the personal and advertising injury limit of insurance.
Example: The court demands a $1,500,000 bond before releasing the attachments against Gary's Garage but the Personal And Advertising Injury Limit Of Insurance is only $500,000. Tightwad Mutual Insurance Company pays only the cost of a $500,000 bond and Gary must handle the rest on his own. |
c. Reasonable expenses the insured incurs when the company requests. This includes up to $250 per day for time off from work.
d. Costs taxed against the insured in suits against an insured that the company defends
e. Interest on the total amount of a judgment that accrues after the judgment is entered in suits against an insured the insurance company defends.
Note: The company's duty to pay interest ends when it pays, offers to pay, or deposits the part of the judgment within the Personal And Advertising Injury Limit Of Insurance with the court.
Example: A judgment for $3,000,000 is entered against Gary's Garage but the Personal And Advertising Injury Limit Of Insurance is only $500,000. Gary wants to appeal but Tightwad Mutual wants the case to end. It deposits $500,000 with the court to hold, ending its responsibility to pay interest as well as to provide any further defense. Note: In some cases, the court may refuse to accept the payment and require the company to continue defending the insured. |
Note: The previous
edition opened the Coverage Extensions–Supplementary Payments section stating
that, in addition to the Personal And Advertising Injury Limit Of Insurance,
the insurance company will pay these items for the insured. The current edition
does not open this section with this language. However, at the end of the
section, it states that these payments will not reduce the Personal And
Advertising Injury Limit Of Insurance.
B. Exclusions
1. There is no coverage for:
a. Personal and advertising injury:
(1) That the named insured assumed in a contract or agreement except for liability for damages that exists without a contract or agreement
Example: A celebrity endorses the named insured’s products, subject to a written agreement stating that the named insured will not slander or libel the celebrity. This agreement does not trigger the exclusion since liability exists without the written agreement. |
(2) Caused or directed by the insured knowing that it violates the rights of others and may cause personal and advertising injury
Example: Billy Joe loved Mary, but she left him for Paul. At his auto dealership, Billy Joe enjoys telling anyone who will listen about his previous relationship with her in order to damage her reputation. Word of this soon gets back to Mary, who immediately files a lawsuit. This coverage form insuring "Billy Joe's Family Motors" does not respond to this claim. |
(3) That arises out of the insured's spoken or written publication of written material with knowledge that it was false
Example: Continuing the example above, Billy Joe decides to include his stories about Mary in his newsletter that he distributes to his employees and customers. Once again, Mary files a lawsuit and, once again, this coverage form does not respond. |
(4) That arises out of spoken or written publication of material that took place before this insurance's effective date
(5) Arising out of criminal acts any insured commits or directs
(6) Arising out of breach of contract other than the named insured using ideas of others under an implied contract in its advertising campaign
Example: Scenario One–Scott has a great advertising idea for his favorite car dealership. He explains it and the dealership seems excited about it. The dealership provides a contract that Scott signs that gives his idea to the dealership with the promise that he will star in the commercial if the idea was used. At a later date, the dealership informs him that it decided not to pursue his idea. Scott later noticed a commercial that looked almost exactly like the one he had proposed and sued for the terms of the contract. Coverage was denied because the situation involved a breach of contract. |
Example: Scenario Two–Scott has a great advertising idea for his favorite car dealership. He wrote the company and provided detailed advertising information and related ideas but never received a response. Scott later noticed a commercial that looked almost exactly like the one he had proposed, and he sued. In this case, the insurance company may have to provide a legal defense because any contract was merely implied, not actual. |
(7) Arising out of goods, products or services not conforming to the quality or performance indicated in the named insured's advertisement
(8) Arising out of the incorrect price of goods, products or services in the named insured's advertisement
(9) Arising out of an
insured's hosted, owned or controlled electronic chatroom or bulletin board
Example: Party Auto Sales’ Website included a customer forum. A competitor sued Party Auto’s owner, alleging slurs that appeared in several forum topics. This coverage does not apply because the forum belongs to Party Auto. |
(10) Arising out of
deceptive Internet practices involving use of another party's name in emails,
domains, intellectual property, or similar items to mislead that party’s
potential customers
(11) Arising out of
unauthorized use of another party's intellectual property rights including, but
limited to, copyright, patent, trademark or trade secret infringement. However,
coverage applies if the infringement of copyright, trade dress or slogan was
part of the named insured’s advertisement.
((12) Arising in any
way from war, whether declared or not, civil war or any warlike act by military
forces by any government or other authority that uses military personnel or
other agents. This also includes acts of insurrection, rebellion, revolution,
usurped power or actions taken by any party against these.
(13) To persons and their family members arising out of employment-related practices such as refusal to employ, termination of employment, coercion, evaluations, demotions, discipline, harassment, humiliation, discrimination, reassignment and similar actions directed against a particular individual. There is no coverage for the direct action or for any procedures, policies, actions or omission that allegedly caused the action.
Example: The procedure manual at Phillips Auto World stated that harassment was not permitted on the premises or at any company function. However, some of the "fun" at the company picnic included a few scenarios that could be interpreted as harassment. The male employees tired of the "male-bashing" and asked Human Resources to stop it but were informed that it was “just fun.” The jokes soon spread into the workplace and caused a group to leave the company, after which they and their spouses sued the company for emotional distress. Phillips Auto sought coverage, but the insurance company denied the claim. |
(14) Arising in any way out of any act or omission that violates or allegedly violates the Telephone
Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), including its amendments or additions, the
CAN-SPAM Act of 2003, including its amendments or additions, or any other
statute, ordinance or regulation prohibiting or limiting the sending,
transmitting, communicating or distributing of material or information.
(15) Arising out of pollutants at any time. This includes threatened, alleged or actual release of any pollutant at any time.
b. Loss, cost or expense that arises out any requirement that any insured or others address and respond in any way to the effects of pollutants or claims or suits by government entities to address and respond in any way to the effects of pollutants
2. An exclusion for bodily injury arising out of personal and advertising injury is added to Paragraph B. Exclusions–Section II–Liability Coverage.
Note: This exclusion is added in order to eliminate duplicate coverage. Personal and advertising injury coverage includes any related bodily injury. As a result, all bodily injury due to personal and advertising injury is excluded under Section II–Liability Coverage.
C. Personal And
Advertising Injury Limit Of Insurance
This section is added to the Aggregate Limit Of Insurance–Garage Operations–Other Than Covered Autos Provision in Section II–Liability Coverage because this coverage is separate from that provided in the Garage Coverage Form.
The most the insurance company pays for the total of all damages because of personal and advertising injury to any one person or entity is the limit of insurance indicated on this endorsement schedule. This is subject to the Aggregate Limit Of Insurance–Garage Operations–Other Than Covered Autos and is regardless of the number of insureds, claims made, or suits brought.
Note: The Each Accident Limit Of Insurance–Garage Operations–Other Than Covered Autos–Liability Coverages does not apply to damages the insurance company pays because of personal and advertising injury.
Example: Willy has had a rough year. A tire being installed on a truck exploded and injured a friend who was visiting him, resulting in a $250,000 payment. Then a customer was mugged in the dealership parking lot after hours. She sued and was awarded $200,000 for her injuries. Now, Fred’s Towing is suing him for defamation. Fred allegedly lost his city-towing contract worth $200,000 shortly after a city councilman overheard Willy comment that he wouldn't trust a “weasel” like Fred to tow his customers' cars. Willy has a Garage Coverage Form with Broadened Coverage–Garages. The Garage Coverage Form limit of insurance is $500,000 and the aggregate limit is also $500,000. The limit of insurance for personal and advertising injury is also $500,000. Willy’s hard times are likely to continue because his aggregate limit has been depleted by the two prior claims and only $50,000 remains in the aggregate to handle the personal injury lawsuit. |
D. Additional
Definitions
Two new definitions are added. The other definitions in the Garage Coverage Form also apply to this endorsement.
1. Personal and advertising injury includes all of the following plus any bodily injury caused by or resulting from any of these injuries:
a. False arrest, detention or imprisonment.
Note: These may appear to be police powers but any of these may be alleged if an individual is not permitted to go where he or she wishes. This is particularly important when dealing with suspected shoplifters. A security officer or even a sales manager asking someone to accompany him to another part of the building can be considered false arrest since there are witnesses to the action and such actions may be accompanied by "loss of face.”
a. False arrest, detention or imprisonment involves physically restraining people.
Note: This is particularly important when dealing with suspected shoplifters. A security officer asking someone to accompany him can be considered false arrest since there are witnesses to the action and such actions may be accompanied by "loss of face.”
b. Malicious prosecution is difficult to define and is usually determined in a legal proceeding.
Note: One party may believe it is simply exercising its rights while another believes it is being harassed because of that party doing so.
Example: Francesca’s Used Cars is located in a commercial area, right next to “High on the Hill Adult Novelties.” Hill’s customers are known to try out new paraphernalia in Francesca’s parking lot and this upsets her patrons. She regularly calls the police to report these incidents. High on the Hill sues Francesca for malicious prosecution, alleging that she is trying to ruin its reputation and take over its location. |
c. Invasion of the rights of tenants by or on behalf of the owner, landlord or lessor, through wrongful eviction, wrongful entry into, or other invasions of a person’s right of private occupancy of space rented or leased from the insured.
d. Slandering or libeling a person or group. This also includes disparaging remarks concerning goods, products or services that belong to or are sold or manufactured by the person or group.
e. Violation of an individual’s right to privacy through any oral or written publication
f. Misappropriation of another party's advertising ideas to use in the named insured’s advertisements
g. Any use or infringement of another party’s slogans, copyrights and trade dress in the named insured’s advertisement done without permission
2. Advertisement is any published or broadcast notice that goes out to specific market segments or the public designed to attract customers and/or supporters to the named insured’s products, goods or services. It also applies to e-mail and Internet activities. With respect to websites, the term applies only to the parts of it dedicated to marketing an insured’s product or service.
The insurance company pays amounts the insured is legally obligated to pay as damages because of bodily injury and property damage that arises out of giving or serving alcoholic beverages at events that take place in conjunction with the named insured's garage business.
Note: This coverage applies only if the named insured is not involved in any way with the liquor business.
Example: Joey is a mechanic in the service department at Phoenix Pre-Owned Motors. He just turned 21. Phoenix’s repair crew decides to have a party for him in the service bays after hours. Everyone leaves at midnight but Joey, unaccustomed to alcohol, ran a stoplight, struck another auto, and caused injuries. Since Joey had minimum limits on his personal auto policy, Phoenix was sued based on allegations that it contributed to the accident that caused the loss. This coverage may apply in this situation. |
Note: Insured's
engaged in the liquor business can insure their exposures under one of two ISO
coverage forms.
CG 00 33–Liquor Liability Coverage Form provides coverage on an occurrence
basis. CG 00 34–Liquor Liability Coverage Form provides coverage on a
claims-made basis.
This coverage insures property damage caused by fire to premises the named insured either rents or temporarily occupies with the owner's permission. It is excess over all other collectible property insurance available to the insured, including deductibles that apply to such other insurance.
As a result, exclusions 3 through 17 in the Garage Coverage Form do not apply to this coverage. The $50,000 limit of insurance is subject to the Aggregate Limit Of Insurance–Other Than Auto and is the most paid for all property damage caused by or resulting from any one fire. This limit can be increased.
This coverage broadens the definition of bodily injury. In addition to the definition in the coverage form, injury that results from providing or not providing professional health care or medical services, furnishing food or drink in conjunction with such professional health care or medical services, or furnishing medical, dental or surgical supplies or appliances, or drugs is also considered bodily injury.
An important exclusion is added. Any business or occupation engaged in providing services included in the new definition of bodily injury are not covered.
Note: The ISO Garage Coverage Form insures only garage operations. Situations occasionally arise where assistance is rendered that is not garage related and coverage should be provided. This is the case with incidental medical malpractice liability coverage. In order for coverage to apply for a particular insured, it cannot be in the business or occupation of providing any of these medical services. Note that the term is “insured,” not “named insured.” A member of the medical community may own an auto dealership. In addition, a spouse of a partner or member may be in the medical profession. Some employees may have health care degrees and are moonlighting to earn extra dollars.
Example: The young son of a family in the waiting room of the dealership is crying because he has a headache. A kind employee offers the child an aspirin. The child subsequently develops Reyes Syndrome, which has been linked to aspirin use in children. The parents sue the auto dealership for supplying the drug when the bottle clearly warned not to dispense to children under the age of 12. This coverage may apply to this situation. |
This section changes Liability Coverage by replacing the Watercraft Or Aircraft Exclusion. The exclusion is restated to indicate that coverage does not apply to any aircraft or watercraft. However, the part of the exclusion that applies to watercraft does not apply to watercraft that the named insured neither owns nor charges to transport persons or property. In addition, the exclusion does not apply to watercraft out of the water and on shore at the premises of the named insured's garage operation.
Note: This coverage does not apply at all if other insurance that covers such damages is in force.
This section changes Liability Coverage by adding the following to Who Is An Insured. If the named insured is a partnership, the spouses of partners are insureds but only with respect to conduct of the garage operations.
This section extends coverage to newly acquired garage businesses for a period of 90 days by modifying the definition of insured to also include garage businesses the named insured forms or acquires or over which it maintains ownership or majority interest. The definition of insured does not include:
This section changes and adds to the Policy Period, Coverage Territory Condition in the Garage Coverage Form.
The insurance company
covers bodily injury, property damage or personal and advertising injury
occurring within the coverage territory during the policy period indicated on
the declarations. With respect to this endorsement only, the coverage territory
is any place in the world if an insured permanently residing in the coverage
territory causes the injury or damage while the insured is temporarily elsewhere,
or a personal and advertising injury offense takes place through electronic
communication such as the Internet.
Note: The original suit for damages from such injury or damage must be brought in the coverage territory. However, this coverage does not apply to any work the named insured performed.